4 ms·
> One option that seems very reasonable to me would be to introduce a third option: ... Dependent Contractor (new gig economy group). Yeah that's my preferred
by jedberg 7y ago
> One option that seems very reasonable to me would be to introduce a third option: ... Dependent Contractor (new gig economy group).
Yeah that's my preferred option too if we must keep the system, but it has a lot of the same problems.
Small orgs don't have the resources to hire lawyers to figure out if they can do 1099 or "new thing", and so it will still have the same chilling effect on 1099 work.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoThere should be a chilling effect on some types of employment arrangements where avoidance of worker protections and ancillary compensation was occurring.
- jedberg 7y agoSure but don't do it by mandating what kind of contracts people can enter into. Do it by supporting social services so that they don't have to accept bad contracts.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoI think we are destined to agree to disagree. Evidence has shown that people will be economically coerced into contracts, or are not educated enough to understand the consequences of the contract (gig drivers not knowing how little they're making) and the social services currently do not exist to protect them, nor are they likely to be spun up. Sure, journalists get the short end of the stick, as well as gig workers who don't need the income and just want to do it part time. Edge cases are unfortunate.
- jedberg 7y ago> and the social services currently do not exist to protect them Exactly. Fix that problem instead.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoSo everyone should suffer until those exist because businesses are permitted to take advantage of them? I'm spending low six figures annually on political donations to those who support universal healthcare. I still support shims like this until it gets here. Sorry I'm not fixing it fast enough for you.
- jedberg 7y agoNo of course not. But AB5 was not the right shim.
- ralph84 7y agoThank you for your service, low-six-figure-man
- mycall 7y agoThanks for putting money on this important table.
- CodeWriter23 7y agoAB 5 has everyone suffering. Consider this for a moment, Silicon Valley: the Tiger Teams you contract to pull your fat out of the fire when your infrastructure starts melting down, well you can’t hire them under AB 5 if they are California-based. Persons (which includes Corporations) cannot be independently contracted to produce your main line of business. And when your business is Tech and so it theirs...
- kansface 7y ago> So everyone should suffer until those exist because businesses are permitted to take advantage of them? That's exactly the point. Everyone wasn't suffering and in dire need of rescue by the state of California. Now, we have a law that hasn't helped the people it was supposed to help and has put quite a few legitimate businesses out of work. Good intentions or not, AB 5 is worse than the old status quo.
- manigandham 7y agoThings are now actually worse than before. Therefore reversing this particular course of action is still an improvement over today.
- manigandham 7y agoWorkers should be able to choose for themselves. There's a non-trivial amount of rideshare drivers who already have full-time commitments (jobs, school, etc) and want extra income. They are not looking for another job and just want to maximize flexible revenue.
- droopyEyelids 7y agoSo the workers will be responsible for understanding the legal decisions and implications?
- manigandham 7y agoThat's how life works, yes. In what scenario are you not responsible at all for understanding the legal situation you put yourself in?
- nick_kline 7y agoHow about the government provides health insurance and other social service benefits (like employment), then it wouldn't be part of the cost those businesses try to get away from paying? There are also thousands of people every year who do gig jobs and then get significantly hurt financially when they fall through a job benefit crack (health insurance etc) when they lose a job.
- manigandham 7y agoSure, healthcare separated from employment would be a fantastic development. Doesn't change my point that people should be able to make their own choices.
- malandrew 7y agoFurthermore, we should be voting for representatives that simplify laws so more people can understand the legal situations they are exposed to.
- mapgrep 7y ago> Small orgs don't have the resources to hire lawyers to figure out if they can do 1099 or "new thing" Well there you have it. If small orgs don’t generally have the legal capability to correctly classify employees among three whole choices, then many probably also can’t choose well between two. AB5 helped them make the correct choice, and good thing, given what you’ve said here, but maybe even two choices is too many. Maybe there should be no 1099.