4 ms·
So Long, Bill Gates, and Thanks for the Monopoly
- pg 18y ago"But the upside was enormous because the monopoly created a stable environment where entrepreneurs could develop new companies and new products around a common platform." This is false. Multiple platforms mean porting and compatibility problems, but they evolve faster. Right now developers are pulling their hair out trying to make things work on incompatible browsers, but who would go back to the days when Explorer had 96% market share? The Windows monopoly didn't encourage hackers to create new companies and new products. Quite the opposite. Little of the work that hackers did reached ordinary people, because ordinary people used an OS hackers didn't use, and didn't want to write programs for.
- Prrometheus 18y agoThe ability of human beings to find a justification for anything never disappoints.
- kirse 18y agoThe Windows monopoly allowed entrepreneurs to develop software for the largest unified computer user-base in the world. If we agree that the ultimate success of a software development business (or any for-profit business) is rooted in its ability to maximize net income, then how can you explain that multiple platforms and user-base fragmentation are beneficial to that ultimate goal? One massively unified market clearly has more income potential than several fragmented markets that individually require additional effort to enter. Also -- "because ordinary people used an OS hackers didn't use, and didn't want to write programs for." If hackers were too stubborn to build for the O/S that clearly had (and still has) market domination, then I would argue that they really were not entrepreneurs when they chose to overlook an obvious business opportunity. Edit: I hope this comment doesn't come off as abrasive, because it was not my intention. Please respond if you think if I've made a mistake in my argument.
- pg 18y agoThe Windows monopoly allowed entrepreneurs to develop software for the largest unified computer user-base in the world. I wouldn't deny it. What I'm saying is that a unified user base is not nearly as important as rapidly evolving platforms. If hackers were too stubborn to build for the O/S that clearly had (and still has) market domination, then I would argue that they really were not entrepreneurs You're right about that too, though again, wrong about the bigger picture. Hackers aren't motivated mainly by money. When the only businesses you can start are boring or evil, they don't start businesses. But when they do start businesses, the fact that they're driven by curiosity and hope, rather than the mere desire to make money, causes them to create the fastest growing companies of all.
- ComputerGuru 18y agoYou know what? I think I'm really going to miss that guy....
- m0nty 18y ago"it was the open architecture of the Microsoft-based PC that spurred massive creativity" IBM-based, shurely? I mean, it ran MS software, but if they'd been in the hardware business they'd probably have done what Apple did, and produced a closed platform. That's more-or-less what they did with their software, after all.
- bayareaguy 18y ago"If all that stuff worked right out of the box, we'd all be out of a job," said David Strom, an independent technology consultant and speaker in St. Louis. Strom has a speech praising Gates for, among other things, effectively guaranteeing full employment for IT people called in to make Microsoft products work properly. This sort of thinking is exactly why hackers I respect stay as far away from Microsoft technologies as possible.
- tfinniga 18y agoI love that the broken window fallacy is being applied to windows.
- sdurkin 18y ago"Without that standard, the computer industry in the 1990s would have resembled the web today: diverse, vibrant and flowering with abundant innovation, but also frequently broken because of the inability of disparate products to make the most basic connections with one another." Wrong. Without Microsoft, the computer industry would have been forced to tackle the issue of interoperability far earlier and more earnestly. If it weren't for this illegal monopoly, computers today would have a vibrant mix of operating systems and technology that would be able to share information seamlessly.
- allenbrunson 18y agoI'm of the opinion that operating systems form a natural monopoly. The average computer user doesn't thrive on diversity. She wants to use whatever her friends use, so they can help her when stuff breaks, they can all share documents easily, etc. I'm not crazy about the stranglehold Microsoft had on the industry for so long. But I think if it hadn't been them, it would have been somebody else.
- thwarted 18y agoAn operating system monopoly is not necessarily the problem, it's when an operating system monopoly is used to gain a monopoly on applications. In the same way users don't care about diversity, they don't care about operating systems. They care about applications. If Microsoft Office ran on other operating systems AND OPERATED EXACTLY THE SAME WAY (which excludes Microsoft's attempts to have Office and IE on the Mac), then the user could still get help from friends when stuff breaks and share documents. It may have been someone else, but perhaps that someone else would have been about encourages standards and interoperability and not application lock-in.
- wallflower 18y agoDoes anyone remember how hard it was to install a printer or SCSI device before Windows?
- edw519 18y ago
- schtog 18y agoStandards are one thing, monopolies another. I guess as the complexity of our systems grow it will be more and more important to keep the technology minimalist and easy to change. Hmm what was i gonna say. Think virtual machines for example. There could be several different but still compile to bytecode so you could run all kinds of languages on different VMs and different hardware by making layers. Hmm I will try to get this clearer and post again. But I stand by the first sentence.
- MaysonL 18y agoI just hope that his leaving is more permanent than "You won't have Richard Nixon to kick around anymore."
- cawel 18y ago"If all that stuff worked right out of the box, we'd all be out of a job," said David Strom I'm not sure if this argument is used to support monopolies (via fueling the IT industry), but if it is, it's ludicrous. It's like saying that companies insuring against vandalism should thank the vandals. I do not see "fixing MS bugs"-companies as organic to the IT industry. Sure, more people are employed, but it does not create innovation, it does not contribute to the growth of the essence of the IT industry (different from the GDP resulting from the IT industry). All of these problems are traceable to a lack of widely supported standards. Pointing to a lack of standards to explain some of today's annoyances (MP3 compatibility, sync issues, etc.) is correct. However, linking the lack of standards with a lack of monopoly in those areas is wrong. I see soft anti-trust policies (in the case of DRM) or lack of motivation for creating standards-making bodies as more interesting causes. Diversity is not incompatible with the existence of common standards. Let's think of all web apps out there, offering competing products, all using HTTP.