9 ms·
I feel bad for the drivers that are being taken advantage of, but AB5 was a terribly written law with good intentions (aren't they all?). The big companies the
by jedberg 7y ago
I feel bad for the drivers that are being taken advantage of, but AB5 was a terribly written law with good intentions (aren't they all?).
The big companies they were obviously targeting have the resources to get around it, but in the meantime it killed independent journalism in the state, as an example.
I know a few journalists who can no longer work in CA, despite liking the system they had. The publications won't touch them for fear of violating AB5.
There are lots of other folks in CA who like being contractors who are finding it much harder now, because the people hiring them are afraid of running afoul of AB5 but also can't afford to hire them as employees.
They really need to scrap AB5 and rewrite it, now that they've seen how much it missed the mark.
AB5 has had a chilling effect on 1099 work in California.
- cjlars 7y agoRegulators created the 1099 / W-2 distinction for a reason. There are probably good reasons to adjust the rules to take into account the so called gig economy, but making 1099 nearly illegal is not a net regulatory improvement when considering all the collateral damage. One option that seems very reasonable to me would be to introduce a third option: Employee (W-2), Independent Contractor (1099), Dependent Contractor (new gig economy group).
- elliekelly 7y agoWhat would be the distinction between "employee" and "dependent contractor"? Unemployment benefits? Health insurance? Minimum wage?
- jedberg 7y agoI suspect dependent contractor and hourly worker would effectively merge. Both would get benefits if they work enough hours. The difference would be whether the boss picks the work hours or you do.
- cjlars 7y agoThe big issues would be when worker starts and ends, self direction in terms of how they do the job (and associated liability), worker's comp, unemployment insurance, and tools / vehicles (I.e. should Uber be required to pay ~50 cents per mile to it's drivers. W-2 says yes, 1099 says no).
- RangerScience 7y ago"Dependent contractor" feels exceptionally well-named. Props to you!
- jedberg 7y ago> One option that seems very reasonable to me would be to introduce a third option: ... Dependent Contractor (new gig economy group). Yeah that's my preferred option too if we must keep the system, but it has a lot of the same problems. Small orgs don't have the resources to hire lawyers to figure out if they can do 1099 or "new thing", and so it will still have the same chilling effect on 1099 work.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoThere should be a chilling effect on some types of employment arrangements where avoidance of worker protections and ancillary compensation was occurring.
- jedberg 7y agoSure but don't do it by mandating what kind of contracts people can enter into. Do it by supporting social services so that they don't have to accept bad contracts.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoI think we are destined to agree to disagree. Evidence has shown that people will be economically coerced into contracts, or are not educated enough to understand the consequences of the contract (gig drivers not knowing how little they're making) and the social services currently do not exist to protect them, nor are they likely to be spun up. Sure, journalists get the short end of the stick, as well as gig workers who don't need the income and just want to do it part time. Edge cases are unfortunate.
- jedberg 7y ago> and the social services currently do not exist to protect them Exactly. Fix that problem instead.
- toomuchtodo 7y ago
- AaronFriel 7y agoRepeated below but this comment seems more pertinent: Can the California state legislature create a new federal class of worker? I keep seeing this in threads, but I don't understand the rationale. The United States Federal Government recognizes W-2 and 1099 filings, the State of California cannot invent a new Federal filing status or amend the United States Code, correct?
- jedberg 7y agoNo but they can create a new state classification and then make the employer do a 1099 for that person federally but treat them differently under state law.
- cjlars 7y agoI believe you're correct that federal intervention would be the best outcome here.
- jeffdavis 7y agoI disagree. The federal distinction is mainly for federal taxes. The state is not just concerned with taxes, it's also concerned with other labor laws, so it may need to distinguish differently.
- cjlars 7y agoI mean, you would need both right? You want consistent tax treatment the whole way through and obviously state worker protections would be the main thing. What am I missing?
- jeffdavis 7y agoI don't see why that's helpful. W2 employees would be treated the same as now. 1099 employees would be treated the same from a federal standpoint, but separated into two groups from a state standpoint.
- mycall 7y agoIf we are talking matrices, should there be an Independent Employee? Somehow I see this as another loophole.
- jedberg 7y agoI see Independent Employee as code for hourly worker, and I see hourly worker and dependent contractors being basically the same, other than who chooses what hours one works.
- Izkata 7y agoI see it more as a tree: Work for money -|-- employee |-- contractor -|--- independent | \--- dependent | \-- youtube ad revenue / patreon / other?
- vadym909 7y agoWhats the difference between dependent contractor and W2? What do they get and what do they don't?
- lhorie 7y agoThat's basically what Uber has been pushing for
- walshemj 7y agoProbably as the government don't like the little guy or gal actually working as a real self employed contractor - see IR35 in the UK (oh but self employed layers that's fine )
- malandrew 7y agoIf someone works for two companies such as both Lyft and Uber are they still a dependent contractor? If you have more than one source of income that seems to be mutually exclusive with being dependent, no? What's the criteria for determining whether someone is a dependent contractor? I'm not against the idea, but it's important to have clear unambiguous criteria.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoI don't think you make a sufficient enough case that AB5 should be scraped, merely that some folks (freelance journalists) were happy with the status quo to the detriment of wide swaths of gig workers (Uber, Lyft drivers). I'll support a third worker category once gig platforms aggressively support the safety nets (universal healthcare, some sort of income protection besides unemployment) those classified workers would need. Until I see Uber and Lyft yelling as loudly for Medicare for All as Bernie Sanders, let them crumble under a torrent of damages at the hands of the court. Go for the cash reserves while they still have them.
- rtx 7y agoWhy let things crumble and not nationalize them. California can easily buy or capture them both and provide a better service. All these gig workers will become public sector employees.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoI'm not against nationalizing when necessary (PG&E), but California could probably deploy a similar digital transportation market system without absorbing the toxicity that is Uber.
- xyzzyz 7y agoJust like the Muni or BART, which is such a good service it’s driving Uber and Lyft out of business.
- r00fus 7y agoRight, because a taxi app and mass-transit are the same scale of solution.
- jedberg 7y agoThe existence of AB5 has had a chilling effect on all 1099 work in the state. That should be the argument against scraping it or at least amending it significantly. > let them crumble under a torrent of damages at the hands of the court That's the problem though. Uber/Lyft can weather the storm with their cash reserves, many of the other companies can't. So they just bow out of the system entirely because they can't afford the risk nor the lawyers to even figure out if they are at risk.
- TheChaplain 7y agoNo need to scrap it, but instead use amendments.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sieabahlpark 7y agoThat's the problem with 99% of the laws they make. They attempt to write with good intentions, but completely lack the awareness of how such a law would be enforced. In their eyes, the journalists should have been FT employees. Uber and Lyft have the capital to fight it and it's not like other states don't exist. CA isn't worth it if they can't make money here. Would really make the new carpool lot they did for LAX a waste of money.
- jedberg 7y ago> CA isn't worth it if they can't make money here. When they write laws like this they know that CA represents 10% of the population and more than 10% of the wealth of the nation. No company would pull out of CA like that and they know it.
- elliekelly 7y agoAnd CA is a regulatory leader but not usually an outlier in the long run. They might currently be the only state classifying gig workers as employees but I can guarantee other states will soon follow.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> CA is a regulatory leader but not usually an outlier in the long run. This comment was typed on a keyboard manufactured with chemicals known to the state of California to cause cancer. While sitting in a chair manufactured with chemicals known to the state of California to cause cancer. At a computer manufactured with chemicals known to the state of California to cause cancer. And the cables supplying power to that computer were also manufactures with chemicals known to the state of California to cause cancer.
- elliekelly 7y agoYes, I see those disclosures regularly even though I don't live in California. Off the top of my head I also have California to thank for leading the way on: - Puppy mill bans - Clean, smoke-free air at work and in bars & restaurants - Tanning booth restrictions for minors - Single-use plastic bag bans - Gay conversion therapy bans California was also the first state to label Roundup as a known carcinogen. Years before the landmark cancer judgment against Monsanto. So it seems Cal/EPA knows what they're talking about and is providing valuable information not just to their constituents but to the rest of the country as well.
- kryogen1c 7y ago> I feel bad for the drivers that are being taken advantage of I have no idea why people think this. You know how people stop driving? They just don't do it. There's no contract to break, there's no boss to tell. They just stop. In fact, they have to go out of their way to drive! It is entirely volunteer work, every single time. It's the same thing people used to say about Walmart destroying mom-and-pop stores, but Walmart doesn't do anything. If they build a Walmart, nothing happens until people flock to work there, and again nothing happens until people flock to shop there.
- reaperducer 7y agoIt is entirely volunteer work, every single time After so many hours of your stomach grumbling, you accept bad work involuntarily.
- kryogen1c 7y ago> you accept bad work involuntarily. Someone always says this, but its an emotional, irrational non-argument and hard to respond. Your argument is that someone unemployed and starving found a job where they could feed themselves - but its not a good enough job? What exactly is your argument?
- jedberg 7y ago> Your argument is that someone unemployed and starving found a job where they could feed themselves Ah but that's the rub. They still can't feed themselves, but it's the only job in town, and some money is better than no money. If we don't create a set of rules that prevents the behavior of places like Walmart, it allows them to create a monopoly of available jobs in an area by being the only one who can operate profitably (or can absorb a loss until all other choices are gone). At that point they can create jobs that aren't good enough, but also leave no other choice.
- kryogen1c 7y ago> They still can't feed themselves [...] some money is better than no money. I dont see how the first half changes the argument, as the second half points out. > If we don't create a set of rules that prevents the behavior of places like Walmart We have rules. Monopoly-busting is a fundamental role of the government. Corporations can accrue more power than their surrounding communities, as history has shown. Besides, other corporations oppose the actions of Walmart, keeping them in check - capitalism!
- mixmastamyk 7y agoIt also destroyed music gigs until they were partially exempted, let’s see if it is enough.
- tedivm 7y agoMusic gigs were exempted while the bill was being made. When AB5 passed it included those exemptions- at no point were music gigs every restricted.
- lyricaljoke 7y agoThe exemptions were very imperfect. Even if musicians and certain types of performers were exempted, this legislation has had an enormous effect on theater organizations, for example, especially at the semi-professional / community level. It's typical for these orgs, which have very limited budget, to hire actors and the creative team (set designers, lighting designers, sound etc.) as 1099 workers. The money is simply not there to be able to pay everybody at an hourly rate for the amount of time that's actual spent on these projects, and the outcome has been that many theater companies are unsure whether they can continue to operate at all. Unless the thinking has changed recently and my understanding is out of date, this is a situation that continues to be worrying to both theater artists and directors of theater orgs.
- mixmastamyk 7y agohttps://variety.com/2020/music/news/california-gig-economy-assembly-bill-5-ab5-musicians-1234583320/ https://variety.com/2020/music/news/california-gig-economy-a...
- tedivm 7y agoDon't forget that AB5 was a response to the California Supreme Court. The court made a ruling that would have classified a lot more people as employees, and then the legislature wanted to clarify that for businesses so they wrote AB5. The California Supreme Court ruling went into affect in January. Without AB5 things would be even more confusing now than it would have otherwise been, and the legislature is already looking at fixes to the law to deal with the other issues that have come up.
- henryfjordan 7y agoThis line of reasoning assumes that the legislature couldn't have made up a third class of worker instead of lumping everyone as either an employee or a contractor. The courts cannot write law in the same way the legislature can, and so was much more restricted in what they could order. AB5 is just unimaginative.
- AaronFriel 7y agoCan the California state legislature create a new federal class of worker? I keep seeing this in threads, but I don't understand the rationale. The United States Federal Government recognizes W-2 and 1099 filings, the State of California cannot invent a new Federal filing status or amend the United States Code, correct?
- henryfjordan 7y agoYou know, I haven't heard that argument being raised yet. That's an interesting point. I think California could have said "pay gig workers with a W-2 but you don't need to give them all the exact same benefits as employees (health insurance, 401k, disability)”. Basically I'm not sure that it matters much, but you are correct in that California cannot amend federal law.
- jedberg 7y agoIf anything you would want them to say "pay them with a 1099 but also you must follow these extra rules beyond the federal 1099 rules". If you make them W2, then there are a bunch of federal rules you have to follow that may not make sense.
- jeffbee 7y agoThe correct solution to the problem AB5 wanted to solve is single-payer universal health care.
- jedberg 7y agoThis is true. And a minimum income or UBI.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoYes, it makes no sense for an employer to have to worry about people’s problems outside of work matters. Makes everything unnecessarily complex, but it does a good job hiding costs from taxpayers and letting governments blame employers for lack of social safety nets.
- r00fus 7y agoYes, AB5 is a band-aid, but if that's all that is possible (politically speaking, it's become a third-rail) then you use the remedy you have at hand or are able to fabricate. CA may be holding out for some increase of the public safety net at the Federal level in 2021 post-election, and might be forced to move on it's own if things don't turn out as desired.
- closeparen 7y agoIt’s only a remedy if it leads to these positions continuing to exist and also adding health insurance. With no insurance and no income you are strictly less able to access healthcare.
- malandrew 7y agoPortable health insurance also fits the bill.
- ryanmarsh 7y agoAB5 was a terribly written law with good intentions (aren't they all?) I'm not convinced of that (all laws are made with good intentions) any more. In retrospect, I don't know what I ever based that belief on.
- gnopgnip 7y agoIndependent journalists can incorporate and offer services b2b, or they can be hired as employees. If the work isn't worth enough for employers to pay minimum wage and a share of taxes that is really a problem with capitalism more than this specific distinction.
- Mirioron 7y agoOr it shows how much (little) people care for the work of independent journalists.
- jedberg 7y ago> Independent journalists can incorporate and offer services b2b Not under AB5 they can't. You can't hire a corporation as a contractor if they are in the same line of business as you are. If you're a newspaper you can't hire a journalist or a "journalism company" under AB5.
- gnopgnip 7y agoUnder AB5 the business to business exemption allows independent contracts who incorporate or otherwise form a business(including sole proprietorship) to avoid the new ABC test if they meet certain criteria. Being in the same line of business affects some of the criteria, but no single factor is dispositive.
- mapgrep 7y ago> AB5 was a terribly written law with good intentions (aren't they all?). Not at all. How many bills have you read? Did you study political science? Have you not seen how you’ve personally benefited from the laws (and case law) on the books? Or could you be perhaps overgeneralizing? > it killed independent journalism in the state This seems patently false given that I read lots of independent journalism from California journalists every day. Maybe you are conflating independent journalism, the sort that exists in an organization devoted to practicing journalism that is not subordinated to the interests of another organization, with freelance journalism. (And you’d still be wrong, but at least choosing the right words. “Independent journalism” has a longstanding meaning.)
- gjs278 7y agono you’re confusing it. and you know the right answer too. don’t comment next time, nobody here appreciates your pedantry.
- bdamm 7y agoTotally agree. I had the insanity of a consultant living in Maryland, working for a company HQ'd in Washington, visiting development centers in California, and with a contract governed in California, needing to create a company so we could be 100% clear of AB5, and rehoming the renewed contract out of Washington, just so we could satisfy a bunch of HR pencil necks. What a pile of short hits.
- bsder 7y agoThe "correct" solution is that for every 40 hours of human work a company should be required to pay for a health plan and some number of hours of vacation and time off or get fined. And, if they subcontract, they are responsible for the subcontractor paying that or both get fined. People with professional degrees and a spouse who pays their healthcare. No big deal. Certify it and document it. Life goes on. Janitorial company that likes to employ cash off the books. Yeah, that's gonna get hammered. Uber and Lyft--certify it or get out.
- jedberg 7y agoSomeone drives 40 hours for Uber one week, and then goes away for two months. How much health care do they get? Do they get cash or a week of benefits? How much cash? Same as the W2 employees but prorated? Technically even full time W2 employees don't have to get health insurance or paid time off. So what if they company doesn't offer insurance or PTO to their employees. Are they off the hook? Your system sounds good but unfortunately isn't tenable. Ironically, if we had single payer healthcare that was funded by taxes, the entire thing would be moot. You'd pay into health care based on what you earned, and you'd get out the same as everyone else.
- bsder 7y ago> Someone drives 40 hours for Uber one week, and then goes away for two months. How much health care do they get? Do they get cash or a week of benefits? One week of health benefits into the common pool. I would prefer that the driver get it. I am also okay with it being used to pay for the healthcare of the indigent who show up at an emergency room (which is what the driver will present as, eventually). > Technically even full time W2 employees don't have to get health insurance Huh? Your employer doesn't have to provide it. But I'm pretty sure that people being required to carry health insurance was one of the provisions of the ACA. I have to file a form with my taxes showing coverage. Has that changed? > Ironically, if we had single payer healthcare that was funded by taxes, the entire thing would be moot. This is misdirection. That doesn't solve the fact that Uber and Lyft drivers are being paid below minimum wage. That ALSO needs to be fixed.