5 ms·
I think you'd be surprised about how many really do believe the Earth is nearly that young https://news.gallup.com/poll/261680/americans-believe-creationism.asp
by zamadatix 7y ago
I think you'd be surprised about how many really do believe the Earth is nearly that young https://news.gallup.com/poll/261680/americans-believe-creationism.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/261680/americans-believe-creati... "People you know" is a very unreliable way to get an idea about various populations.
Regardless I think the comment was about applying current "solutions" to prior times and seeing if agrees with what we'd call a good solution in retrospective, not what people believe currently.
- gerdesj 7y agoNo, I would not really. I have some pretty odd ideas myself and I trained as a Civ Engr, run an IT company and have subscribed to New Scientist for about 30 years. Sometimes I notice aspects of my own woolly thinking and sort them out but I've no doubt that many remain. The funny thing is that "woolly" is in the eye of the beholder or something. I'm not daft enough to have misplaced 85% of the entire universe unlike the entirety of physicists and their "science" 8)
- foobar1962 7y agoNot misplaced, unaccounted for based on what is visible (or more accurately, detectable).
- whymauri 7y agoMy older brother has founded two separate isotope dating companies, one for C-14 dating and the other for rare isotopes. At this point, he has about 15 years of experience in the field and a decent clientele. He believes the Earth is 6000 years old, though. He rationalizes the science he works on as (the biblical) God testing his faith. My father, who works at his C-14 company, also believes this. I will never understand.
- throw_away 7y agoHow do they reconcile when they give customers answers > 6000 years and the whole "thou shalt not lie" bit?
- Geee 7y agoIt's not a lie. When God created everything, he made it seem it was older.
- throw_away 7y agoPerpetuating known lies seems like lying. Is it ok because it's God's lie?
- Geee 7y agoI think so. It can be said that it's not a lie, but a God's test of your faith.
- throw_away 7y agoProbably not the right venue for a deep theological discussion, but ya, don't you give the right answers in tests? Like if it was a test of faith about God's existence in an atheist society, the right thing to do would be to proclaim "God exists". But here, the test is to pretend that the lie is true to everyone else, but in your head, to know that this isn't the right answer? In this moral framework, I wonder what the right ethical thing to do when another creationist is the customer? Do they both accept the lie^H^H^Htest of faith?
- Geee 7y agoIt's a test of personal faith, they don't have to proclaim it to others to 'pass the test'. They pass the test by having faith without proof. It depends on how they interpret the results to the customer. They might show the data and say that "it seems that this rock is million years old". They don't have to believe it themselves. If the customer is another creationist, they probably marvel the perfection of God's creation and how impeccably he has been able to fake the age of the universe. You know, they probably see it as an evidence of God's omnipotence.
- adrianN 7y ago
- gerdesj 7y agoI can only initially rationalise that as "start from God and work back" and "start from science and work forwards". Whether you ever get to the bottom of this, keep loving them both. That is something that does not need a god or science or even a capital letter - I'll assert: Love is the fundamental thing that transcends any ideology.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- projektfu 7y agoI cannot tell a lie. I put that envelope under that pile of garbage. —- Arlo Guthrie
- philwelch 7y agoHonestly, if God created the universe 6,000 years ago and made everything seem as if it were older—I mean, that’s just a fundamentally unfalsifiable metaphysical hypothesis. For all we know, God did that last week or maybe 5 seconds ago. There’s nothing stopping that hypothesis from being true, it just makes, by definition, no measurable or practical difference and is hence irrelevant to scientific inquiry.
- whatshisface 7y agoBut that would go against how things are supposed to work according to the Bible: would God really be playing a big trick, aiming to deceive? A philosophically motivated abstract godlike being might be expected do that, but the Bible is a lot more specific than that about what God's like...
- philwelch 7y agoYeah but at that point you’re arguing theology.
- whatshisface 7y agoRight, but YEC is theology. You were arguing theology from the beginning!
- philwelch 7y agoI was just arguing a distinction between physical and metaphysical truth. My “theology”, such that it exists, is merely that God is fundamentally beyond human understanding and that we can’t meaningfully use human motivations or morality to model God’s actions.
- whatshisface 7y agoIf everything about God is beyond human understanding, then a belief in that god doesn't leave you with any more beliefs than you started with, which makes it atheism by a different name. I would argue that you would have to have at least one religious belief to be counted as religious (and no, "the belief that I have a religious belief" doesn't count.)
- rsynnott 7y agoSome people do now (particularly in the US; while some form of creationism is somewhat common worldwide, literalist young earth creationism is mostly a big deal in some US protestant religions). But it's a fairly new invention as a semi-mainstream concept. It emerged in the 20th century.