4 ms·
Cubicles were an especial hypocrisy. They cost more per office than carpentered walls. In which case they made no sense at all.
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
Cubicles were an especial hypocrisy. They cost more per office than carpentered walls. In which case they made no sense at all.
- buttcoinslol 7y agoOffices cost more than cubes. An office needs a door, ceiling, lights, lighting control, sometimes a sidelight (window), floor/wall finishes, HVAC, along with a couple receptacles and a data opening. This costs more than an 8x8 cube.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoCeiling, lights, windows, HVAC already exist. Wiring is already needed (data,power) The difference is some wallboard and a hollow-core door. Don't underestimate the cost of that 8x8 cube, Its astronomical. Up to $10,000 though of course you can get crap for $500. When I built our office out, it cost $150 per walled-off office plus door.
- quickthrowman 7y agoIt cost $150 to have an office framed, dry walled, taped and muddled, and painted? Please explain how this is possible, the 5/8th drywall for both sides of the wall is practically that much for materials alone. That stuff doesn’t exist when a space is being completely remodeled either. I work in construction doing tenant improvements, so I see a lot of construction drawings.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoBut you understand, there's not a lot of difference in the lighting and power. Not fair to add that to the cost of offices, and then pretend its free for cubicles. My office buildout was 10 years ago. Prices change. Do we really think drywall in bulk is going to exceed $5000 per cube?
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoWith cubicles you can run the cords to centralized sockets somewhere near the cubes - do you run the cords out the door of your office?
- derefr 7y agoIf you assume everyone has a full workstation drawing 1500w peak, you really can't share sockets.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoMany offices are full of only laptops - those are drawing ~200 Watts peak, and then may another 100 for a couple of monitors and peripherals. That's many more users. My office has literally that - boxes with 4 sockets each in the middle of a shared space which we all run our power-bars to.
- derefr 7y agoSure, the open-plan ones of today are amenable to a low degree of wiring. The types of employees made to sit in those offices are amenable to a low degree of wiring. The average office that has cubicles, though, is also one that’s wired for per-employee power delivery. Or, I could say it as the reverse: if you know you’re setting up an office to have fixed workstations (e.g. a CG art department in a video game studio; or any department in a company with a pipeline whose main software is a hog, like desktop publishing), then you’ll likely set up with cubicles rather than open-plan, because a workstation kind of implies gradual personalization with bunch of surrounding cruft that needs floors and walls and shelving. (I have a feeling that even in FAANG, the people who use workstations aren’t sitting in open-plan areas. Anyone care to speak to that?) And, because of this, the “standard” kind of cubicle partitions are expensive, because they’re also expected to work to handle part of the wiring requirements for power delivery. If they were just plyboard, they’d be cheap; but they’re not just plyboard.
- mywittyname 7y ago
- justinclift 7y agoYeah. Looking here in Aust, this seems like the right kind of plasterboard (from a local hardware chain): https://www.bunnings.com.au/gyrprock-csr-3600-x-1200-x-16mm-plasterboard-fyrchek_p0732495 https://www.bunnings.com.au/gyrprock-csr-3600-x-1200-x-16mm-... That's non-trade price, probably something like $US42 each. So, couple hundred bucks for that, then the rest (taping, joining, painting). Then the electrical. That's without labour costs.
- driverdan 7y agoThat doesn't make sense. Material costs alone are more than $150 for an 8x8 office with a door. Was that cost subsidized by the building owner?
- kube-system 7y agoYou're all missing the biggest expense: real estate. The space required by that door could add 25-50% to your total space requirements compared to cubes of the same size. And that's before we add human perception as an element... offices the size of a cube are a horrible experience. They need to be considerably larger to feel like the same amount of space.
- ashtonkem 7y agoI suspect that cubicles were more about social stratification than anything else. But cubicles were well out of fashion before I joined the work force, so that’s just speculation on my part.
- saalweachter 7y agoThe advantage of cubicles over offices is rearranging work groups on a semi-regular bases. You can create a new work group, assign a third of your employees to it, and then rearrange all of the cubes on the floor so that all of the work groups are together over a weekend.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoRearranging serious cubicles, costs more than recarpentering offices. It might be faster, but not cheaper. And how many times do the cubicles get moved, at all? Short of a move-out to another space, I'd guess the median cubicle is never moved. You want some flexible space, plan for it. But the 'open office plan' was always a hoax.
- vel0city 7y agoRe-arranging cubicles at my office took a couple of people in the office a couple of hours to move a few cubicles around. Unplug the few cords going to the built-in power strips in the cubicles, unplug the cubicle switch, plug it all in at the new space. Cubicles snap apart and together without much effort. Redoing walls requires paying architects to get plans, getting bids from contractors, getting approvals from building management and potentially opening our lease up to negotiations regarding tenant improvements, getting contractor's insurance vetted, getting walls demo'd, paying to get everything disposed of, paying for new materials and installation, repainting, getting electricians to redo electricity and lighting for the space, potentially doing new low voltage runs (don't want to run cat6 out the door) and getting proper permitting to do all of this. I don't know how moving a cubicle gets to be more expensive when comparing how many more people are involved to rebuild and that one requires a couple of hours while the other takes days at best.
- Symbiote 7y agoHow would they cost more? I've only seen the full-height cubicle in American films, but most of the stuff -- desk, shelves and so on -- is still required in an individual office. They don't require a real door or doorframe, and electricity and network connections can be run fairly cheaply under the floor. What am I missing?
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoCubicle furniture is astronomical. The cube walls themselves are astronomical. Some studs, wallboard and a hollow-core door are cheap. The wiring etc are needed for both. Folks keep trying to refactor stuff into office costs, but that's all needed for both.
- WorldMaker 7y agoIronically, cubicle furniture was first billed as cheaper than arranging/rearranging drywall. It's almost funny that drywall construction is cheaper than cube wall construction (again).
- bluGill 7y agoIf you rearrange often cubicals are cheaper. However most places replace the cubes (gotta have the latest shade of neutral off white) when the do the every 5 year rearrange... Offices tend to feel more permanent and so are less often changed. Once again making them cheaper. (though they will repaint offices once in a while)
- WorldMaker 7y agoI understand the concept behind rearranging the people in offices from time to time as a sort of human resources "crop rotation" attempting to get coworkers that otherwise don't interact on projects to perhaps cross-pollinate ideas that can benefit the company (though arguably are there good scientific studies on how much that has actually worked?). But I've always been skeptical of rearranging office layouts themselves. It seems counter-productive, to me at least, because constant environment changes contributes to a low level unease and alert/anxiety/suspicion at the very least in low level tribal/social brain parts, if not bubbling up into very literal distrust in the stability of the company. But I'm not a highly paid office furniture consultant, nor a sociologist/anthropologist, so what do I know.