9 ms·
I have been beating this drum for a while. I feel like I'm shouting aliens. The CFR for sixty plus is staggering. Below sixty? Still crappy, but not shut do
by taeric 7y ago
I have been beating this drum for a while. I feel like I'm shouting aliens. The CFR for sixty plus is staggering. Below sixty? Still crappy, but not shut down the world. Below twenty? We wouldn't even notice.
The problem is not whether this is more or less scary than the flu (or anything else), it is both. With no solutions aimed at buffering nursing homes/elderly.
Am I just insane? This narrative seems completely absent in all of the coverage.
- JshWright 7y agoWhat narrative... that COVID-19 is most deadly for those over 60? That's literally the only fact that most people know about it. If you think that has been absent in all the coverage, I have no idea what coverage you have been paying attention to.
- taeric 7y agoIt is and it isn't. This thread is predicated on an IFR that is a flat 5 or so percent on the population. We all acknowledge that it is deadly. Because it is. And you are right that this is in all the data. But the narrative is still holistic. We are locking down everyone to try and kill the virus. Yes, it could work. But so could strict access to most nursing homes. Wouldn't be cheap, but could have even been more effective. Reasoning that we could reach herd immunity style buffer between the populations. (Note that I flat reject just letting people die. I am not saying to abandon the older at risk crowd. I'm saying take pointed measures to explicitly protect them.)
- philwelch 7y agoThis was more or less the original UK strategy: isolate the elderly and go full-bore for herd immunity. They scrapped that plan after they updated the model to account for ventilator shortages. There is lots of commentary on that strategy if you want to go back and read it. Even if you were gonna do this, you’d have to figure out how to isolate high-risk populations as thoroughly as possible, to the point of locking caretakers in with them and whatnot. If you lock everyone down, you have a lot more latitude to half-ass things as long as you keep R below 1. Isolating high-risk populations and deliberately pursuing herd immunity means operating consistently under the assumption that virtually everyone else will, as opposed to may, be contagious.
- taeric 7y agoThat was reported as full on no shut down. Just crap reporting? Note that I am still proposing an expensive solution. But asking if the barrier between the populations could be setup stronger. Such that the death and hospitalization load would have been what we have had, minus most of the elder population. Edit: you edited on me. Yes, I am proposing that offering strict access to this crowd could have been done cheaper and more effective than what we have done.
- philwelch 7y agoSorry about the edit. The problem with isolating high risk populations is that you have to go round them all up and temporarily house them in quarantined facilities. And since the elderly are sometimes infamous for their unwillingness to be rounded up and forced to leave their homes, you have to either force them anyway or just abandon them to their fate. And that’s without touching the massive logistics of such an effort. (Not rounding them up would be even harder.) Honestly, if you were gonna try and do that, I think geographical isolation would be a better option. Compartmentalize your state/region/country into separate zones, block all non-essential travel between zones, regularly test essential travelers, and change the lockdown status of each zone based on local conditions. What will end up happening is occasional breaches between zones where a zone might go from green to red. But it gets us in a position where most people are mostly unrestricted most of the time. It also makes it possible to eradicate the virus without actually infecting most of the population, which is nice. Logistically you’d, at most, just set up checkpoints on roadways and inside airports and train stations to enforce the travel restrictions. Over time you could even allow travel between green zones.
- taeric 7y agoNo worries on the edit. Meant that more to explain if I seemed to ignore party of your post. I think you could have gotten pretty good volunteer isolation. As simple as getting grocery stores to deliver to elderly. As expensive as renting the Ritz for a month. Still expensive, but cheap compared to what we have landed in.
- 7y ago
- JshWright 7y agoThere are millions of people in high risk groups outside of nursing homes. How do you propose protecting them? There are also millions of people in low risk groups who care for people in nursing homes and other high risk populations. How do you propose keeping them from infecting those they are caring for? The thread is also predicated on a very high base reproduction number. A high R0 means a very large percentage of the population needs to be immunity before "herd immunity" is a thing (on the order of 80-90%). Even with a very low IFR, that is hundreds of thousands dead.
- taeric 7y agoWe haven't dodged that bullet in our current strategy. And the more data we get, the more it looks like we haven't protected them, honestly. I'll note some of the first cases in WA included a high school student that had not been traveling. I cannot square that, how contagious this is, and the idea that it wasn't widely in that school. I think herd immunity is silly at the holistic level. At a cohort level, though, it could work reasonable. Consider, at this point we could start rotations of health workers that have the antibodies. I have said it before, but I will stress again I am just a random internet poster. Much of why I am posting this is to get challenged on it.
- redis_mlc 7y ago> We are locking down everyone to try and kill the virus. What are you talking about? That was never the goal in the US.
- taeric 7y agoThat sentence is a shortened version of what we seem to be doing. Which is keep it under control while we race to a vaccine. To kill it. Of course, the more data we get, the less control we see that it was ever in. Such that right now,I don't think we have a coherent plan.
- JshWright 7y agoNew York seems to have a reasonable plan. Hospitalization rate is under control, careful planning is going into how to reopen the state in a tiered way, etc.
- taeric 7y agoWhat are they doing to keep it out of the rest of their long term care facilities? Note that they have over a million people over sixty. And if you redo their numbers assuming the CFR is roughly known in the different age brackets, things could get much much worse. (That is, the CFR in WA is in very low numbers holistically. For the sixty plus? It is over 15%!!) So, unless they have something protecting them, just reopening slowly didn't really have a mechanism to protect them. Now, they could go for herd immunity in care workers. Rotate in those with antibodies, and you are simulations how we protect the elderly from the flu. But just slowly reopening? What is the mechanism that is expecting a change?
- JshWright 7y agoIt's not just "slowly reopening". The reopening is predicated on testing capacity, as well as the ability to adequately track and trace.
- 7y ago
- Jabbles 7y agoYou're not insane, but you need to take into account that the CFR would be higher if the healthcare system were overwhelmed with patients. Also reducing death is not the only target, we are reasonably sure that many patients will have long-lasting damage to their lungs. There is of course some trade off between number of deaths avoided and amount of money we should be prepared to throw at the problem. Where on this spectrum are you?
- taeric 7y agoI'm on a different angle, I think. My specific point is that people need to stop looking at a single IFR/CFR stat. It does no good. We look to be getting safer numbers there by simply increasing testing. (Of note, NYC has a strict lower bound on its numbers with how many in its population has died. But, do note they have more people over sixty than most cities do people. Such that most places will not be comparable.) And that is the problem. The virus has not gotten safer as we get more data. Our understanding is just not focusing on helping the elderly. We seem to be taking a crap shot that everyone can stay home and we can out sit the virus. I would wager we could have setup hotels and strict access controls on supplies into and out of at risk communities cheaper than what we have done. Certainly if you count on all of the job loss.
- djsumdog 7y ago> you need to take into account that the CFR would be higher if the healthcare system were overwhelmed with patients This is the narrative we keep getting fed over and over again, but it doesn't seem to be working out. There are a lot of people who were afraid to go to doctors for minor issues, a lot of important surgeries canceled for being elective, etc. On top of that, 80% of people who need a ventilator who are older or have other health issues, will die on them[0]. For the younger patients, it's almost a coin toss. Some hospital systems are overwhelmed, but some are totally empty. Treating a region as large as the US as one unified geographical region, even with our unrestricted travel, didn't seem sound. The devastation to peoples jobs, lives, savings, homes .. everything ... we keep saying Lives > Economy, but unless our leaders address how to deal with reconstruction (no one seems to be talking about this), there could be a lot of consequences worse than covid down the line. 0: https://www.webmd.com/lung/news/20200422/most-covid-19-patients-placed-on-ventilators-died-new-york-study-shows#1 https://www.webmd.com/lung/news/20200422/most-covid-19-patie...
- redis_mlc 7y agoNo, you're correct. We know from the high rate of corona infection in SF with low mortality that corona stats are being improperly analyzed.
- joshuamorton 7y agoCan you elaborate? On what are you basing the high rate of corona infection?
- macintux 7y agoI’m fairly confident the Stanford study will never die, no matter how many stakes are driven through its heart.
- loblollyboy 7y agoNo, most people are just illogical. The numbers show that this is <1% fatal and probably <0.1% but all it takes is one story of some 30 year old dying on the news and everybody loses their minds. Granted, I was very scared myself before we had numbers, but I don’t know how many people are willing to actually take a look at them now that this has become sort of political. It’s like how a school shooting will get a lot of coverage, but nobody talks about how way more people are shooting themselves in the head. Emotions over facts.
- chimprich 7y ago> The numbers show that this is <1% fatal and probably <0.1% In New York City about 0.15% of the entire population of the city have already died from the virus, putting a lower limit on the IFR. Estimates of the IFR have been consistently between about 0.5% to 1% by most authorities I have confidence in.
- taeric 7y agoThat is a lower limit on the IFR in NYC. They also have more people over sixty two than city of Seattle has people. So, much more dense, with about 13% of the population an at risk group. And calculate that IFR per age band. Running WA numbers in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23080035 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23080035 shows that the IFR here ranges from .7% to 15%(!) if you do that.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nodamage 7y agoCan you provide specific numbers?
- taeric 7y agoSure. Per yesterday's paper, there have been 15185 cases and 834 deaths in WA. That would be a CFR of about 5%. Now, it says the cases are 33% above sixty, and the deaths are 91% above sixty. So that would be a CFR of 758/5011, 15%. Contrast with below sixty. Which comes to a CFR of about .7%. If I go with just under twenty, the paper doesn't give me enough data to calculate. They are 4% of the cases, but don't even get listed in the deaths breakdown. Under forty, the rate is about 1.5%. And note that more testing can drive down these numbers. But it's unlikely to do so for the elderly.