4 ms·
There is a tiny fraction of the available game to feed America. A single deer would feed a family of four for, what, a week? So, every family needs 52 deer per
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
There is a tiny fraction of the available game to feed America. A single deer would feed a family of four for, what, a week? So, every family needs 52 deer per annum. Forget it.
This is sort of why civilization is based on agriculture. Not hunting-and-gathering.
- bluedino 7y ago>> A single deer would feed a family of four for, what, a week? Depends on the size but you can get 40-60lbs of venison from a whitetail deer.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoAnd at 2000 calories a day, 9 calories/gram, family of four, there you are.
- dragonwriter 7y ago9 kcal/g is pure fat; protein is only 4 kcal/g.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoyeah but its not all protein - fats are 9. I guess wild deer are pretty lean though.
- mindcrime 7y agoI don't think anybody is proposing to replace the entire existing food supply chain with nothing but hunted deer. There is no reason however, to think that hunting can't supplement a family's food stocks if other sources start to become thin. And there's a lot more to hunt than deer. There's also more in play than hunting. A family might feed themselves through a combination of any or all of: hunting, trapping, fishing, foraging for wild edibles, home gardening, AND buying from whatever is available on the market. One interesting thing about this is that those living close to the coasts may be in better shape in one or two regards. Most notably, seafood is one area where "direct to the consumer" sales is a real thing, and there isn't a lot of processing involved. At least where I grew up on the NC coast. It's common for seafood houses to sell oysters, clams, shrimp, etc. directly to consumers.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoAgain, there is every reason to believe (know) hinting/foraging is woefully inadequate. Simple numbers. Natural 'foods' are pitiful fractions of modern cultivars. It takes a quarter acre(?) of Jerusalem Artichoke to gather a few baskets of roots, which must be boiled and peeled down to a few score pounds of edible material. Even a bonanza 10-acre plot in a meadow would feed 40 people for a few days. Early Americans spent the whole summer struggling/working like slaves to put up enough food for the 3 months of winter. Seafood - that sounds like continuing to rely upon the food supply line (fishing boats and their supply chain). That used to be pretty good return. Not sure stocks today could feed a fraction of America for long. Most of us eat seafood a meal a week/month that way even in the best of times.
- mindcrime 7y agoI don't really understand what point you're trying to make, w/r/t the post you're replying to. Again: A family might feed themselves through a combination of any or all of: hunting, trapping, fishing, foraging for wild edibles, home gardening, AND buying from whatever is available on the market. I'm saying that hunting, etc. are individuals components of a broader strategy for providing food - not that any one of those things is sufficient in and of itself. As as of today, it doesn't appear to me that the commercial market for food is going to just disappear overnight. But if things devolve to the point that you can't buy everything you need, then some of these other approaches can come into play. Seafood - that sounds like continuing to rely upon the food supply line (fishing boats and their supply chain). There isn't just one "food supply line." The supply chain for the steak you buy at Food Lion involves a lot of intermediate steps and processing. And those are exactly the steps where we've heard news reports of the processing plants closing down, etc. My point about seafood is that there are fewer such intermediate steps involved. A boat comes in, docks, and sells their shrimp to the seafood house, and the seafood house sells to the public. The main processing is weighing. And some boat captains even bypass the "sell to the seafood house" part and sell direct.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoResponded to the comment directly above (?) As a supplement to a family's food supply, hunting and foraging are totally insufficient. Not if everybody was doing it. The numbers aren't there. Fewer steps in the seafood supply chain, doesn't offset the fact that in America anyway, it currently provides a whopping total of 1 meal a week per. That's gotta be dropping too. So still the numbers don't support any idea of supplementing food supplies to any great degree. The OP was just a puff piece about an uptick in hunting. That was fun and interesting. I just posted to provide the insight that, this isn't going to ever matter to our situation in any significant way. We have to support/restart our commercial food chain, or its going to get very bad. No alternatives are reasonable.
- yread 7y agoOn the other hand if you follow the NHS guidelines (70g/day) 20-30kg of meat from a deer would last a family of four ~80-120 days. Not that bad
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoNot if other foods were unavailable (the assumption). You need 2000 calories a day. 70g of meat is ~600 calories. So triple that, divide by 4 and you've got the week I mentioned.
- horsawlarway 7y agoOther foods aren't unavailable though... They aren't hunting because they're starving, they're hunting because meat is harder to get, and it's a nice luxury that's also expensive. Couple that with reduced/no income and choosing to hunt isn't insane. I know a fair number of people in rural GA who will hunt one deer a year and freeze it, You get small servings of meat all season. It goes a long way... No one would seriously recommend an all meat diet. It will kill you. Seriously - Go google protein poisoning. Unless you're eating incredibly fatty meat like seal, don't eat just meat.
- efiecho 7y ago> No one would seriously recommend an all meat diet. It will kill you. The Carnivore Diet is a real thing that is gaining popularity, if choosing between two extremes with veganism on the other side, I would much prefer an all meat diet.
- horsawlarway 7y agoThey're still not recommending what the original commenter was - a diet based solely of lean venison. The carnivore diet fits pretty well into the "high fat" category. I just went and checked, and the following seems to be a fairly consistent outline of the diet --- Red meat (beef, pork, lamb), with an emphasis on fattier cuts of meat to take in enough calories. Other options include: Organ meats Eggs Lard Bone marrow Butter Salt and pepper --- Basically - A mix of protein and fat with fat constituting much of the calorie intake. So yes, my comment should really read >No one would seriously recommend an all LEAN meat diet. It will kill you. but the poster was doing calorie calculations for pure lean venison. That's insanity.
- gbronner 7y agoYou can get 60 lbs of meat off a medium sized sized deer, and more if you go for bones, certain organs (e.g lungs, testicles) that are less commonly eaten.
- indymike 7y agoIt takes about 2-6 deer to provide meat for a family of four for a year. So, a single deer is about two months of meat. (a deer is 50-125lbs of meat... depending on species and size)
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoNot if that's all the calories you have - then it adds up to a week's nutrition. But sure, as a trivial additive for fun, deer can work for a tiny fraction of the population. My state of 3M had 100,000 deer harvested last year. That's deer for 3% of the population. One deer each. Not gonna put a dent in our food supply. That was my only point.
- mindcrime 7y agoMy state of 3M had 100,000 deer harvested last year. And what about rabbits, squirrels, turkeys, ducks, quail, bison, elk, feral hogs, etc., etc? There's more game out there than just deer.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoThey have an even more vanishingly small contribution, total poundage, to the food supply. I don't mean to be a scrooge - go hunting if it pleases you! But its not gonna feed America, not even a percent or two of us. The numbers don't support it.
- mindcrime 7y agoBut its not gonna feed America, not even a percent or two of us. The numbers don't support it. Nobody is claiming that it will.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoOh everybody was chiming in about supplementing. But whatever.
- FlyMoreRockets 7y agoYou must be refering to those tiny deer back east. Here in the west we have mule deer, which dress out to over a hundred pounds. You're looking at over 70 pounds of meat. If your family of four eats two and a half pounds of meat a day, every day, they may not be actual humans. An elk will net around 250 pounds of boneless meat.