3 ms·
> The same thing is an issue with traditional international transactions, but settlement systems like Ripple offer very fast transaction times (seconds instead
by arcticbull 7y ago
> The same thing is an issue with traditional international transactions, but settlement systems like Ripple offer very fast transaction times (seconds instead of days) and reduce exposure to exchange rates, which makes them much cheaper to use.
Ripple is not decentralized, which is why it's cheap. That also just makes it a direct replacement for SWIFT. You can do that without blockchain. You can stand that up in a single RDS instance in about 5 minutes flat, and hash the previously appended rows in a Merkle tree like we've done for eons.
> BTC throughput is artifically capped by its developers to 7 transactions per second (globally), which causes ridiculous bidding wars for transactions. This is not an issue with most cryptocurrencies that have large throughput as one of their main design goals.
There's no truly decentralized cryptocurrency that even comes close to satisfying simultaneously having anywhere close to the transaction throughput of Visa (just one of many processors) while also satisfying the verifiability goals of being able to download the blockchain onto your computer. Because they're competing goals.
> Cryptocurrencies do not have to rely on Bitcoin's way of doing things. There are energy-efficient ways. A single Bitcoin transaction may consume 700 kWh, but a Visa transaction consumes 0.006490 kWh and a Ripple transaction consumes 0.0000113 kWh (http://papers.netrogenic.com/sid/eco-friendly-money.pdf http://papers.netrogenic.com/sid/eco-friendly-money.pdf).
Ripple is not decentralized which is why it's efficient. There are no decentralized, efficient coins. It's also not even close to a fair comparison. They're only counting the electricity consumption of a few validator nodes in that link of yours, and they cap out at 1500TPS, Visa supports 50000TPS.
Further XRP is just a distributed inter-bank ledger. Visa isn't a comparison for that, something like SWIFT is.
> These are not actual transactions. TransferWise can offer cheap rates only on well-balanced corridors because then real money doesn't have to move. If USD->INR payments have a volume of 1M per day and INR->USD also has 1M, then they don't have to move any money and can bypass the whole international transactions side of things and associated fees and locally pay out the same money that was deposited into their accounts.
I have no idea what this means. You do know bags of money don't make their way onto boats every time you make a forex transaction right? The exchange rate is determined by the price that requires no physical currency to leave one country and move to another. Which makes it incredibly efficient. And very real.
> If international transactions were cheap, there would be no need for middle-men like TransferWise.
They're a provider of cheap international transactions. International transactions are cheap.
- mopsi 7y ago> Ripple is not decentralized, which is why it's cheap. Their ledger is inherently decentralized. It runs without a central operator. Consensus is formed by independent parties. > I have no idea what this means. No international transactions take place between financial institutions, they just change a few lines in their internal database table. > They're a provider of cheap international transactions. International transactions are cheap. They serve limited cases and their volume is tiny, only 4B a month. They are no way an indication what international transactions cost.
- arcticbull 7y ago> Their ledger is inherently decentralized. It runs without a central operator. Consensus is formed by independent parties. "Ripple Controls The Network And Who Gets To Validate Transactions, Making It A Centralised And Permissioned Blockchain" [1] That means it's no different than an RDS instance with a Merkle tree. That's not comparable to the other coins we're discussing. > No international transactions take place between financial institutions, they just change a few lines in their internal database table. That's literally how SWIFT works. It's literally how TransferWise works. It's how every international exchange mechanism works, and it's what you described as "not actual transactions." > They serve limited cases and their volume is tiny, only 4B a month. They are no way an indication what international transactions cost. Generally, the less you serve, the more expensive your service, not less, due to economies of scale. TransferWise represents an upper bound on cost, not lower. As I explained before, at scale, InteractiveBrokers will charge you 0.002% ($20/million) for any Forex transaction you like, up to $1B per month, and will charge you progressively less as you go up from there. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/thomassilkjaer/2019/03/07/14-common-misunderstandings-about-ripple-and-xrp/#1de0612471d0 https://www.forbes.com/sites/thomassilkjaer/2019/03/07/14-co...
- mopsi 7y ago> "Ripple Controls The Network And Who Gets To Validate Transactions, Making It A Centralised And Permissioned Blockchain" [1] The quoted part is a misunderstanding that's refuted in following paragraphs. I fully agree with it - Ripple isn't centralized. > That's literally how SWIFT works. It's literally how TransferWise works. It's how every international exchange mechanism works, and it's what you described as "not actual transactions." Nope. There's no way for me and you to directly access SWIFT for deposits and withdrawals like we can sign up with TransferWise or send funds directly from one crypto wallet to the other. We have to go through our banks, who route transactions through chain of trusted intermediaries, who add their own processing fees. TransferWise cleverly bypasses this in balanced corridors where no money has to be moved though the network of financial institutions, but that's a very limited business. They are very far from serving the whole world at cheap rates, and their niche business is no indication of how much a typical international transaction costs. > InteractiveBrokers will charge you 0.002% ($20/million) for any Forex transaction you like, up to $1B per month How reassuring. Sadly, banks do not pass on the savings to customers, and the entry barrier for newcomers with better pricing is very high. Even smaller banks are getting fucked, let alone retail customers.