3 ms·
Optional technologies or services are optional until they aren't. So now we are going to go down the whole “Minority Report* rabbithole and make laws just in c
by scarface74 7y ago
Optional technologies or services are optional until they aren't.
So now we are going to go down the whole “Minority Report* rabbithole and make laws just in case? You don’t tie your login infrastructure with Google, you use Oauth 2 and plugin any third party you wish.
Representative governments answer, however imperfectly, to the governed.
How well is that working out in the US between gerrymandering, the electoral vote having an opposite outcome than the popular vote, and how it is almost impossible to get rid of an incumbent?
Email self-provisioning has significant hurdles for even technically-competent individuals let alone the general public.
I didn’t say set up your own email server. I said create your own domain. You can create your own domain with your own email address with a few clicks on Godaddy. If you don’t like GoDaddy, there a dozens on other places that will transfer your MX record to them and you keep your own email address.
- dredmorbius 7y agoDepending on your jurisdiction, there are numerous laws and regulations governing private busines-individual services and relationships, including those concening employment, housing, transport, communications, lending, banking, data services, healthcare, barber and cosmetologist services, food, drink, lodging, gambling, theatre, insurance, brokerage servises, funeral and burial services,and others. Regulations serve to create a common and uniform floor of service levels. The problem with a strictly voluntaryist, free-market, laissez-faire approach is that it tends strongly to a Gresham's law "bad terms drive out good" race-to-the-bottm dynamic, particularly unfortunate when there is but one monopoly provider on the market. This occurs well before reaching the far end of the slippery slope on which you seem to be perched. Several of my earlier comments have been badly misapprehended, I'll not belabour them though I'll note the fact.
- megous 7y agoGresham's law doesn't work in strictly free market economy. By definition, debased coins will drive out regular coins only if you force the acceptance of both coins at face value. It only works under legal tender laws. If people read the conditions of the free google account they realize that the service can be terminated at any time for any reason without warning, and there's absolutely nothing there about any corrective mechanisms. Contrast this with terms of [especially national] domain name ownership. Anyway, given the number of people who will give their data to such a service under such conditions, you may well be right that some regulation would be useful, especially around getting your data out in some short time period after account termination. (But only to holders of the valid authentication credentials.) Forced email address portability would be also nice (provider would have to forward incomming emails for a reasonable fee or for free), for some limited time, maybe a year.
- dredmorbius 7y agoSee: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22927202 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22927202 https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/search?q=gresham%27s+law+management&restrict_sr=on&sort=relevance&t=all https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/search?q=gresham%27s+la...