5 ms·
This is why 802.1x and RADIUS are key. I used to maintain the RADIUS servers at an ISP and dealt with the craziness that were the initial implementations of 802
by rcarmo 7y ago
This is why 802.1x and RADIUS are key. I used to maintain the RADIUS servers at an ISP and dealt with the craziness that were the initial implementations of 802.1x, and to this day I keep finding corporate networks that do crazy things like rotating standard WPA Wi-Fi passwords via policies instead of just setting up 802.1x properly.
Of course, vendors don’t help here. Spending six digits on Cisco gear to get “out-of-the-box” end-to-end authentication (that then is weirdly inflexible in hooking up to your corporate AD) is certainly not on most small companies’ radar, especially when they get cheap APs that “work”.
For home use, I’ve bee looking for decent APs (_not_ proprietary fancy mesh setups) that support 802.1x and don’t cost an arm and a leg, and I’ve been seriously considering ripping out my Airports (which are amazing Wi-Fi gear, and sadly discontinued) and going with a combination of OpenWRT gear and an embedded RADIUS server.
But I’ve been wondering if there are decent SOHO solutions out there for 6-12 APs and up to 50 users — it would be great for small companies/startups.
- ComodoHacker 7y agoLook at MikroTik. 802.1x is supported in all products including SOHO ones. Also their wireless management solution (CAPsMAN) is decent.
- oger 7y ago+1 for MikroTik. Super good value IMO - especially in a home or small office environment.
- DyslexicAtheist 7y agoabout MikroTik I'd be extremely worried about security - not exactly a good track record: MITRE/CVE's: https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvekey.cgi?keyword=Mikrotik https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvekey.cgi?keyword=Mikrotik "Most MikroTik routers fail to get patched a month after severe security issues disclosed" https://portswigger.net/daily-swig/most-mikrotik-routers-fail-to-get-patched-a-month-after-severe-security-issues-disclosed https://portswigger.net/daily-swig/most-mikrotik-routers-fai... "Finding and exploiting CVE-2018–7445 (unauthenticated RCE in MikroTik’s RouterOS SMB)" https://movaxbx.ru/2020/01/29/finding-and-exploiting-cve-2018-7445-unauthenticated-rce-in-mikrotiks-routeros-smb/ https://movaxbx.ru/2020/01/29/finding-and-exploiting-cve-201... "Coinhive malware infects tens of thousands of MikroTik routers" https://searchsecurity.techtarget.com/news/252446369/Coinhive-malware-infects-tens-of-thousands-of-MikroTik-routers https://searchsecurity.techtarget.com/news/252446369/Coinhiv...
- iso1210 7y ago> "Coinhive malware infects tens of thousands of MikroTik routers" https://searchsecurity.techtarget.com/news/252446369/Coinhiv.. https://searchsecurity.techtarget.com/news/252446369/Coinhiv.... "Kenin said malicious actors were exploiting a vulnerability in the routers that MikroTik had patched in April -- just one day after the flaw was first discovered." So an exploit was found (it happens) and patched within 24 hours. From memory this was only vulnerable if you didn't block incoming winbox traffic on your wan port (which is of course good practice, and I believe the default configuration). Upgrading a mikrotik router is a matter of running "system package update install". You could stick that in a scheduled script if you wanted. Upgrading a cisco or juniper router requires things like support contracts, tac accounts, and other nonsense, then in many cases doing things like using tftp (!!) to copy a binary to the router, then ensuring you have a serial connection (!!) to the switch for when it breaks.
- icedchai 7y agoUpgrades on Mikrotiks are so simple. I used them for over 10 years and never once had a problem. In my previous experience both from my ISP days and some time in a corporate IT "networks" department, almost nobody upgrades their "enterprise" (Cisco) routers or switches. It's too risky.
- iofiiiiiiiii 7y agoSounds more like a track record of owners not patching their routers. Every brand of network devices has had serious security flaws. At least MikroTik is cheap and functional.
- vetinari 7y agoWe are a small company and we use Ubiquiti Unifi gear for that; for now including the supplied RADIUS server. We do have a domain, but for something that public as Wifi and VPN passwords we went with separate credentials.