4 ms·
> Developers in particular don't generally care about security, so selling Rust as a "secure" language is not going to be enough. You do realize that OpenBSD i
by hedora 7y ago
> Developers in particular don't generally care about security, so selling Rust as a "secure" language is not going to be enough.
You do realize that OpenBSD is, by far, the most secure general purpose operating system specifically due to decades of thankless work by people like Theo de Raadt, right?
I don’t think healthy skepticism of Rust is strong enough evidence to conclude that they don’t care about security.
- staticassertion 7y ago> You do realize that OpenBSD is, by far, the most secure general purpose operating system specifically due to decades of thankless work by people like Theo de Raadt, right? Yes, I think it is fair to say that I am very familiar with all of this information. I work in information security, and was quite into Linux kernel security for a while. I disagree with your assertion about it being the most secure general purpose OS but I'm not gonna go there :) > I don’t think healthy skepticism of Rust is strong enough evidence to conclude that they don’t care about security. Cool, that was not my conclusion either. I'm saying that Rust's value proposition in general includes memory safety and I think that it's not compelling for most developers, especially with regards to rewrites of low-value attack surface.
- cosmojg 7y ago> I disagree with your assertion about it being the most secure general purpose OS but I'm not gonna go there :) Could you please go there? I'm very curious what the contenders for "most secure general purpose OS" might be.
- staticassertion 7y agoI think geofft's points go a long way. I think having this conversation would require a lot though - what is "Secure" what is "general purpose". Is OpenBSD even general purpose? Is the base install general purpose? What makes an OS secure? I think maybe as a "with 0 configuration to the OS/ services" OpenBSD could be a top contender. With "I have practical security challenges to solve and I'm willing to change things in this system" I might choose Linux. If I'm handing a laptop out to an employee or friend, maybe a Chromebook, or even Windows! It's a pretty nuanced discussion that I couldn't do justice to without really caring and feeling that everyone involved in the conversation is equally invested/ coming in with the right attitude, which is impossible on an internet forum.
- pnako 7y agoWell, there is only one real "general purpose" OS that runs on supercomputers, mainframes, servers, laptops, tablets, mobile and embedded, and that's Linux. So it's also the most secure.
- geofft 7y agoI thought it was the most secure general purpose operating system because it's so rarely used - especially for use cases like running untrusted code in unprivileged accounts - that it's a low-value target. Sure, OpenBSD doesn't have exploitable security holes when used as e.g. a packet router, but when was the last time Linux did? OpenBSD's website says things like "Only two remote holes in the default install, in a heck of a long time!", but remote holes in the default install is such a small surface on any OS (besides e.g. Windows XP). When was the last time you saw a remote hole in the default install of, say, Ubuntu desktop? macOS? The Amazon Linux AMI? The interesting vulnerabilities are in server software that isn't running by default, local privilege escalation, etc. Also, weren't there like four security bugs in December, at least one of which was remotely exploitable?
- monadic2 7y ago> Sure, OpenBSD doesn't have exploitable security holes when used as e.g. a packet router, but when was the last time Linux did? didn’t linux move a packet routing vm into the kernel in the last ten years? I’d say chances are high there are multiple exploitable holes just based on time and surface area alone.
- a1369209993 7y ago> When was the last time you saw a remote hole in the default install of, say, Ubuntu desktop? Literally right now, with snaps. If you only mean unintentional remote holes, and not deliberate backdoors, then we have very different ideas of what "most secure general purpose operating system" means. Also, BSD doesn't generally actively refuse to fix security holes when thousands of people compain about them.
- geofft 7y agoGranting your framing for the sake of argument, then we've got one remote hole in a heck of a long time in Ubuntu desktop, and still nothing in macOS or Amazon Linux. I'm certainly not claiming that any of these OSes is better than OpenBSD. I'm claiming they're all about the same, and the "OpenBSD cares more about security than everyone else" narrative isn't actually based in evidence. OpenBSD has a particular view of security, which they care about very much, and OpenBSD has done some very cool and precedent-setting things - but that particular view is applicable to narrow use cases, and other people quite reasonably care about other parts, while incorporating versions of innovations from OpenBSD too. Also, if I understand your unstated argument correctly, even if we don't admit a difference between unintentional remote holes and "deliberate backdoors," there's still a huge and meaningful difference between remote holes that can be exploited by a tiny number of people and remote holes that can be exploited by anyone.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]