11 ms·
It's easy to get a patent on just about anything. I have a patent for a faster-than-light communications device: https://patents.google.com/patent/US7126691B2
by lisper 7y ago
It's easy to get a patent on just about anything. I have a patent for a faster-than-light communications device:
https://patents.google.com/patent/US7126691B2/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US7126691B2/en
I filed it as an exercise to see if you can get a patent on a device that violates the laws of physics. Turns out you can.
- csours 7y agoAhem KNOWN laws of physics.
- lisper 7y agoIf you can communicate faster than light then you can send information backwards in time. That's not just a violation of the known laws of physics, that's a causal paradox, which is much, much worse. It's actually conceivable that the Navy's gadget could work (though I will give you incredibly long odds against). It's not even conceivable that mine would even under alternate laws of physics. The universe would have to be logically incoherent to allow that.
- haneefmubarak 7y agoEh. Suppose our current theory of relativity was wrong in some specific way or someone came up with something that sidestepped our current understanding - you could still have a logically coherent universe in those scenarios, because it'd just mean that our current understanding and theories of how the universe works were wrong.
- lisper 7y ago> Suppose our current theory of relativity was wrong in some specific way There aren't many ways in which relativity can be wrong. Relativity follows logically from the assumption that the laws of electrodynamics are independent of the observer's state of motion. The evidence that this is true is overwhelming. To overturn this part of physics would be comparable to showing that the earth is in fact flat.
- haneefmubarak 7y agoI'm not saying that it is wrong - experiments and data to date seem to mostly validate our current theories etc - I'm just trying to point out that it's not inconceivable that we might not have a 100% correct theory and that that the parts that we're incorrect on could lead to possibilities that we would otherwise consider inconsistent (within our current understanding). I'm sure that historically, scientifically minded folks who believed in whatever they thought they knew at the time considered some aspects of their "knowledge" to be incontrovertible given how overwhelmingly the evidence until then seemed to support their theories - until it didn't. There's not a reasonable reason to expect that we have arrived at the ultimate understanding of most things such that most if not all new discoveries will only be refinements; the evidence until now has shown that that approach to science has been incorrect for basically most of history.
- lisper 7y ago> I'm not saying that it is wrong This is exactly what you said: > Suppose our current theory of relativity was wrong You should read this: https://chem.tufts.edu/AnswersInScience/RelativityofWrong.htm https://chem.tufts.edu/AnswersInScience/RelativityofWrong.ht...
- haneefmubarak 7y agoI'm saying that it could be wrong (as any and all things could be), not that it currently is. Im also aware of Asimov's essay on the topic of how wrong something can be. That being said, his point about getting less wrong really addresses one thing: theories are largely formed on predictive power and we improve over time as we collect more observations and attempt to address the inconsistencies between our theories and our observations to the contrary. As a result, since newer theories should have greater predictive power, they should be less wrong, and thus should have a higher probability of being correct. None of that, however, necessitates that the current theories should have a 100% probability of being correct. Keeping that in mind, it is worthwhile to realize that there are questions that can be asked today given our current level of understanding and observation that are simply nonsensical to ask in a prior time frame (easy example: asking "what is the band gap voltage of InGaAs?" in 1600 AD). This means that results that seem impossible at a given time frame (real time displays that render imagined worlds) become a simple question of how to in a different time frame. Putting this all together: we could definitely be wrong about anything. Sure, theories that seem consistent and have consistently provided good predictive power across most of not all current observations are useful, but they don't preclude new discoveries that could be even more correct and allow for things that we couldn't have previously considered possible.
- simiones 7y agoYou're saying that, in principle, new physics could allow for FTL travel that nevertheless does not permit time travel and the grandfather paradox etc, right?
- haneefmubarak 7y agoYep! Alternatively, perhaps new physics would allow for what appears to be "time travel" but in reality is not (travel between the present here and a different "time" in a remarkably similar but parallel universe).
- zozbot234 7y agoClosed timelike curves (i.e. causal loops) are exotic but not altogether outside of mainstream physics. The basic fact of continuity that's inherent in QM means that no logical paradox arises; consistency is always possible. FTL is more problematic for other, less directly-related reasons.
- lisper 7y ago> Closed timelike curves Those are not the same as FTL signaling. CTCs don't by themselves produce causal paradoxes. FTL signaling does.
- zozbot234 7y ago> FTL signaling does. Pick some example of a "causal paradox" of the sort that might introduced by FTL signaling. If the underlying system is a quantum one (hence with continuous amplitudes, albeit the reasoning also extends to simple probabilities) no logical paradox actually arises because the underlying values are continuous. This would imply that there's no difference between that and a CTC. Of course larger-scale physics appears classical to us but that's a consequence of quantum decoherence and ultimately of the "law" of increasing entropy (2nd law of thermodynamics). Which is just as much of an obstacle to classical CTC's.
- lisper 7y agoThe word "signaling" necessarily implies the transfer of classical information (because of the no-cloning theorem) and that in turn implies some model of the transition between quantum and classical. Whether that transition is (meta)physically real (i.e. collapse) or just an arbitrary threshold applied to a continuous process (decoherence) doesn't matter. What matters is that FTL leads to a logical contradiction with respect to the characterization of the state with respect to whatever model you choose to apply. The underlying metaphysical reality is irrelevant.
- zozbot234 7y ago
- csours 7y agoAh, it's not the laws of physics you care about! It's causal paradoxes! In other words, you want the patent office to not only know the laws of physics (reasonable), but also have a deep knowledge including where there is future potential for change in understanding (maybe less reasonable).
- lisper 7y agoI would expect someone at the patent office to be familiar with the basics of modern physics, including the "cosmic speed limit" imposed by the speed of light. I would not necessarily expect them to know why nothing can move faster than c, but I would expect them to know that nothing can and to reject a patent for something that moves faster than c on those grounds. There is actually a specific rule for this sort of thing: https://www.ipwatchdog.com/2011/10/11/the-patent-law-of-perpetual-motion/id=19828/ https://www.ipwatchdog.com/2011/10/11/the-patent-law-of-perp... It is generally applied to perpetual motion machines.
- ISL 7y agoYou're a hero.
- lisper 7y ago:-)
- chenster 7y agoI bet in patent office got no one really understood what quantum communication entails.
- Psyladine 7y agoThe communication only exists if the receiver is there to witness the "hello"?
- inscionent 7y agoSo I can use you patent to send the patent back in time, generating prior art, which caused your patent to never exist.
- lisper 7y agoWell, you could if it worked, but it doesn't, so you can't :-)
- rwmurrayVT 7y agoThe fact it's "Cited by" other patents, including by the DoN is pretty hilarious.
- ttizya20 7y agopatent office be like: "sure why not"
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoAnd sure why not. If somebody wants to develop a device and sell it, you can get a royalty. Wake me when that happens.
- lisper 7y agoIt is indicative to me of a certain level of intellectual laziness on the part of the patent office. This laziness has consequences. For example, everyone who wants to go into business making something that involves quantum entanglement has to at least consider the possibility that my patent is valid and that this might be a threat to their business model. Even if my patent is not valid, I can still use it to extort money from them simply by asserting that it is valid and that they are infringing on it. Once the patent has issued, the burden of proof is on them to show that I'm wrong and it may well be cheaper for them to buy me off than pay a lawyer to defend themselves against my lawsuit. This is what makes patent trolling profitable.