4 ms·
I am out of China at the moment, but I can say from Chinese media buzz is that it is now almost certain that China's SARS numbers already passed hundreds by ear
by baybal2 7y ago
I am out of China at the moment, but I can say from Chinese media buzz is that it is now almost certain that China's SARS numbers already passed hundreds by early-mid November.
It appears that by late November, the government first took a notice of the outbreak, and by early December it was already a complete freak out.
How the government knew? China has built a nationwide electronic infectious disease reporting system after the first SARS outbreak with specific intent of spotting SARS recurrence. Hospitals in China are required by law to report anything with a remote semblance of SARS into the system. China also holds nationwide drills for infectious disease specialists annually with SARS comeback in mind.
Any claim that China was caught unprepared are hard to believe.
Given that first reliably confirmed info on Beijing dispatching orders to provincial governments on handling a "disaster" also comes onto first days of December, it seems very, very likely to me that they already knew of it being SARS in December.
I also heard of what I have no ability to confirm, like the talk of huge pileups at HK border crossings in first days of December, and a spike of private jet departures.
- nabakin 7y agoAre there any Chinese articles you could link us?
- baybal2 7y agohttps://www.scmp.com/news/china/society/article/3074991/coronavirus-chinas-first-confirmed-covid-19-case-traced-back https://www.scmp.com/news/china/society/article/3074991/coro... SCMP is itself source refer to a third party source. Caixin had a deleted report with about the same message. A few other apparently refer to the same blurry pics with a document saying something about SARS that were going around in Wechat groups in first week of January. The first "something is going on" signal I remember was an article on aboluowang in the last week of December, where they cite a report of major mobilisation in provincial governments, and preparation for "medical emergency" starting first days of December.
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoThat article is discussing retrospective case tracing, just like the retrospective analysis being done in France. The case from November was not recognized as a novel virus at the time.
- yfzhou 7y agoAny source for that? Google doesn't give me any result if I search "武汉 肺炎" (Wuhan Pneumonia) prior to December 30. December 30 was definitively the first time it appeared on the news, and when it did, it quickly became the top news in about a week.
- microcolonel 7y agoWhy would media in China be publishing articles including that term before December 30; and what does not seeing those articles say about the parent post?
- yfzhou 7y agoDo you think Chinese politicians are superhuman who know things before anyone report on them? Xi Jinping had no problem locking down cities after he learned the severity of it. It's ludicrous to think he knew it in December but somehow decided it was a good idea to wait till it spread to the whole country to do it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- microcolonel 7y agoI mean, surely given how embarrassing it has been for PRC, I wouldn't expect 新華 to be excited to publish it for the public and the world to see. And yes, in China especially I expect the party to know about bad news, particularly bad news generated at state institutions, before the media is permitted to report on it, and I expect that reporting to be partial if it ever comes. In fact, I am suspicious of anyone who knows anything about this and claims otherwise.
- kmonsen 7y agoA few things: - He had no problems locking down cities after the severity became known. Is fairly Reasonable to think that in the beginning they thought it was something they could keep quiet and it would go away - people in China don’t report things that might be negative for fear of consequences, he is creating a situation where he doesn’t get to know things before it’s too late this way
- lisper 7y ago> Any claim that China was caught unprepared are hard to believe. And yet it appears manifestly to be the case, no?
- eloff 7y agoDoes it? Per capita they did better than most countries with the least warning. I'm no fan of China, but I give credit where credit is due.
- kmonsen 7y agoIt really depends on how many cases they have had, I think it is hard to trust any information coming from there with no verification.
- eloff 7y agoNo, number of cases is a bad metric. Deaths is far more accurate. I don't trust their numbers, but if you assume deaths are at least within an order of magnitude, it's clear they did better than any major western country. Rather than pointing fingers at China we should point at our own governments and ask how with months of warning watching this unfold in China, we were caught completely unprepared and on the back foot? Every single country. It's a truly shameful performance that has cost us big time in deaths and lost economic output.
- kmonsen 7y agoI don’t trust deaths as well coming from China. There has been some interesting research into sudden changes in number of mobile subscribers in China suggesting it was much, much worse. Although it has been bad, parts of Europe has not been that bad. Germany, Norway, Denmark and maybe others have had very low numbers of deaths with much less impact on the population than China. Also of course New Zealand have done very well. Sure we should ask our governments to do more, but this issue is because of China. They create the conditions for Coronaviruses and they are extremely unhelpful in fighting them.
- kmonsen 7y agoI think hundreds is a very low estimate. It seems not that it spread from China to Italy and France late last year and that seems unlikely but not impossible if only hundreds Chinese people had the virus.
- xfs 7y agoIf you had the correct source you'd know the reporting system about pneumonia of unknown etiology you mentioned was not put into use until mid-January much to the disappointment of the official who boasted about it.
- fspeech 7y agoOn 10/18/2019 US held a pandemic simulation that happened to focus on coronavirus (the director of Chinese CDC was also involved): "That center's latest pandemic simulation, Event 201, dropped participants right in the midst of an uncontrolled coronavirus outbreak that was spreading like wildfire out of South America to wreak worldwide havoc. As fictional newscasters from "GNN" narrated, the immune-resistant virus (nicknamed CAPS) was crippling trade and travel, sending the global economy into freefall. Social media was rampant with rumors and misinformation, governments were collapsing, and citizens were revolting." https://hub.jhu.edu/2019/11/06/event-201-health-security/ https://hub.jhu.edu/2019/11/06/event-201-health-security/ Presumably Chinese government holds such events regularly to test preparedness as well. They could be easily confused with prescience if there is not enough transparency about such things.
- tim333 7y agoA slight variant from that is some academics looked at keywords trending on WeChat search, a bit like google trends, and the earliest was the Chinese term for SARS which started trending on 1 Dec 19. The term for "Novel Coronavirus" started trending on Dec 11th So that suggests they noticed people getting sick around the 1st and had identified the virus by the 11th. Say case zero was on Nov 1 and it doubled every 3 days then there I guess there would be about 1000 infected by Dec 1st and maybe 5 or 10 seriously ill. (guessing it takes 12 days to get seriously ill and maybe 5% of those infected). I think epidemiologists actually estimated it started about Nov 10th. Link to paper https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.02.24.20026682v1.full.pdf https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.02.24.20026682v...