16 ms·
> I quit in dismay at Amazon firing whistleblowers Assuming this is the real true reason (I would trust Tim, but you never know, so just being explicit here),
by simonebrunozzi 7y ago
> I quit in dismay at Amazon firing whistleblowers
Assuming this is the real true reason (I would trust Tim, but you never know, so just being explicit here), it takes huge balls to do something like this.
The economic loss has to be somewhat taken in relation to your total wealth (e.g. if you lose $1M by quitting but you already have $10M+ in the bank, it's not as hard as if you had zero in the bank), but still... Very few people would have the courage to walk away from big sums of money purely on principle.
Again, assuming this is all true, I admire Tim for this move, and plaude him. I had my issues with Amazon when I was there (2008-2014), some of them made me uncomfortable, but I would have never had the courage to walk away.
It also potentially damages Tim's ability to get hired in the future, as some other large organization might not like his behavior with Amazon and be reluctant to bring him on board. At the same time, hopefully there are smaller startups that want exactly this type of courage and rectitude and will hire him for his talents.
Good luck, Tim.
- nivenkos 7y agoAlso takes huge balls to publish an article about it publicly (rather than just resigning quietly). I'd be worried about being sued for defamation, etc.
- jdc 7y agoThe Streisand Effect helps to some degree there.
- simonebrunozzi 7y agoIANAL, but I think he didn't write anything that would put him in danger; plus, if Amazon would sue him, it would be one of the worst moves from a PR perspective.
- toyg 7y agoHe's Canadian and lives in Canada. Canadian laws on libel and defamation might be less oppressive than US ones (hopefully they're not as bad as in the UK).
- btilly 7y agoUS laws on libel and defamation are shockingly good. Free speech is woven into our culture and the Constitution. This post is squarely in the center of what is meant to be protected. UK laws are so horrible that the USA passed a law that UK libel judgements are not enforceable here. See https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-10940211 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-10940211 for more. Canada is somewhere between the two. Incidentally the country with the worst libel laws in the world is Australia.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoI'm pretty sure South Korea wins that contest: libel is a criminal offense and truth is not a sufficient defense. https://www.straitstimes.com/asia/east-asia/fighting-for-justice-in-south-korea-where-truth-can-be-a-crime https://www.straitstimes.com/asia/east-asia/fighting-for-jus...
- btilly 7y agoOuch. You’re right. Too bad I can no longer edit my comment
- TulliusCicero 7y ago> A growing number of alleged sex abusers are seeking to use legal actions of their own to force victims into silence or into dropping their accusations. > Filing a report to police is not in itself grounds for a defamation action, but if a rape victim goes public with their allegations, a criminal complaint can be filed against them. My God, that's horrifying.
- matthewheath 7y agoUK libel laws aren't that bad for situations like this — if he were sued in the UK, he could rely on the defence of honest opinion and I imagine he would prevail.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoit isn't defamation if it is true and I think everything not pertaining to Tim Bray was already a matter of public record.
- darkerside 7y agoAgreed. This takes more courage than quitting itself, in my opinion. What if he wrote this letter, sent it to the media, and then worked in good faith within Amazon to change things for the better? That seems like the hardest road, and also the one that might make the most difference.
- sulam 7y agoAs he said, you don’t go to the media when you’re a VP at a company. You go through channels. Anything else -would- make you radioactive, because it means you can’t be trusted to work at fixing things that you carry some responsibility for as a senior leader. Caveat: companies where everyone is a VP probably have another title that denotes senior leadership: Managing Director, Partner, etc.
- darkerside 7y agoWhile I see where you're coming from, "that's not how it's done" might not be the right answer when the things that are happening are already crossing ethical boundaries that are more serious than breaking with corporate traditions. I think I would agree that making media rounds would be a crude move, but there are actions you can take along a continuum before that (like this blog post) that might help apply external pressure while still having access to the internal levers. It reminds me a bit of Congresspeople who gain the courage to speak honestly after they've left their government roles. Yes, it's still courageous, and there are good reasons not to speak out while you're inside the system, but damn, you've just given up your best chance at making actual change.
- sulam 7y agoSomething I didn’t know before I became a VP at a middling tech co — as a senior leader, your actions are considered more reflective of the company in general and specifically legally. Obvious in hindsight, but an underling that gets fired is considered representative of not much. A VP, even if they get fired, opens the company to accusations that the behavior they were fired for is representative of the company, because of their role. For roles where you are a voice of the company, you need people who will use channels, because the alternative is literally bad for the company in ways that are very concrete. Put more viscerally, I would not want one of my peers going to the media before they talk to me and give me a chance to address their concerns.
- rsynnott 7y agoThere don’t really seem to be any factual claims in the article which weren’t previously public?
- reitzensteinm 7y agoI think you can trust that it's the real reason, because either way it's going to make him radioactive for the next gig like this. No large company keeps its hands completely clean. Defense contracts, Chinese censorship, exploiting addiction, anticompetitive behaviour, sexism, the list goes on. Having a public figure at your company that's willing to martyr themselves to push the knife in just a little deeper when you have a scandal is a dumb idea.
- wegs 7y agoHe's also 64. That's near retirement age, and I imagine he can afford to retire early.
- simonebrunozzi 7y agoI wouldn't dismiss how hard it can be to quit a job you love, just because you're 64. I know people that love doing what they do well in their late 70s, and job satisfaction for them is way more important than any monetary aspect.
- Symbiote 7y agoThere might be charities, non-profits or other organizations that would appreciate his skills. I remember my dad spent all of about two weeks "retired" (resigned in protest in similar circumstances, but from a staff of maybe 100) before finding a part-time job at a local charity he liked.
- labster 7y agoHe has a few reasons to retire -- and a few reasons not to retire. And he laid them out for us about a year and a half ago: https://www.tbray.org/ongoing/When/201x/2018/10/25/On-Retirement https://www.tbray.org/ongoing/When/201x/2018/10/25/On-Retire... > Progressive friends, people whose opinions I respect, give me shit about working for Amazon. I claim that the problem is capitalism, flaccid labor laws, and lame antitrust enforcement, not any particular company; maybe I’m right. And now he's basically admitting he was wrong. Impressive.
- sradman 7y agoIt doesn’t require huge balls, it requires ranking virtue signalling over monetary gain. Firing whistleblowers is a terrible thing but after forming/joining an activist group demanding that your employer addresess climate change, and promoting Naomi Klein as a spokesperson for the blue collar workers at the same corporation, I suspect that your ability to distinguish between whistleblower and social justice activist is compromised.
- morelisp 7y ago> ranking virtue signalling over monetary gain I'll cop to not being completely au fait with current right-wing rhetoric, but I thought a core part of "virtue signalling" (insofar as it might actually exist beyond "position I disagree with", which your post suggests it might not) was that it was low-effort / low-cost. In other words, no action where the alternative is non-trivial monetary gain could be virtue signalling. Between this and Bray's arrest for environment activism previously, I'd propose that this is not "virtue signalling" but simply being virtuous.
- DagAgren 7y agoIn pretty much every case, "virtue signalling" is code for "this person is being virtuous, and I don't like it".
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoright but there is a rhetorical undercurrent of this person doesn't really believe in this virtuous thing they are doing, and is thus a hypocrite. Because being a hypocrite is one of the top sins of our culture. Of course it is weird because the person doing the accusation of hypocrisy is actually against the virtuous act, and is thus for people not believing in the virtue. It's a weird rhetorical trick that sounds sort of unhinged the more you hear it.
- munchbunny 7y agoI've heard the same accusation being made by minorities, LGBT, women, etc. especially in the context of someone else, typically not from the less privileged group in that context, who is abusing the moral concern to shut down discussion rather than actually trying to help. One of my friends, as somewhat of an activist on these issues (I'm purposely staying vague for anonymity), has gotten exactly that type of vitriol from people who obviously see themselves as "woke". They got hit with some pretty nasty stuff that was pretty transparently moralistic character assassination rather than an honest attempt at disagreement. I'm impressed that they're able to continue working on these issues despite the crap they put up with from people who are supposedly on the same side of the issues. To put things into context, I hear/see the above issue orders of magnitude less often than people parroting right wing talking points, but in the cases where I think the accusation is well-founded, I don't think it's about hypocrisy at its root. I think it's about being disingenuous. Then again we may be using two words to mean the same thing.
- austincheney 7y agoHe has stated in the past that his short stint at Google gave him enough wealth that he never needs to work again. Tim is known for stating things on his blog that are easily interpreted as self-complementary so the real reason for him doing anything, as stated from his blog, is irrelevant.
- ex_amazon_sde 7y ago> it takes huge balls to do something like this. > The economic loss has to be somewhat taken in relation to your total wealth > Very few people would have the courage to walk away from big sums of money purely on principle. A good number of engineers refuse to even interview with FAANGs and other nasty companies on principle and they don't get any public praise.
- paulintrognon 7y agoIt's one thing to refuse interviews, and another thing to quit a job you love and invested 5 years of your life and that paysvery well.
- ex_amazon_sde 7y agoThe latter it's much easier: the stocks are vested after 5 years, the unspent disposable income is saved somewhere and now and you are ready to leave. Also the turnover of engineers in Amazon is among the highest in the industry and only a few stay beyond 5 years. In comparison, refusing to work for some FAANG takes 10 times more courage for someone out of college and without saving.
- otterley 7y agoTim himself acknowledged in his message that he’s leaving over a million dollars in unvested RSUs on the table by leaving.
- esoterica 7y agoIt's a little silly to talk about unvested RSUs as "leaving money on the table" when they are analogous to future unearned salary, which everyone by definition gives up when they quit a job. If you don't have any RSUs but you make $100k a year, and an actuarial table says you can expect to live for 50 more years, then you're theoretically "leaving $5 million on the table" when you quit your job, but no one describes it that way.
- artsyca 7y agoSomewhere between university and the present day we went from being idealistic to realistic to defeatist and the tone of this conversation stinks of pre-covid stereotypes let me guess you enjoy the free coffee and casual culture too much to walk away from a neo-fascist dictatorship with corporate characteristics or maybe you're mortgaged up to your eyeballs Edit: don't you think some liberal leaning corporate behemoth would want this guy whoever he is to use as a pawn because he took an ethical stand and can lend a patina of legitimacy to their gray area shady dealings? the world has suddenly become too complex for the IT crowd it seems
- artsyca 7y agoYea the downvotes are designed to create a climate of fear https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/z3bjpj/amazon-vp-tim-bray-resigns-calls-company-chickenshit-for-firing-protesting-workers https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/z3bjpj/amazon-vp-tim-bray... Look it's made the cool kid news
- kspacewalk2 7y agoJust out of curiosity, which neo-fascist dictatorship paying you lots of money did you walk away from? Which has offered you a job? An interview?
- artsyca 7y agoI've walked away from tons dude two mega corporations and an agency and at a heavy personal cost may I add but what choice did I have? Selling my ethics was too high a price Listen every large organization becomes a leftist surveillance state unless we drastically work against that tendency As systems professionals we should know that by now but we collectively turn a blind eye need I remind you who was selling counting machines to the bad guys during that war in Europe all those years ago? How many engineers had the courage to step into their 1:1 and indict their managers for treason back then? If you haven't become a corporate outcast by 40 you're a traitor Edit -- before you say it's my way of claiming sour grapes for my failings as a software engineer you shouldn't be surprised that every corporation is essentially the same corporation with different plutocrats at the helm repeating each other's tired monologues to the same masses of unwashed pizza eating feature trolls It's the same in north America as it is in socialist dictatorships only here the managers pretend they're our friends and there they're our dads
- nicoburns 7y ago> Very few people would have the courage to walk away from big sums of money purely on principle. On the contrary, bucketloads of people do this all the time. The world would be a better place if more people did.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoCitation needed. From what I've seen, there tends to be other reasons, and the ethical issues are at best the straw that broke the camel's back, and at worst cover for quitting ahead of getting fired. (For avoidance of doubt, I'm not saying either is the case here.)
- take_a_breath 7y agoPeople work in less profitable industries and choose less-profitable majors all-the-time. Teaching, non-profit, nursing and research are fields where the pay doesn’t always match the schooling or knowledge required.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoSure, I'll grant you that, but it's much harder to give up something you already have than to abstain from something you don't have.
- Symbiote 7y agoI'm surely not the only one here who declines or ignores messages from headhunters for companies with politics or technology I fundamentally disagree with.
- SubiculumCode 7y agoThis is just extemporizing to deny a strong point...and in any case, it is easier to give up on an income of you have a lot in the bank.
- bob33212 7y ago
- _ta_2323221 7y agoSo as an already rich person he forewent becoming slightly richer after realizing his work supported an exploitative system that happily puts low-level employees at risk for the financial benefit of the company? A true hero indeed. Sorry for being slightly sarcastic here, but Amazon has a long history of treating its warehouse workers badly, that behavior didn't start with Covid-19. I find it a bit hypocritical therefore to become rich on the back of such a system and then, from a comfortable position of privilege and wealth, grandly declare that you will no longer partake in it. I realize he worked for AWS but it still supports the same company and provides the infrastructure they surveil and control their workers with. I think who deserves more credit here are the workers that protested their treatment, which are often paid only slightly over minimum wage and don't have any savings that they can live off before landing another high-paying job.
- Waterluvian 7y ago> Very few people would have the courage to walk away from big sums of money purely on principle. I think assuming this is revealing of one's own attitude more than anything. I also feel like big companies have people convinced that they're being paid a lot because they're exceptional or special in some way. Really, they're being compensated for either stress or location or working more than 40 hours or giving away their morals. I say this because I know a few people who made this kind of decision. And speaking with them about it, it wasn't difficult. They just had a more complete compensation model to evaluate against.
- st1ck 7y ago> if you lose $1M by quitting but you already have $10M+ in the bank Losing money is hard, but if you reframe it as being rewarded $1M (with pretty low marginal utility after $10M) by losing your freedom, then such a choice is only rational.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gumby 7y ago> Assuming this is the real true reason (I would trust Tim, but you never know, so just being explicit here), it takes huge balls to do something like this. Agree: People can quit and say what they want. People in high paying jobs can quit and often find an equivalent replacement; perhaps have one lined up before they leave; in such a case the impact is limited. But if you quit on principle and take a public stand on it other large companies are more likely to treat your decision as a sign you are dangerous. So it takes not just the ability but also the willingness to take such action.
- koheripbal 7y agoHe even alludes to it in his post when he mentions that he generally dislikes the toxic culture at Amazon.
- gumby 7y agoDespite having a few friends who like it, by and large “toxic environment” has been the impression I've gotten from most people I know who have worked there, so I’ve never applied.
- ubermonkey 7y agoSeriously great move by Tim. He has power and celebrity (of a sort), so he's likely insulated from any real blowback here, but it definitely makes Amazon looks very, very shitty. Well, shittier. Anyway, this is what a principled tech leader looks like.
- throw_m239339 7y agoI am glad he said it so that people here can't claim it is not happening. I'm also glad he is making clear these policies come from the top at Amazon so that people can't claim that Bezos knows nothing about that and isn't involved in any of this. These are the most important things to me. People with principles are rare these days. And people here can't just spin these stories into something else now.
- koheripbal 7y agoIn his post, he states... > It’s evidence of a vein of toxicity running through the company culture. So clearly he's had other issues and encounters with the toxic work culture there. It really shouldn't be any surprise that people usually have multiple reasons for quitting their job.
- stronglikedan 7y ago> people here can't claim it is not happening > people can't claim that Bezos knows nothing about that and isn't involved in any of this. All of this assumes that people will believe Tim. People still can claim those things simply by saying they don't believe him.
- joeys7 7y agoHe is the only person resigning at Amazon over these firings. I’ve seen other emails sent to the activist email lists over people resigning due to this. But he’s the most high profile. I have tolerated a lot of evilness from Amazon and justified it as a “different organization”. I work in Amazon Music which isn’t responsible for facial recognition or warehouse abuses. But seeing them fire whistleblowers... that’s just heartbreaking to watch. Makes me want to quit too. The only reason I haven’t yet is to keep up the activism.
- clevergadget 7y agodo it keep it up dont quit, he should have made them fire him for his activism rather than walk away. mad respect to him but there are better ways to go.
- iancmceachern 7y agoI disagree, I think it makes him more hirable. I guess it depends, perhaps he is less hirable at a company that values profits over humanity, but definitely more hirable at a company that values humanity over profit.
- ashconnor 7y agoAssuming Tim is in Canada he's probably not eligible for Employment Insurance too.
- sachdevap 7y agoI don't think employment insurance concerns him. He has earned way too much money for that to be a problem.
- cowpig 7y agoStarting the comment with "assuming this is the real reason" seems disingenuous in a post that seems to be supportive of the author. But that it's repeated again in the 3rd paragraph, and that the final paragraph then mentions that it'll make Tim "hard to hire"? There's no basis in evidence: Tim's wikipedia page shows a history of activism consistent with taking this kind of stand, and a staggering resume that indicates it's unlikely he'll have any trouble finding work if he wants it. I'm pretty disappointed in HN that this is the top-voted comment on this article..
- berryjerry 7y agoThere are always multiple reasons. As people below had pointed out he is 64 and already planning on retiring per announcements a year ago. This is another reason on top of the previous ones he stated. The straw that broke the camels back?
- craigsmansion 7y ago> There's no basis in evidence It's hard to rise to the top in a morally lax organisation without making some compromises on the way there. Furthermore, it's easy to take a stand when you're financially secure because of those compromises. So in my opinion the OP is right: it's good for Tim to take a stance if truly, deep down, he feels this is morally wrong, but ultimately him being outspoken means little when compared to those who did the right thing from the start and as such never got a position to make a headline on HN in the first place. Tim is assured of a cozy job with a "good guy" startup regardless. If genuine, it's certainly a personal victory for him, but it doesn't mean much for the rest of us (except, cynically, that selling out and then raising your profile by denouncing the party you sold out to is a valid career path).
- abvdasker 7y agoI agree that the subtext of the parent comment makes it seem a lot like concern trolling. Even if it is sincere, the qualifications riddled throughout the comment totally undercut any message of support the author may have intended.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ignoramous 7y ago> Very few people would have the courage to walk away from big sums of money purely on principle. No shit. Cognitive dissonance (in justification of Amazon's policies) even from some of the smartest people I know is a sight to behold: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16249272 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16249272
- CobrastanJorji 7y agoThat's a pretty amazing comment. I worked at Amazon many years ago and recall many convesations where it was generally agreed that we were surely being paid better than at other tech companies because the compensation at other tech companies included all of the perks. It wasn't remotely true, but it had to be true, because we were all smart people, and we were still here, weren't we?
- madeofpalk 7y ago> It also potentially damages Tim's ability to get hired in the future, as some other large organization might not like his behavior with Amazon and be reluctant to bring him on board For what it's worth, I'm sure he would consider this a feature. Given his already stated beliefs, I'm sure he wouldn't want to work at a company that would be turned off by this. (just to be clear, I don't actually know Tim. I've never heard of him before this).
- code_duck 7y ago>Very few people would have the courage to walk away from big sums of money purely on principle. Some people are wise enough to understand that having 20 million vs 10 million does not actually do much to improve your quality of life.
- VRay 7y agoEDIT: Wait a second, I wasn't able to read TFA originally since it was overloaded with traffic. It's back up now, and I can see that Tim Bray was a VP.. This will probably have some impact on him getting more jobs as a VP at FAANG corps, haha. I doubt he'll have trouble finding ethical employment and/or starting his own company though... > It also potentially damages Tim's ability to get hired in the future Can confirm that it'll have zero effect. I know a guy who, when he left Amazon, sent an e-mail to about 5,000 people parodying the scene from Half Baked where the guy curses out his coworkers and quits. Amazon's HR was furious with him, but all that came of it was that they didn't give him severance pay. He didn't have any higher purpose in quitting either, he just wanted more money and to work on something more interesting somewhere else. Apparently he's on some sort of blacklist within Amazon, but he's been doing fine at another FAANG company for years.
- cbsmith 7y agoIt might make certain large organizations reluctant to bring him on board, but I imagine those organizations wouldn't be places he'd like to work. I think there will be other large organizations that would be more inclined to hire him; if nothing else, this makes hiring him a good branding exercise with other employees. Maybe I'm overly optimistic, but I'd like to think at least when you are talented enough, sticking true to your nature probably serves you better than to do otherwise.
- cbsmith 7y agoAs expected: https://twitter.com/timbray/status/1257383599424315397 https://twitter.com/timbray/status/1257383599424315397
- pbreit 7y agoGuessing he was able to leave because he is financially stable.
- Naracion 7y agoAs cowpig has mentioned in another comment, I also doubt Tim would have trouble finding other opportunities if he wants to. However, as Tim says: "The victims weren’t abstract entities but real people; here are some of their names: Courtney Bowden, Gerald Bryson, Maren Costa, Emily Cunningham, Bashir Mohammed, and Chris Smalls." What about these people that were fired? When people get fired for whistle blowing, what does that mean for their future job prospects? Does it severely hurt your chances at a faang? As a PhD student of color guided by a moral compass who has to make employment decisions soon, this is an important question for me.
- efa 7y agoI'm not sure why he includes: "I’m sure it’s a coincidence that every one of them is a person of color, a woman, or both. Right?" Is race as issue here? I thought they were fired for whistle blowing? Is he saying a white whistle blower wouldn't have been fired?