3 ms·

Anywhere you can store a dollar bill, I can store a piece of paper with my private key written on it. Yes, it absolutely is rendered less useful by the fluctua

by elil17 7y ago

Anywhere you can store a dollar bill, I can store a piece of paper with my private key written on it. Yes, it absolutely is rendered less useful by the fluctuation of exchange rate.

arcticbull 7y ago
Not in a real bank, which is insured by the FDIC so in the event it becomes insolvent I get my money back. Unlike an exchange where I get a big ol' SFYL.
- mopsi 7y ago
  Banks have vaults and offer storage services for important documents, including encryption keys. Retrieval difficulties etc can be dealt with by having multiple copies stored in different places. Paper money is no different from keys. If you burn either of them, they're gone for good, but that doesn't stop them from being useful if you use reasonable precautions.
  - arcticbull 7y ago
    Paper money can be converted to digital, insured, replaceable currency by being deposited in a bank. Cryptocurrency cannot.
    - mopsi 7y ago
      So can cryptocurrencies be converted. Each form of storage comes with its upsides and downsides. During the Cypriot banking crisis of 2012-13, 47.5% of savings over 100 000 EUR were seized by the government. A 200 000 EUR deposit became a 152 500 EUR deposit overnight.
      - arcticbull 7y ago
        I think you're not following what I'm saying but I'll dive into the two aspects here: (1) You can convert cryptocurrencies but that doesn't change the fact your key remains a single point of failure, or your exchange's key remains a single point of failure. This is as designed. There is no remedy. It is intentional. It does not apply to an FDIC insured bank account. (2) During the MtGox crisis and the QuadrigaCX [1] crisis (among many, many, many others), 100% of deposits disappeared overnight with zero recourse (aka SFYL). While neither this nor the Cypriot banking crisis are ideal, I know which one I'd prefer to have gone through. Not to mention at the end QuadrigaCX sent $400,000 on crypto to their dead founder's wallet which is just thrown in with the rest of the pool of lost coins. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/dantedisparte/2019/02/05/quadrigacx-how-to-lose-140-million-in-an-instant/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/dantedisparte/2019/02/05/quadri...
        mopsi 7y ago
        > (1) You can convert cryptocurrencies but that doesn't change the fact your key remains a single point of failure, or your exchange's key remains a single point of failure. This is as designed. There is no remedy. It is intentional. It does not apply to an FDIC insured bank account. There can be unlimited number of copies of the same key. For more secure storage, a key can be split into parts that allow reconstruction only if, for example, any 3 of the original 5 parts are present. You can't have such backups with cash. There's no single point of failure, unless the whole system fails and keys have no value anymore. Speaking of which... > (2) During the MtGox crisis and the QuadrigaCX [1] crisis (among many, many, many others), 100% of deposits disappeared overnight with zero recourse (aka SFYL). While neither this nor the Cypriot banking crisis are ideal, I know which one I'd prefer to have gone through. I lived through the collapse of the Soviet Union when money became completely worthless. The photos of the Weimar Republic and baskets full of bills - I've seen that with my own eyes, and I'm not sure that was the last time for me to experience a complete financial collapse. Cash isn't as long-lasting as people seem to think, with a few notable exceptions like the USD. Most currencies that existed in Europe 30 years ago are gone. If you tear down a wall during home renovations and come across a hidden stash of 1997 French francs, they're worthless and can't be exchanged for the Euro anymore: https://europa.eu/european-union/about-eu/euro/exchanging-national-currency_en https://europa.eu/european-union/about-eu/euro/exchanging-na... As to the exchanges - they a are a mirror image of traditional bank accounts (deposit money and hope it doesn't vanish) and should be avoided as much as possible. One of the aims of cryptocurrencies is getting rid of such blind trust based relationships and replace them with cryptographically secured ones that are bound to well-established rules that cannot be arbitrarily changed.
        arcticbull 7y ago
        > There can be unlimited number of copies of the same key. Unlimited copies of a single point of failure remains a single point of failure. > ... 47.5% of savings over 100 000 EUR were seized by the government. A 200 000 EUR deposit became a 152 500 EUR deposit overnight. I should say that Cypriot haircut is nothing compared to how far all the cryptos have fallen in the last 3 years. Nothing. [1] If you got in over the last few years a Cypriot haircut would look downright luxurious. Speaking of wheelbarrows full of garbage, how do you think Zcash and Iota holders feel? Think they're glad they invested in "secure money"? Or are we just going to blame them for picking the wrong crypto? > As to the exchanges - they a are a mirror image of traditional bank accounts (deposit money and hope it doesn't vanish) and should be avoided as much as possible. One of the aims of cryptocurrencies is getting rid of such blind trust based relationships and replace them with cryptographically secured ones that are bound to well-established rules that cannot be arbitrarily changed. They are not. Traditional bank accounts are insured by the government which is also the sole issuer of the currency. To the extent the government remains functional your cash is secure, safe and insured. If the government fails, your bitcoin won't help you either. [1] athcoinindex.com
      - deleted 7y ago
        [deleted]
- elil17 7y ago
  The money in a bank is not paper currency. Your deposit is backed by as little as 3% cash reserves. My original point was that crypto is a medium of exchange, like cash, not that it is a store of value, like bank account deposits.
  - arcticbull 7y ago
    > The money in a bank is not paper currency. Your deposit is backed by as little as 3% cash reserves. Utterly irrelevant so long as it's backed by the FDIC. Nobody has lost a single penny since the Great Depression to a bank failure. Not during COVID. Not in 2008. Not ever. > Your deposit is backed by as little as 3% cash reserves. I'm not sure the Bank of Tether even has that much on hand, and it defines the pricing of all cryptocurrencies. > My original point was that crypto is a medium of exchange. It's not a useful medium of exchange due to its insane volatility and high implied and direct fees. > ...not that it is a store of value, like bank account deposits Cash and bank deposits are a medium of exchange and an intentionally lossy store of value. This is all pretty much ECON-101.

by elil17 7y ago

Anywhere you can store a dollar bill, I can store a piece of paper with my private key written on it. Yes, it absolutely is rendered less useful by the fluctuation of exchange rate.

arcticbull 7y ago

Not in a real bank, which is insured by the FDIC so in the event it becomes insolvent I get my money back. Unlike an exchange where I get a big ol' SFYL.

mopsi 7y ago
Banks have vaults and offer storage services for important documents, including encryption keys. Retrieval difficulties etc can be dealt with by having multiple copies stored in different places. Paper money is no different from keys. If you burn either of them, they're gone for good, but that doesn't stop them from being useful if you use reasonable precautions.
- arcticbull 7y ago
  Paper money can be converted to digital, insured, replaceable currency by being deposited in a bank. Cryptocurrency cannot.
  - mopsi 7y ago
    So can cryptocurrencies be converted. Each form of storage comes with its upsides and downsides. During the Cypriot banking crisis of 2012-13, 47.5% of savings over 100 000 EUR were seized by the government. A 200 000 EUR deposit became a 152 500 EUR deposit overnight.
    - arcticbull 7y ago
      I think you're not following what I'm saying but I'll dive into the two aspects here: (1) You can convert cryptocurrencies but that doesn't change the fact your key remains a single point of failure, or your exchange's key remains a single point of failure. This is as designed. There is no remedy. It is intentional. It does not apply to an FDIC insured bank account. (2) During the MtGox crisis and the QuadrigaCX [1] crisis (among many, many, many others), 100% of deposits disappeared overnight with zero recourse (aka SFYL). While neither this nor the Cypriot banking crisis are ideal, I know which one I'd prefer to have gone through. Not to mention at the end QuadrigaCX sent $400,000 on crypto to their dead founder's wallet which is just thrown in with the rest of the pool of lost coins. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/dantedisparte/2019/02/05/quadrigacx-how-to-lose-140-million-in-an-instant/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/dantedisparte/2019/02/05/quadri...
      - mopsi 7y ago
        > (1) You can convert cryptocurrencies but that doesn't change the fact your key remains a single point of failure, or your exchange's key remains a single point of failure. This is as designed. There is no remedy. It is intentional. It does not apply to an FDIC insured bank account. There can be unlimited number of copies of the same key. For more secure storage, a key can be split into parts that allow reconstruction only if, for example, any 3 of the original 5 parts are present. You can't have such backups with cash. There's no single point of failure, unless the whole system fails and keys have no value anymore. Speaking of which... > (2) During the MtGox crisis and the QuadrigaCX [1] crisis (among many, many, many others), 100% of deposits disappeared overnight with zero recourse (aka SFYL). While neither this nor the Cypriot banking crisis are ideal, I know which one I'd prefer to have gone through. I lived through the collapse of the Soviet Union when money became completely worthless. The photos of the Weimar Republic and baskets full of bills - I've seen that with my own eyes, and I'm not sure that was the last time for me to experience a complete financial collapse. Cash isn't as long-lasting as people seem to think, with a few notable exceptions like the USD. Most currencies that existed in Europe 30 years ago are gone. If you tear down a wall during home renovations and come across a hidden stash of 1997 French francs, they're worthless and can't be exchanged for the Euro anymore: https://europa.eu/european-union/about-eu/euro/exchanging-national-currency_en https://europa.eu/european-union/about-eu/euro/exchanging-na... As to the exchanges - they a are a mirror image of traditional bank accounts (deposit money and hope it doesn't vanish) and should be avoided as much as possible. One of the aims of cryptocurrencies is getting rid of such blind trust based relationships and replace them with cryptographically secured ones that are bound to well-established rules that cannot be arbitrarily changed.
        arcticbull 7y ago
        > There can be unlimited number of copies of the same key. Unlimited copies of a single point of failure remains a single point of failure. > ... 47.5% of savings over 100 000 EUR were seized by the government. A 200 000 EUR deposit became a 152 500 EUR deposit overnight. I should say that Cypriot haircut is nothing compared to how far all the cryptos have fallen in the last 3 years. Nothing. [1] If you got in over the last few years a Cypriot haircut would look downright luxurious. Speaking of wheelbarrows full of garbage, how do you think Zcash and Iota holders feel? Think they're glad they invested in "secure money"? Or are we just going to blame them for picking the wrong crypto? > As to the exchanges - they a are a mirror image of traditional bank accounts (deposit money and hope it doesn't vanish) and should be avoided as much as possible. One of the aims of cryptocurrencies is getting rid of such blind trust based relationships and replace them with cryptographically secured ones that are bound to well-established rules that cannot be arbitrarily changed. They are not. Traditional bank accounts are insured by the government which is also the sole issuer of the currency. To the extent the government remains functional your cash is secure, safe and insured. If the government fails, your bitcoin won't help you either. [1] athcoinindex.com
    - deleted 7y ago
      [deleted]
elil17 7y ago
The money in a bank is not paper currency. Your deposit is backed by as little as 3% cash reserves. My original point was that crypto is a medium of exchange, like cash, not that it is a store of value, like bank account deposits.
- arcticbull 7y ago
  > The money in a bank is not paper currency. Your deposit is backed by as little as 3% cash reserves. Utterly irrelevant so long as it's backed by the FDIC. Nobody has lost a single penny since the Great Depression to a bank failure. Not during COVID. Not in 2008. Not ever. > Your deposit is backed by as little as 3% cash reserves. I'm not sure the Bank of Tether even has that much on hand, and it defines the pricing of all cryptocurrencies. > My original point was that crypto is a medium of exchange. It's not a useful medium of exchange due to its insane volatility and high implied and direct fees. > ...not that it is a store of value, like bank account deposits Cash and bank deposits are a medium of exchange and an intentionally lossy store of value. This is all pretty much ECON-101.