6 ms·
Now this is interesting. All of the reasons provided for open plan offices have been disingenuous; the reason why open plan offices are a thing is that it dras
by ashtonkem 7y ago
Now this is interesting.
All of the reasons provided for open plan offices have been disingenuous; the reason why open plan offices are a thing is that it drastically lowers the land cost per employee. This is why they were popularized in NYC and SF; two cities with famously high land costs.
But of course, abandoning the open plan office is expensive. Companies will need more space, driving up the cost per employee. One can’t help but wonder if this’ll push for more permanently remote positions.
- cmsonger 7y ago> One can’t help but wonder if this’ll push for more permanently remote positions. I think that's right. Currently these companies are learning to effectively remote work under the duress of COVID-19. How long until they start to ask themselves "what do I do with all this expensive office space." Returning to pre-COVID-19 life requires a vaccine, of which there is no guarantee. But a path forward with dramatically reduced office space requirements will look sure -- and offer value to employees who like the flexibility. There are some really good reasons to want to have an office and face to face interactions; but right now they all look pretty fragile.
- zozbot234 7y ago> All of the reasons provided for open plan offices have been disingenuous; the reason why open plan offices are a thing is that it drastically lowers the land cost per employee. Then why not make those rationales explicit and have the same norms around noise and distractions as you'd find in a library reading room. Keep a reduced number of separate private offices, small meeting rooms, cubicles etc. in case people need to do something that would annoy or distract others. Being disingenuous about these things is pointless, it just keeps people from reaching good compromise solutions.
- ashtonkem 7y agoThere are a small number of companies that do that, including 37signals. I think that few companies do that because setting cultural norms and rules like that is very hard, especially when companies are growing.
- MereInterest 7y agoI would add the caveat that "when companies are growing" only applies to startups, and not traditional new businesses. If you are doubling your headcount every 3 months, then of course you can't set cultural norms, because there isn't enough time. If you have a lower rate of growth, then you can teach new hires the culture as they come in, and it gets passed on.
- ghaff 7y ago"Library rules" are difficult in a lot of situations. Many job functions require a lot of time on the phone; it's not practical to be constantly seeking out conference rooms/alcoves for calls. Or, indeed, every time you want a word with someone. Companies can (and do) try to isolate different functions but it's always going to be an issue with more open environments.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoCubicles were an especial hypocrisy. They cost more per office than carpentered walls. In which case they made no sense at all.
- buttcoinslol 7y agoOffices cost more than cubes. An office needs a door, ceiling, lights, lighting control, sometimes a sidelight (window), floor/wall finishes, HVAC, along with a couple receptacles and a data opening. This costs more than an 8x8 cube.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoCeiling, lights, windows, HVAC already exist. Wiring is already needed (data,power) The difference is some wallboard and a hollow-core door. Don't underestimate the cost of that 8x8 cube, Its astronomical. Up to $10,000 though of course you can get crap for $500. When I built our office out, it cost $150 per walled-off office plus door.
- quickthrowman 7y agoIt cost $150 to have an office framed, dry walled, taped and muddled, and painted? Please explain how this is possible, the 5/8th drywall for both sides of the wall is practically that much for materials alone. That stuff doesn’t exist when a space is being completely remodeled either. I work in construction doing tenant improvements, so I see a lot of construction drawings.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoBut you understand, there's not a lot of difference in the lighting and power. Not fair to add that to the cost of offices, and then pretend its free for cubicles. My office buildout was 10 years ago. Prices change. Do we really think drywall in bulk is going to exceed $5000 per cube?
- 7y ago
- swebs 7y agoIf that were the only reason, then cubicles would be equally popular. For some reason companies want floor plans that do not allow your back to the wall, no partitions higher than sitting shoulder level, minimal sound or sight blocks. I think there must be some psychological effect they're taking advantage of when workers feel like they're being constantly watched from all angles.
- derefr 7y agoYou'd think, if it were so univerally taken-advantage-of, there'd be some studies in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Industrial_and_organizational_psychology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Industrial_and_organizational_... that can be pointed to as the source of all this.
- Vrondi 7y agoCubicles cost more and take up more space than just rows of desks.
- kingbirdy 7y agoOpen office seems to me to be even more space-efficient than cubicles. In an open office, I have 2-4 coworkers within arms reach. In a cubicle, everyone at least has a few feet of "bubble" in their cube.
- CinchWrench 7y agoConsistency space.
- AndrewKemendo 7y ago>the reason why open plan offices are a thing is that it drastically lowers the land cost per employee This argument never made sense. How is open office cheaper than WFH? Answer, it's not. It's just the cheaper option that also allows you to retain your illusion of control.
- sswezey 7y agoIt’s not being compared to WFH. It’s being compared to employees having private offices. You’re making a straw man argument.
- AndrewKemendo 7y agoIntentionally in order to point out that such an argument is a false dilemma. There are more options than [private office, open office]
- ashtonkem 7y agoThe jump from one office type to another is far less extreme than going from an in-person office to WFH. In the absence of strong external motivators, minor changes will be more preferred due to inertia effects.