3 ms·
I don't understand how convection can increase the time to cool down. It seems to me that the higher temperatures closer to the surface facilitated by convectio
by adrianN 7y ago
I don't understand how convection can increase the time to cool down. It seems to me that the higher temperatures closer to the surface facilitated by convection would lead to faster cooling.
- jaggederest 7y agoFaster cooling, but smoother gradients. It means that if you go down a hundred miles, it will be warmer, but the entire center of the earth will be closer to the same temperature. If you assume a solid, you assume a certain constant thermal conductivity, as Kelvin did, even though with a liquid, that's not true. Basically, he assumed that the heat was diffusing slowly, and that it couldn't go above a certain temperature at the core (i.e. not a gas or liquid), and so you had hard limits on the total reservoir of heat in the planet and could calculate a linear fit on it. It turns out the effective thermal conductivity of the center of the earth is much higher than the thermal conductivity of e.g. continental crust.
- im3w1l 7y ago> If you assume a solid, you assume a certain constant thermal conductivity, as Kelvin did, even though with a liquid, that's not true I think the liquid is a red herring here. The important thing is a that there are two layers with different properties. Would work just as well with an inner highly conductive solid.
- ufo 7y agoWIthout convection the earth as a whole takes longer to cool down but the surface layer cools faster. In an earth with a convective mantle the earth as a whole cools faster but the surface layer cools slower (because it is receiving more heat from the core). This article helped me understand that back in the day: www.blc.arizona.edu/courses/schaffer/449/England%20-%20Perrys%20Neglected%20Critique.pdf