8 ms·
Microsoft is infesting Windows 10 with annoying ads (2017)
- netcoyote 7y agoGreat! When Windows gets awful enough, it will actually be the year of Linux Desktop.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kylebenzle 7y agoAgree. I can't understand why anyone is still on windows or mac os. The world does not make sense.
- metalforever 7y agoAdobe and VR
- DoofusOfDeath 7y agoCan you elaborate about the VR? I'm starting to look into a Valve Index setup on a Linux gaming PC. But I'm unclear about what kind of VR goodness I'd miss by avoiding Windows 10.
- somebodynew 7y agoVR is only usable if the game and the entire supporting stack works perfectly (graphics drivers, USB 3 controller, power management etc). There are tight framerate/latency requirements and everything goes through intricate off-screen rendering as VR headsets don't pretend to be an additional monitor anymore. This leads to two classes of major problems: total failure (crashing outright) and stuttering (low framerate, high latency, or occasional "hiccups"). These are equally unacceptable (stuttering ruins VR and can make you feel ill). It is difficult enough to avoid these issues on Windows where the OS vendor, the graphics card vendor, the motherboard vendor, the game developer, and the VR rendering API developer are focusing their attention and releasing frequent patches to fix VR issues. There seems to be a general opinion that an Nvidia GPU on Windows 10 is the standard VR development target. If VR doesn't work perfectly for you on Linux, it's going to be a pain to sort it out, assuming that's even possible without hoping a third party releases an updated binary blob in the future. Valve does pay attention to Linux and provide SteamVR support, but they haven't officially released Half-Life: Alyx for Linux yet. They will probably release more information about compatibility when they do.
- BubRoss 7y agoAdobe definitely keeps people off of linux, although it is a shake, because linux or not, their software is terrible for most things compared to alternatives.
- dorkwood 7y agoPC gamers. Graphic designers who can't afford a Mac workstation. 3D artists who use 3rd party render software such as Octane. I'm sure there are many other groups that I'm unfamiliar with.
- deadbunny 7y ago> PC Gamers Baring games with anticheat you can play pretty much any game release within the last 20+ years with Wine + Proton + DXVK/D9VK. Usually with minimal fussing. You can check out ProtonDB[1] to see if you favorite game works. 1. https://www.protondb.com/ https://www.protondb.com/
- whyhow 7y agoI tried Ubuntu for the first time in years last month. At first I was pretty happy with it, but gradually I grew frustrated. Every time I would install a new library in R (statistical programming language) I would have to spend 10-15 minutes trying to figure out why it didn't work. I'd end up in this deep rabbit hole of missing dependencies that I never had a problem with in MacOS or windows
- fishstamp82 7y agoI would recommend arch linux, everything exists in the aur and most things work out of the box. Dont buy the hype that arch is hard, its a really simple system imo.
- ohazi 7y agoThe setup process for Arch is challenging, but it can be a rewarding exercise if you want to have a better understanding of how a Linux system is put together. It's like Linux from Scratch, but less time consuming, and you end up with a system that you can actually use when you're finished. But yeah, once it's set up, and you've figured out how things typically work in Arch (e.g. you install a package first, but nothing is enabled by default - you have to decide how you want it to start), it's a great system. You'll learn how to actually use systemd, and will generally have a better feel for how everything is supposed to function, which will make you better at investigating things when they break, or when they don't work out of the box, even on other systems. Also the Arch wiki is an amazing resource regardless of what you're running. I don't necessarily have any reservations about recommending Arch to a beginner, but you do have to be curious and willing to learn. People who tried Linux and then got frustrated because some piece of software didn't work quite right out of the box probably wouldn't enjoy using Arch.
- kjsthree 7y agoManjaro takes the edge off Arch. After having tended my Arch garden for a year or so (very grateful for all the learning) I’m happy with the balance of some handholding without losing the AUR.
- ramshorns 7y ago
- auxym 7y agoMS Office
- 29athrowaway 7y agohttps://www.freeoffice.com/en/ https://www.freeoffice.com/en/ Pretty convenient, has a ribbon interface same as MS Office. Honestly I can't even tell the difference. Except for one thing: It doesn't take as long to start, and doesn't require a supercomputer to run with a decent performance. Lotus 1-2-3 or Quattro Pro on a 286 feels faster than Excel.
- NullPrefix 7y agoGot excited for a while until I've noticed that this office is free as in free beer, not free as in freedom.
- 29athrowaway 7y agoStill better than staying on Windows only because of MS Office. LibreOffice, Caligra Office (formerly KOffice) and Gnome Office (Abiword, Gnumeric) are not quite there yet.
- Marsymars 7y agoEvery time I try a Linux desktop, I find it unpleasant and/or time consuming to use. If I use it for long enough that I get used to it, it's a breath of fresh air when I do go back to macOS or Windows. They just don't have the UI/UX polish I want.
- intopieces 7y agoAgreed, it’s telling that all the discussions about switching to Linux get right to “... and all you need to do it compile your own trackpad, WiFi, and display drivers. Sleep doesn’t quite work and scaling on HiDPI is still broken, but at least you’re not using Windows...” Linux guys, I love you, I really do, but please spare a thought for those of us whose jobs and personal commitments don’t permit us to tweak our set-ups ad infinitum before you recommend the switch. Computers are fun, but we also need to get work done.
- fouric 7y agoHave you actually tried installing Linux on a computer recently, or just read discussions? If you've actually tried it and ran into issues that required you to compile your own drivers, either you're using a user-hostile (users != programmers) distro like Arch or you might have just gotten unlucky. None of the computers I've used with Linux over the past nine years have had more than two small issues (all of which I was able to fix within a few days), and two of my boxes had no issues at all. Hardware support in Linux is so much better than it was two decades ago.
- polotics 7y agoI concur. Linux usage has been seamless in comparison with MacOs or Windows from my PoV, for at least 5 years.
- jjdredd 7y agoI wouldn't say that Linux maintenance is completely smooth for me, but if something happens it's usually due to my own poor attention. OTOH Windows 10 is determined to force its updates on me at the most inconvenient times. Once I left Windows 10 to update over night, to be greeted with grub rescue screen in the morning. Took me most of the next day to fix things. Linux isn't perfect but at least it doesn't break everything and I'm the one in control of things.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- abdulhaq 7y agoWifi drivers, bluetooth drivers, printer drivers, graphics card drivers. Drivers. I'm a fan of linux and used it as my primary OS for over a decade. Now Windows 10 is good enough and is less hassle.
- sempron64 7y agoThis is my anecdote, but when using crummy old printers and scanners I've had a lot more luck with Ubuntu just working out of the box with them (with maybe a selection dialog), but I had to hunt down and download the driver software on the Internet on Windows 7. With Windows 10 I've had a better experience where it has generally found drivers through Windows Update. So drivers are mixed bag on any OS, I think.
- boomlinde 7y agoHaving drivers maintained in-tree probably gives Linux an edge over Windows when it comes to old hardware.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- BubRoss 7y agoEven just on the surface, linux interfaces are nowhere close to the refinement of the windows 7 UI.
- lone_haxx0r 7y agoAs someone who uses Linux as their main OS, I can tell you a few: 1. Ugly UIs: Of all the distros I've tried, the only one that doesn't make me wanna gouge my eyes out is Ubuntu. Most Linux users seem to have accustomed to ugly UIs to the point that they don't notice their ugliness anymore. 2. Bad UX: I've been using Gnome shell for 2 years and I still don't understand it. I never remember if ALT+TAB switches between groups of windows or between windows, or between windows in the same group. Or was that ALT+ESC?. I've never had such issues on Windows. Am I just too stupid for Gnome? Also, why do I have to edit 2 obscure files (from the POV of a regular user) in order to have a simple 'show desktop' button in my taskbar? Also, why do I have to install an external application (Gnome tweak tool) to disable mouse acceleration? And if you're not on Gnome, good luck trying to use libinput (used by Linux Mint and Ubuntu Mate) directly, because for some bizarre reason the "flat acceleration profile" setting is ignored if you're using a touchpad. Also, why do I have to install an external plugin and edit an obscure file to have audio compression/normalization when Windows has a single checkbox that reads "Enable audio normalization" Also, why does PulseAudio start to crackle each time I open reader mode on Firefox? * Note: You can choose a desktop environment with decent UX, but it will look ugly (xfce). Or you can choose a DE that looks good but has bad UX (Gnome Shell with Ubuntu customizations) 3. If the app you want isn't in your distro repos, you have 2 choices: a) Install a ppa whose server doesn't work anymore, so now each time you update your repos, there'll be ugly warnings about the dead server. Now you have to Google "how to remove ppa" and choose between 5 articles telling you 5 different ways to do it. b) download a .tar.gz and spend 1 hour installing the right dependencies the right way, and then 'make'ing and 'make install'ing only to find that there's some obscure error. After all of this, I still use Linux because I think Windows is slightly worse overall. But would totally understand why some people still choose Windows.
- sergeykish 7y agoIt looks similar to my experience ten years ago. Ubuntu is hardly manageable. It breaks once you tweak. I've switched to Arch: * no Gnome, use simple DE * ALSA, no audio normalization, no cracks * AUR https://aur.archlinux.org/ https://aur.archlinux.org/ - it has everything, if not building package is simple with PKGBUILD It is beautiful under skin.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- som33 7y ago>Agree. I can't understand why anyone is still on windows or mac os. The world does not make sense. Because the average person is a moron, that's how we have steam, mmo's, uplay, origin, etc. DRM and windows 10 with drm in it is a sign of idiocracy. Remember there was a time when there was no steam, origin, uplay, aka we got honestly coded software, complete games with dedicated servers and level editors. That stopped because the companies realizing their customers were computer illiterate morons beyond their wildest imagination.
- nexuist 7y agoThe average person is not a moron. The average person has a job and a family not related to computer science and does not want to spend 8+ hours editing configuration files and compiling drivers just so they can print a poster for their daughter's graduation.
- som33 7y agoYou don't seem to understand any piece of software that is running between two computers, means you no longer own your machine and they can do whatever they want to it, you are running corporately hacked software. The level of stupid comming out of HN commentariat is alarming. You're literally buying internet dongle enabled software, aka something someone stupid would be doing. Imagine in the 90's you bought a PC and windows required a second disc and an ethernet cable coupled to the back of a staples store you bought it in. That's "software as a service", aka something morons would do. Whenever you don't get a complete piece of software you are literally being robbed, the fact Hacker news commentators think themselves "hackers" while supporting defective software, means your brains aren't working. The idea that having microsoft and big companies ability to spy on everything you do is somehow enlightened is nonsense, you're an idiot building a turnkey tyranny, if politics ever goes south all these companies will have all the data they want about you and your behavior and you'll morn the day you gave away your basic rights to privacy for stupid consumer convenience.
- modzu 7y agoi had a time sensitive mission critial task for work a few months ago. had to reboot and windows 10 began a forced automatic update. the next day i installed debian and i have not looked back, its a glorious feeling to have control of my own computer again!!! very stable and very fast. it used to take me like 10 seconds to open phpstorm (turns out that's windows defender at work). takes 1s on linux. try it!!!
- tfehring 7y agoThe Year of the Linux Desktop will be 10 years after you can set up a Linux desktop, including installing all the software you need, without opening the terminal. Anyone who distributes software for Linux end users but doesn't include a one-click installer should keep this in mind.
- TheAdamAndChe 7y agoGreat! We're like a year away from that then. I remember installing Ubuntu in 2011 with no issues. It installed with Windows using a burned CD, and had a store that I could download everything from. Updates were via gui. Of course I played with the terminal because I was a geek, but a layman could use and update the computer with absolutely no issue.
- freediver 7y agoCountdown to free, ad-monetized Windows has started.
- pugworthy 7y agoIt already is essentially free. I did a full install the other day on a new computer build and didn’t need a key. All it does is put an always on, fairly innocuous message in the lower right corner of the screen.
- 29athrowaway 7y agoBusinesses and governments get their licenses audited though. That's where the bulk of the money is.
- ViViDboarder 7y agoI’ve become increasingly annoyed with this trend. Apple is doing it too on iOS, though the ads are all for first party products. If you use Apple News you can’t turn off all the teaser headlines for News+. If you use 4Gb of your free iCloud storage you’ll be pestered with “Upgrade” notifications. Similarly, it’s a little more expected on the web, but I used to have YouTube Premium and now that I’ve canceled, every new YouTube session has a pitch for premium.
- jmuguy 7y agoOh don't worry, even if you never showed one iota of interest in Youtube Premium and skip every single annoying popup related to it - you'll still get asked every single time you open the app.
- cptskippy 7y agoI pulled up YouTube on my Model 3 the other day and it gave me a 1/3 screen ad for Premium.
- cm2187 7y agoAnd nagging for Apple Pay, Apple Music. Like I don't think any version of Windows ever had as many annoying modal dialogs than modern iOS.
- wayneftw 7y agoI can’t use Spotify(premium!) without having a freaking in-app pop up on iOS too. I’m actually thinking about going back to pirating music and just building my own player that load things off of S3.
- NullPrefix 7y agoWhy the main picture of the article contains a depiction of upside down person behind two bars?
- derision 7y agoIt's a medal icon like kind of thing
- nonfamous 7y agoPublished Mar 17, 2017.
- DoofusOfDeath 7y agoIt would be nice if someone could update the title. I only clicked on the link because I thought it was news.
- dang 7y agoUpdated.
- mike50 7y ago2017
- dpau 7y agoyes OP pls update title, this has been going on for years now
- Priem19 7y agoPick your flavor of Linux: https://distrowatch.com https://distrowatch.com. I recommend Xubuntu, but whatever, as long as it's not Windows 10.
- ModernMech 7y agoLinux distros aren't exactly immune to this kinds of thing. Remember this? https://lifehacker.com/how-to-remove-amazon-ads-from-ubuntu-12-10-5953180 https://lifehacker.com/how-to-remove-amazon-ads-from-ubuntu-...
- Symbiote 7y agoThat was once, on one distribution, 8 years ago.
- AdrianB1 7y agoThe article on the Verge is also 3 years old.
- black_puppydog 7y ago1. So you could disable them entirely? --> Not the same situation then, is it? 2. Choose any other distro and be done. I was very unhappy about the shopping lens, but these two don't really play in the same league.
- ModernMech 7y agoI don't have any ads on my Windows 10 desktop, so how is it not the same? Apparently I must have disabled them all. The implication of throwing up a link to distrowatch and claiming "pick a flavor" is that you won't have this kind of issue with Linux. When in fact even if you choose a distro without ads you may find yourself upgrading one day and surprise! There are ads all of a sudden!
- blibble 7y agoso as a consumer where can I get a copy of the version of Windows without the ads?
- cs702 7y agoClearly, this is a far more intrusive alternative than web advertising. Many advertisers surely love the idea of being able to advertise "from below the application layer," via the operating system itself, using ever bit of data they can collect directly from you, from the heart of your computer, bypassing browsers, ad-blockers, firewalls, ISPs, etc. Looks like this is the inevitable future -- I mean, present -- of Windows, Android, and iOS. :-(
- som33 7y agoIt's almost like humanity is too stupid to understand when you buy criminally coded stolen software as a service, you will get screwed. The fact that parts of the OS functionality are living on some remote server is a sign of idiocracy. Steam, origin, uplay, epic games store, Windows 10, are all signs humanity is stupid. Watching the entire tech community steal software from the public beginning in 1997 with ultima online was enlightening. No one should complain about windows 10 ads, you literally bought an OS that is fraudulently coded, there is no reason for any OS to be client-server. It's exactly the same as buying windows 95 or XP with missing files and a missing CD/DVD that they didn't give you which is sitting in some remote servers drive.
- saagarjha 7y agoI must be too stupid to understand why you think Windows is “fraudulently coded” or why communicating with a server is stupid…
- pjmlp 7y agoA survivor from the M$ days I guess.
- som33 7y agoI can tell you the facts an the figures and you won't reason to the right conclusion, see the science: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYmi0DLzBdQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYmi0DLzBdQ Why would anyone buy an incomplete piece of software or software that can be disabled remotely unless they were stupid about a corporations intent? Which is what windows 10 is by the way, why would you buy a PC which microsoft literally can tell you what you can and what you can't do with your computing device? You don't seem to get the entire tech industry knows mots of our species is stupid, they can't believe how dumb humanity is. That's why they celebrating the death of software ownership and the gullibility of humans.
- friendlybus 7y agoThe idea of using reason against itself so that you can conflate two separate categories; feelings and emotions is fundamentally wrong. Every step you take down the emotionality path away from the mind, is a step towards pools of emotion being sucked up into heirarchy and class. Mommy will be there at the end of the day to clean up the garbage wilfully dumb people create and she will freeze emotional hearts still with enough guilt that the heart can no longer beat without permission. If thats the road you want to take so that you can spend a few years playing with the toys lying around, then at least make another Simpsons show so that the dumb can self signal their mindless emotional state non-destructively to the rest of us and we wont have to forcefully limit the zombie invasion.
- meddlepal 7y ago2017.
- 29athrowaway 7y agoSwitch to Linux. No telemetry, no forced updates, no ads.
- ecmascript 7y agoI love Windows 10 except for the ads and the intrusive spyware installed. This is why I stopped being a .NET developer and went all in on open source stuff. Switched to Ubuntu and Fedora and today they are so good there is really no reason to use Windows for most folks. My dad now uses Ubuntu, he doesn't seem to really notice any big difference since he mostly use the web browser anyway. My grandma uses Ubuntu and my mother used to but now have a Macbook. The only negative thing with running linux is that some hardware has much worse support still to this day.
- bzb3 7y ago(laughs in LTSC)
- pacamara619 7y agoIn other news: sky blue, water wet.
- noxer 7y agoI admit you need to uninstall a bunch of crap when you first install Windows 10. That sure sucks but its not a Windows thing. You get default apps on every platform and the more of an "advanced" user you are the more likely you will need to replace them. For a majority of people these apps are however what they will use so kinda makes sense to have them preinstalled. Even for games, people would find it weird if no game was present. Every windows they can remember had games preinstalled. Anyway simply remove what you don't need including OneDrive and you will not get ads or notification. Lock screen and stat menu can be configured to not show tips or recommended apps. The store itself can even be de-installed (if you don't need it). Obviously everything is opt-out but that has been the case since ever. PS: There are powershell scripts to automate cleanup if you have to do this regularly its just a github search away.
- holri 7y ago>You get default apps on every platform and the more of an >"advanced" user you are the more likely you will need to >replace them. This is not true for me with Debian.
- noxer 7y agoIt certainly is if you can find any platform that comes with Debian. You may pick your distro and even pick predefined software collections you want to have installed or simply install only the core. But really thats not the point. You can build your personal windows 10 image an replace the default apps too.
- holri 7y agoYou can not compare the debian software repository with a windows 10 image. I do not need to buy new hardware often because Debian runs nice even on very old hardware. I type this on a computer 14 years old, that just got apt-get dist-upgrade since then. You can not do that with Windows.
- noxer 7y ago
- xook 7y agoI know this is three years old, but my question remains the same (for lack of data) – Is this localized to non-Pro or Enterprise editions of Windiws 10? I haven't seen this behavior anywhere on my machine. Then again, I don't use any of the default applications, and I've spent many an hour going through every tiny setting wrt privacy/analytics settings. The only place I've seen this crop up is a relative's computer which is the Home edition.