3 ms·
Few points. That strain is said to be characteristic to large horseshoe bats from Yunnan Bats in China don't seem to live so far north, and away from the coas
by baybal2 7y ago
Few points.
That strain is said to be characteristic to large horseshoe bats from Yunnan
Bats in China don't seem to live so far north, and away from the coast. More so, for larger species.
The very few bats known to live near cities, are all small insectivorous species. SARS carrying bat species don't normally like living near humans.
Bats are not considered food, even by nouveau riche weird meat eaters in China.
The above mean that there should be no bats sold on wet markets. First responder reports confirm that.
1. So, out of where did the SARS strain very close to the wild virus came out from in the middle of a 10 million people megalopolis?
2. From where did the story about bats came out from to begin with?
3. It is now near certain that first reports of influx of respiratory patients happened as early as November, and it had nothing to do with the seafood market. If so, how media were first able to connect the dots to the market, and do it so quickly, and confidently?
4. The first report incriminating the market came out few weeks after first evidence of the government sending censorship directives, and instructions on outbreak handling to provincial authorities.
5. It means that a low key regional newspaper broke out a report at the same time when even a squeak about sars outbreak got people into trouble.
6. The amazing synchronicity with which top tier national medias republished the story of an obscure regional newspaper is clearly unnatural.
7. The way how zealously Chinese media came out to blast earliest reports doubting this outbreak originating from the seafood market even before that became news in the West stands out. Are all of them subscribed to the same obscure American academic journal?
8. Chinese government is no stranger to manufacturing bizarre hoaxes
Normally, this is not what Chinese government would cover up. The concealment of original SARS outbreak only happened after the fact of its existence becoming public.
What was covered up in 2003 was not its existence, but the lacklustre emergency response after it became clear that they completely screwed up.
Similarly, other natural disaster coverups only happened after it becoming clear that somebody screwed up.
I.E.: the Wenzhou train collision. The cover up was made not for screwup of signalling system designers, but to make the emergency response look "adequate." The guy wanted to render it a "small, manageable derailment accident," and not to show hundreds people dying on his hands while he did nothing.
- pacala 7y agoI struggle with similar questions. Probably we'll never know. As of your first point, there may be another natural virus, as of yet unidentified, possibly carried by a different species, that brought the disease to Wuhan. From the virologist chatter I hear, the genetic difference between RaTG13 is too large to have RaTG13 a recent direct precursor of SARS-CoV-2, either through genetic manipulation, or via culturing. Alternatively, everything that came out of China since Jan 2020 is pure BS. As of yet, there is no independent verification of the origin of RaTG13, which conveniently was found 'lying around in a freezer' in Jan 2020, stored there all the way back in 2013. Nor there is independent verification of the genomic sequences of all the other viruses that are 'lying around in a freezer'. Nor are the Chinese authorities very open to international collaboration on this matter. The sharp politicization of this issue is worrisome in itself.
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoRaTG13 wasn't exactly "lying around." The Wuhan Institute of Virology searches out and catalogs bat coronaviruses. They have a "library" of a few hundred frozen viruses. Most of them probably receive very little in-depth study after initial categorization. > Nor are the Chinese authorities very open to international collaboration on this matter. The Wuhan Institute of Virology actually engages in a large amount of international collaboration. The international collaborators of the WIV (among them are some of the most prominent coronavirus and emerging infectious diseases researchers), in the United States and elsewhere, have been defending the institute against the various conspiracy theories circulating online (and being promoted by the US President). The researchers at the WIV receive training at national labs in the US, France and Australia. In other words, the WIV is tightly hooked into the international research community. It's not some secretive place that the outside world can't peer into. > possibly carried by a different species, that brought the disease to Wuhan SARS and MERS were both transmitted to humans through an intermediate host species. It's reasonable to believe that SARS-CoV-2 also went through an intermediate host. It's also not certain that the initial spillover occurred in Wuhan. It could easily have begun in the countryside and only blown up when someone brought it to Wuhan, which is a major transportation hub.
- watertom 7y agoI want to know how they identified a new viral pneumonia back in late November with just a handful of cases. Someone please correct me if I’m wrong, but since the initial symptoms are flu like wouldn’t it require a statistically significant number of additional cases, deaths or symptoms in order to alert the health officials that something new was taking place, and an investigation was warranted? In late November they had less than 15 cases but they had already identified it as a new virus. How would they know to look for a new virus with so few cases? Unless they had prior knowledge about a new virus that was accidental released, which prompted them to start looking.
- baybal2 7y agoTaiwan is a good calibration point. There, they managed to trace all cases down to a single arrival from the mainland. From that, it looks quite believable that it would've taken 3-4 full generations of reinfections to take the count to 200 hospitalisations. I think, 200 hospitalisations should've been around the same number for the signal to attract attention by Chinese disease surveillance, if it wasn't picked up by the purpose made SARS screening network. If we believe the news that Hubei already saw hundred extra deaths in January, and that hospitals were already near full in mid January, then the number of infections should've been already above 1000 at Jan 1.
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoThey didn't identify the new case in November. There is a report of a case that was retrospectively dated to mid-November, by searching through patient records and probably by re-testing samples. But that retrospective analysis was done months later. The virus was not identified until the end of December, which is more than a month after the case in mid-November.