3 ms·
They realized a bit late. Europe razed her forests. Maybe they can track their trees because they only have so many. To compare: CA is about twice as big as the
by renewiltord 7y ago
They realized a bit late. Europe razed her forests. Maybe they can track their trees because they only have so many. To compare: CA is about twice as big as the UK and Californians own more forests as individuals than the UK has in total. Four times as much area in California is forest as in the UK in total.
They owe the rest of the Earth a terrible debt.
- avianlyric 7y agoBefore we go too far with the UK bashing. It’s worth noting that the UK’s population is ~66 million. California is ~44 million. California population density is ~251 people/sq mile. UK population density is ~727 people/sq mile. So the UK has almost 3x the population density, the UK simply doesn’t have oodles of unused space like the US. So a significantly reduced number of trees and forests isn’t much of a surprise.
- renewiltord 7y agoIndeed, but more people isn't good for its own sake. Lest we forget, California produces almost as much in its economy as the UK does with 2/3rds the people. We are more forested, we are more people-efficient, we are just as power-efficient, our energy comes form just as good sources. They need to step up. Our conditions here will not last forever and it is time for them to reforest, and pay the debt they owe the Earth.
- avianlyric 7y agoIf feel like you’re arrogantly ignoring the fact that California is part of the much larger US economy, and all the benefits that entails. And that despite the so called “good power sources” California still emits almost double the Co2 per capita than the UK (CA ~10 ton / capita; ~6 ton / capita; for 2017). You’re also forgetting that most of the UKs deforestation periods occurred during World Wars I & II, so the US also benefited significantly from this deforestation. The UK has also done a significant amount of _re_forestation. Increasing forest coverage from a low of 9% to 38% today[1]. So before you march around telling people to “step up” perhaps consider doing a little research, and examine your own impacts on the world. Don’t just belittle others. [1]: https://www.ies-uk.org.uk/deforestation.php https://www.ies-uk.org.uk/deforestation.php
- renewiltord 7y agoI'm carbon negative. I'm probably at the 0.01% in this world. Europe has led the world down a dark path and she needs to heal the wounds she has given Mother Earth. Per-capita isn't as useful a measure as carbon intensity (/km^2) or carbon efficiency (/dollar). At this point, if the UK stopped doing its slow-motion destruction of the planet and started creating more with less, it can still redeem itself for the harm it's done all of humanity present and future.
- avianlyric 7y ago> I'm carbon negative. I'm probably at the 0.01% in this world. I’m sure the UK has plenty of carbon negative people too, so you being carbon negative is nothing to write home about, and quite frankly irrelevant to your argument. > Europe has led the world down a dark path Right so Europe has been the worlds primary superpower for the last 50 years, not the US. And the US hasn’t been an independent nation for almost 300 years. I clearly missed that memo. > Per-capita isn't as useful a measure as carbon intensity (/km^2) or carbon efficiency (/dollar). I also don’t see the relevance of either carbon intensity or carbon efficiency. Carbon intensity just shows that CA is a large land mass, and carbon efficiency, well the UK is more “carbon efficient” at 139kg/$ compared to CA’s 154kg/$, so the UK is 10% more efficient (2017 figures, GDP/Co2). > At this point, if the UK stopped doing its slow-motion destruction of the planet and started creating more with less, it can still redeem itself for the harm it's done all of humanity present and future. Looking at the stats, it appears it’s CA that has some catching up todo. Not the UK.
- renewiltord 7y agoThat's the trick. Present value is only so much of the picture. If I dump hecka carbon in for 350 years and then suddenly go clean for one year, I still have to account for my 350 years. The UK has a lot of sins she has to clean up after. No lectures from her till she cleans up her mess. "Yeah, I didn't kill anyone today." doesn't get you off the murder charge.
- 7y ago
- alimw 7y agoWell you're right, we just need to get rid of half the people then we can start working on that. What do you suggest we do with them?
- renewiltord 7y agoYou can't kill people. I simply propose that we move costs back on to consumers. So, like I do, make everyone pay for the carbon they produce. Stagger it so that they overpay by some amount and let the countries that haven't yet polluted underpay. It'll be a small factor, some 10x or so. For my life that'll be around $4k extra in costs per year. If someone already lives a very carbon neutral lifestyle then it'll be much less. If they fly a lot more it'll be a lot more.
- asdff 7y agoEngland used to be like 95% under the plow to feed itself in the middle ages. As agricultural techniques improved, it became possible to have land set aside for forests while feeding the population. This land use rate isn't an English problem, it is an entire agrarian world problem. Blame the farming cultures that slaughtered the pastoralists 10,000 years ago if you want to finger point. It's kind of cherry picking that you singled out CA and ignore the wastes of forests felled from the Atlantic to the rockies. We haven't done much better. It wasn't even a century ago that we had dust bowls sweeping across the great plains from so much overfarming. 100 years ago the total population of CA was 1/6 of greater London, you can't compare the UK to CA much better than an apple to an orange.
- renewiltord 7y agoAnd now that agricultural techniques are better. It's time for the UK to give back to the Earth. Their endless whinging about the developing world logging their forests stands as hollow if they will not undo the untold amounts of harm they have done the Earth. I picked California because I live here and because we're good at this - for all of our faults.
- avianlyric 7y ago> I picked California because I live here and because we're good at this Source please
- renewiltord 7y agoMy lease document? Probably not going to share a source for how I live here.
- baud147258 7y agoI think it was asking about 'because we're good at this', not whether or not you live in CA
- asdff 7y ago