3 ms·
At the Federal level the median US politician sometimes has the power to glass countries and that power is typically exercised every so often. They actively wor
by roenxi 7y ago
At the Federal level the median US politician sometimes has the power to glass countries and that power is typically exercised every so often. They actively work to redistribute and moderate the wealth and lives of the most materially prosperous country.
The justices are socially aware but there is a big gap between them and the professional politicians. They take substantially less advantage of opportunities to foist their human foibles on others. They are politicians, but of the nose-out-of-joint variety where their peers tend to be limbs-strewn-over-an-area types. The difference is large enough that they don't really merit the same label.
It'd be nice if the US kept them from getting more politically active. The best Supreme Court is a quiet and sleepy one.
- claudeganon 7y ago> The justices are socially aware but there is a big gap between them and the professional politicians Go read anything about Chief Justice Roberts history as a conservative activist and see if this really holds true.
- pstuart 7y agoThe impeachment trial showed that activism can occur by doing nothing.
- wl 7y agoWould you characterize the Clinton impeachment trial in the same way? What do you believe the Chief Justice should have done but didn't in either or both trials?
- pstuart 7y agoThe Clinton trial was about lying about a blowjob. He did lie, and he was a sexual predator, but I fail to see how it had anything to do with his official conduct (it was poor personal conduct but that's a different story). Trump engaged in a shakedown of another country for personal gain (including blocking money that Congress had appropriated) and then engaged in a massive coverup. I'd consider that to be a collection of crimes. Roberts did not allow witnesses to be called, and did not allow the hearings to be recorded. The GOP refused to participate in the trial at all and declared before it started that they would not even consider a guilty vote.
- wl 7y agoRehnquist characterized his role as presiding over the Clinton impeachment trial by quoting from Iolanthe (A comic opera): "I did nothing in particular, and I did it very well." My impression of Roberts presiding over the Trump impeachment trial is that he tried to emulate Rehnquist. There's plenty to criticize about the Trump trial, but I don't see how you can pin it on Roberts. It was the Senate that voted to not call witnesses, not Roberts deciding that. Since the Senate has "the sole power to try all impeachments" (US Const. Art. I, § 3, cl. 6), it's not even clear Roberts had the ability to override that decision. I'm not sure what you're talking about with things not being recorded. You can find the entire trial on YouTube.
- pstuart 7y agoI don't blame Roberts specifically for the outcome, but I was not impressed. "Doing nothing" is often doing something in absentia. I writing in haste and have already been too political in this thread (hopefully in a respectful manner). We could dissect the flaws (which I would enjoy in the proper forum with time to carve out for it), but as an independent (but "progressive") voter I found both trials to be shams. My original comment was snarky (but true), but in the end I'm not interested in arguing for the sake of "my team" or "being right", but to pursue truth wherever it may lead me.