4 ms·
So what laws do you want the government to pass and do you trust government politicians to actual make intelligent laws regarding the internet?
by scarface74 7y ago
So what laws do you want the government to pass and do you trust government politicians to actual make intelligent laws regarding the internet?
- dredmorbius 7y agoWhat alternative do you propose? Are you familiar with existing fair practices, consumer rights, and consumer protections acts?
- scarface74 7y agoDon’t use Google. Most third party sites that give you an option to use Google, Facebook, etc. also have the option of just creating an account on their site. As far as email, create a domain name and use your own email address. Free will is great isn’t it? Everything doesn’t require the nanny state to step in and solve all of your problems.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 7y agoOptional technologies or services are optional until they aren't. Dependencies create defacto requirements with the alternative of severe disadvantageous if opting out. Corporations answer to shareholders, creditors, business partners, and management long before they do individual users. Who, in the case of Google aren't even direct customers (advertisers are). Representative governments answer, however imperfectly, to the governed. Email self-provisioning has significant hurdles for even technically-competent individuals let alone the general public. Your suggested alternatives ignore the problem and create more.
- scarface74 7y agoOptional technologies or services are optional until they aren't. So now we are going to go down the whole “Minority Report* rabbithole and make laws just in case? You don’t tie your login infrastructure with Google, you use Oauth 2 and plugin any third party you wish. Representative governments answer, however imperfectly, to the governed. How well is that working out in the US between gerrymandering, the electoral vote having an opposite outcome than the popular vote, and how it is almost impossible to get rid of an incumbent? Email self-provisioning has significant hurdles for even technically-competent individuals let alone the general public. I didn’t say set up your own email server. I said create your own domain. You can create your own domain with your own email address with a few clicks on Godaddy. If you don’t like GoDaddy, there a dozens on other places that will transfer your MX record to them and you keep your own email address.
- dredmorbius 7y agoDepending on your jurisdiction, there are numerous laws and regulations governing private busines-individual services and relationships, including those concening employment, housing, transport, communications, lending, banking, data services, healthcare, barber and cosmetologist services, food, drink, lodging, gambling, theatre, insurance, brokerage servises, funeral and burial services,and others. Regulations serve to create a common and uniform floor of service levels. The problem with a strictly voluntaryist, free-market, laissez-faire approach is that it tends strongly to a Gresham's law "bad terms drive out good" race-to-the-bottm dynamic, particularly unfortunate when there is but one monopoly provider on the market. This occurs well before reaching the far end of the slippery slope on which you seem to be perched. Several of my earlier comments have been badly misapprehended, I'll not belabour them though I'll note the fact.
- megous 7y agoGresham's law doesn't work in strictly free market economy. By definition, debased coins will drive out regular coins only if you force the acceptance of both coins at face value. It only works under legal tender laws. If people read the conditions of the free google account they realize that the service can be terminated at any time for any reason without warning, and there's absolutely nothing there about any corrective mechanisms. Contrast this with terms of [especially national] domain name ownership. Anyway, given the number of people who will give their data to such a service under such conditions, you may well be right that some regulation would be useful, especially around getting your data out in some short time period after account termination. (But only to holders of the valid authentication credentials.) Forced email address portability would be also nice (provider would have to forward incomming emails for a reasonable fee or for free), for some limited time, maybe a year.
- wackget 7y agoYou're not thinking of the typical consumer, who won't have a clue about why using a proprietary service could be bad until the shit hits the fan. It's all well and good for you - someone who's aware of the risks and issues - to say "just don't use Google/Facebook", but laws would protect the average person who just wants the quickest/easiest way to get an email account or to sign in to websites. Also even if consumers were all highly educated in the pitfalls of Google etc., major websites still force you to use Google technologies whether you like it or not. Google Recaptcha is everywhere; eBay forces you to use it to sign in to your account. Are people now supposed "just don't use eBay" now as well?
- scarface74 7y agoSo now we need laws instead of education? Are you also okay with Apple’s “walled garden” because it protects people? Yes, if you don’t like the tradeoffs that eBay gives you - don’t use EBay. You can use Amazon, Facebook marketplace, Craigslist, etc. to sell and buy stuff.
- dredmorbius 7y agoI'd really like to see your data on the comparative efficacy of education vs. regulatory approaches.
- scarface74 7y agoI’m sure it would be much more efficient if we passed laws stripping everyone’s freedom of choice and entrust the government with enforcing “The One True Way”. What next? Have a centralized authority to guide the economy using “Five Year Plans”?
- dredmorbius 7y agoInteresting data.
- 7y ago
- Applejinx 7y agoMore than I trust google.
- scarface74 7y agoThe difference between Google and the government is that I can more easily escape the rules that Google imposes than the government.
- fsflover 7y agoI moved to another country, but Google is still here...
- scarface74 7y agoIt isn’t in China....
- brewdad 7y agoAh yes, that Libertarian paradise we call China. You've gone off the rails here, mate.
- scarface74 7y agoYeah that was snarky. But are you actually saying there is no alternative in your country besides Google? Yes you can get to google.com from almost anywhere in the world. That’s kind of how the internet works. You can also get to another website just as easily.
- dicknuckle 7y agoYou have to remember: politicians are the geezers that gave Zucc softball questions on FB violates their users (0), wanted to ask Bill Gates how to lock down our internet (1), nevermind the countless nanny state bills they have proposed over the years to censor the entire internet like they do for their grandkids. Please don't ever, ever forget that these people have not a clue how any of this works and will take an axe to the security and open-ness of our beloved series of tubes. (0) https://www.cnet.com/news/some-senators-in-congress-capitol-hill-just-dont-get-facebook-and-mark-zuckerberg/ https://www.cnet.com/news/some-senators-in-congress-capitol-... (1) https://www.theverge.com/2015/12/7/9869308/donald-trump-close-up-the-internet-bill-gates https://www.theverge.com/2015/12/7/9869308/donald-trump-clos...
- 101404 7y agoI trust elected politicians, controlled by checks and balances, more than unelected greedy billionaires only supervised by themselves. How about you?
- scarface74 7y agoWell, seeing that: 1. The average tenure of Senator or Representative in the US is steadily increasing. (https://www.termlimits.com/new-research-congressional-tenure-steadily-increasing/ https://www.termlimits.com/new-research-congressional-tenure...) and because of how much money it takes to win an election, it’s really hard to get rid of a member of Congress. 2. Because of how both the Electoral College was designed and the design of the Senate with 2 senators per state regardless of population, if you live in a more populous state, you have less voting power. 3. The more tenured Senators have more power and they have the power to block legislation. The people of the state where the leaders live are the only ones that can oust the Senate leaders. 4. Most rules aren’t done by legislators they are done by committees led by Presidential appointees who are approved by the Senate - again appointments can be blocked by the leaders of the Senate. Many of their policies are approved and struck down by unelected judges. 5. Then there is always gerrymandering. 6. You really don’t believe politicians - many of whom basically did insider trading pre-Covid - are greedy rich people? The President himself is a billionaire.
- 101404 7y ago> You really don’t believe politicians - ... - are greedy rich people? Could you point out where I said that? Please don't put words into my mouth just to "win" a discussion. That's pretty cheap.
- scarface74 7y ago“I trust elected politicians, controlled by checks and balances, more than unelected greedy billionaires only supervised by themselves.” So the alternative between trusting greedy rich people who both don’t have the power of the state, and I can choose to use alternatives, is to trust greedy rich people with the power of the state - most of which I have no power to get rid of because a) they aren’t in my district, b) the alternatives don’t have the money to get elected, and c) get elected by the flyover states because they have two senators just like the more populous states