3 ms·
> Vegas also doesn't have a subway system, which was cited as why it spread so rapidly in NY. There's no real evidence to support the thesis that the MTA was a
by jcranmer 7y ago
> Vegas also doesn't have a subway system, which was cited as why it spread so rapidly in NY.
There's no real evidence to support the thesis that the MTA was a primary vector of spread in NYC. Granular data of infection rate by neighborhood is spotty, but the data that does exist doesn't show any clear trends towards increased infection rates nearer subway lines. And the borough with the highest infection rate is the borough with the least transit ridership, and the borough with the lowest infection rate is that with the highest transit ridership...
(Source cite: https://pedestrianobservations.com/2020/04/15/the-subway-is-probably-not-why-new-york-is-a-disaster-zone/ https://pedestrianobservations.com/2020/04/15/the-subway-is-...).
- cameldrv 7y agoI think it’s pretty clear that having a large portion of the city spend an hour a day packed together with 80 or so other people is going to increase transmission from a droplet spread disease.
- jgwil2 7y agoInteresting hypothesis. We should sill look at the evidence before stating it as fact.
- cameldrv 7y agoIn Wuhan, 11% of traced contacts came back to transport. One thing that might help would be to open the windows in the subway cars.
- jcranmer 7y agoAs opposed to people living packed together in dense apartment blocks? Or working in crowded office blocks? Or spending leisure time in crowded recreational facilities? Or shopping in crowded stories? Or eating in crowded restaurants? Yes, subways are crowded, but so is everything else in NYC. As for why NYC is doing much worse than other comparably dense cities worldwide, my thesis is that it's a failure at all levels of civic participation (federal, state, local, and even residential and commercial proprietors) to be proactive in counteracting the spread of coronavirus.
- runawaybottle 7y agohttps://youtu.be/R5K5ZBDPB3g https://youtu.be/R5K5ZBDPB3g That’s rush hour. Let’s not kid ourselves.
- jcranmer 7y agoHave you seen what the street above that station (note the station name) looks like during non-rush-hour situations? It's still that crowded. (I'll also point out that you picked literally the busiest station on the entire system to use as an example.)
- runawaybottle 7y agoJust a quick YouTube search. I’m a life long long New Yorker, I can promise you that’s not the busiest. I can try to find you some video of the 7 line, it’s like that all the way from Grand Central to Main Street Flushing during rush hour. The thing about the subway is that we all try to hold onto a pole or bar, total vectors for the spread. It’s not just an obvious case of being near each other, we’re forced to touch the same surfaces so we don’t collide every 30 seconds.
- jcranmer 7y agoMTA says Times Square is the busiest station, by a not-even-close margin (63M annual versus 44M for #2): http://web.mta.info/nyct/facts/ridership/ridership_sub_annual.htm http://web.mta.info/nyct/facts/ridership/ridership_sub_annua...
- runawaybottle 7y agoAh right, I didn’t even check to see the station. My larger point is there are many many stations that look just like that during rush hour.
- jcranmer 7y ago
- ancientworldnow 7y agoRush hour cars have 200+ people in them and essentially no air circulation. Generally you're just inches away from people if you aren't outright touching.
- runawaybottle 7y agoNo one actually lives in the borough with the most ridership, they just work there. Rush hour on a subway is about as close as your going to get (no pun intended) to a clear cut ‘yep, this is how it spread’.
- freepor 7y agoThe idea that a subway system like New York's (or even more, London's) is NOT a major vehicle of disease transmission is an extraordinary claim that requires evidence more extraordinary than this.
- totalZero 7y agoLiving in proximity to a subway line doesn't necessarily mean you spend more time on the subway than people who live further away, nor does it mean that you use the subway more. Subway commuters who can't afford to live close to a subway line probably live further from their workplaces, too, which would mean they spend more time on the subway and have more transfers between lines. Those people may then carry germs back to their neighborhoods. The subway is a shared space with poor air quality and many hard surfaces that are touched by many people every hour. The blog post you are "citing" tries to draw conclusions by zip code in a map that is not granular enough to support the claims. You yourself acknowledge this so I'm not sure why you use that blog post as evidence. Also, Jeff Harris (the MIT professor who wrote the paper with which the blogger disagrees) is a doctor as well as being an economist. That doesn't mean he is infallible, but I wouldn't be so quick to dismiss his thoughts.
- simonh 7y agoAgreed, boroughs with high transit ridership are going to be the big hubs, but very few of the people going through those hubs live in the immediate vicinity of the hub, and the people who do live in that vicinity may not have a lot of direct contact with those commuters. The whole problem with transmission through subway transit is that the people using that transit scatter to all and every corner of the region and beyond. They don't stay concentrated in the immediate vicinity of the transit system. I use an inner city transit system every day on my usual commute, but the transit system hub I access it from is about 15 miles away from where I live. I use a bus and then a regional train network to get to it, then go into the underground.