3 ms·
There are sizable open source projects which do all coordination asynchronously. There are no synchronous meetings, even online. The military takes writing ser
by Animats 7y ago
There are sizable open source projects which do all coordination asynchronously. There are no synchronous meetings, even online.
The military takes writing seriously.[1] People write things which are acted upon by others. The reader needs to understand clearly what is intended. Especially when they are out of communication with the sender.
It's worth understanding the military five-paragraph order format.[2] Not because it's used much in civilian life, but because it's a checklist for what must be covered in an order. Note especially "Commander's Intent" and "Desired Endstate". A key point in combat orders is knowing why something is being done. Because the enemy gets a vote. If things don't go as planned, then what?
[1] http://tsg3.us/tnsg_lib/pldc_school/wobc/is_1460_materials/ch3.pdf http://tsg3.us/tnsg_lib/pldc_school/wobc/is_1460_materials/c...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_paragraph_order https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_paragraph_order
- torgian 7y agoThe army’s field manual for writing. It’s quite good and I find myself referring to it even now, after my military career.
- krebs_liebhaber 7y agoThe military has also been responsible for some rather gruesome crimes against the written word [0]: > Vanilla flavoring shall be pure or artificial vanilla in such quantities that its presence shall be organoleptically detected, but not to a pronounced degree. > Candied cherries shall be made from pitted cherries. They shall be thoroughly processed with sugars to a soluble solids content of not less than 72 percent and artificially colored with a red dye. They shall be cut to yield 1/4- to 1/2-inch (6.4 to 12.88 mm.) cherry pieces on the average. > One of the changes dictated by the Defense Department, Nunn said, shifts "the tolerance of candied cherries from 12.8 mm. to 12.7 mm. Always onward and upward." > The flavor of the finished product shall be typical of the type indicated. There shall be no off-flavors or off- odors. In case you haven't caught on, this spec is describing a fucking fruitcake. [0] https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-1985-12-25-8503290530-story.html https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-1985-12-25-850329...
- onionisafruit 7y agoThat’s funny, but it has me wondering what recipes typically look like for mass produced food.
- larrywright 7y agoHaving spent some time working fast food many years ago, it’s not far from that. Temperatures, cooking times, sizes. All precise. Much of the food comes from suppliers in a ready to use state — onions, pickles, fries, etc. I would bet that the specifications given to those suppliers are written in similar language.
- gonzo41 7y agoWhen i buy fast food I'm chasing memories of my first bites, my first time made enough of an impression that I want to come back. If you mass produce food then it makes sense to distill the exact notes on what made me spend a dollar the first time so you can have it a second. There's nothing worse than being out field and getting a spoiled ration.
- jasonpeacock 7y agoEvery time you see specs like that, imagine the situation that led to those specs. I'm bet at some point the candied cherries being used were too small (e.g. a supplier dumping their leftovers) and so they had to get specific about the requirement.
- mattkrause 7y agoNot sure I see the problem? It is very detailed, but isn't that the point of a spec? The alternative is getting/accepting a low bid where the vendor puts in a homeopathic dose of vanilla and one lousy cherry, resulting big profits for them but a deliverable that's almost entirely but not quite, unlike fruitcake. You could imagine a different system, where somebody tastes existing fruitcakes from different bakers, then picks one that seems like a good value for the money. However, there is still the problem of ensuring that the delivered product matches the sample. Moreover, it could, in theory) allow for corruption--how do you know the taster and baker aren't colluding? The US (and especially DoD) are set up to avoid that sort of "individual corruption", at the expense of much more bureaucracy. This isn't totally successful--somebody will instead lobby to reduce the maximum cherry size to 1/3 inch to exclude a competitor--but at least it's an ethos.