3 ms·
> With respect to modern rulings, I have yet to walk away finding the arguments abysmal. Windsor? I read all the opinions (the majority and all three dissents
by tialaramex 7y ago
> With respect to modern rulings, I have yet to walk away finding the arguments abysmal.
Windsor?
I read all the opinions (the majority and all three dissents) and they were all terrible law.
The majority ends up with a convoluted rationale for why the Court should even be here, since Windsor already got what she claimed relief for. A court's purpose is to serve justice, but very clearly the Supreme Court doesn't need to even take Windsor in service of justice, instead it serves a political end.
The dissents are no better. Scalia for example rightly points out what the majority are up to, and, sensing which way the wind is blowing but apparently not inclined to learn anything from that - he guesses this will be back, as it indeed was in Obergefell, but is apparently oblivious that he's doing the same exact thing he accuses them of.
There's a decision by Judge Posner on related topics which is much better law, Baskin v Bogan. Posner may or may not have an opinion about whether gay marriage is a good idea, we don't learn one way or another. But he is clear that it isn't logically consistent to say your state only marries people for the purpose of raising kids, then also have a law which says people who biologically cannot, or genetically should not have kids may get married. As a result the prohibitions on gay marriage fail. That's what I want to see in my legal decisions.
- pmiller2 7y agoI wish Posner had gotten appointed to the Supreme Court. His decisions always seem to follow an elegant logic that I find appealing.