3 ms·
> For comparison, last week we caught a significant race condition in another Kubernetes-related project we maintain called Helm (written in Go) that has been t
by rvz 7y ago
> For comparison, last week we caught a significant race condition in another Kubernetes-related project we maintain called Helm (written in Go) that has been there for a year or more, and which passed the race checker for Go. That error would never have escaped the Rust compiler, preventing the bug from ever existing in the first place
While the possible security benefits of Rust is interesting in software like Kubernetes, it seems like this whole blog-post is an implicit RIIR proposal for the Kubernetes ecosystem from a Microsoft software engineer which isn’t going to happen anytime soon.
> Rust has made great progress in the past year with its async story, but there are still some issues that are being worked out.
On top of that, there are still many crates that aren’t using async-await yet and most are not even 1.0, thus are not stable. I would not touch such crates if they are still immature or even unsafe.
Realistically, a Rust Kubernetes is possible but practically the effort of a production ready version is measured in years.
- steveklabnik 7y agoKubernetes is an ecosystem. It doesn’t need to be written in Rust for Rust components to play a part. Helm is not Kubernetes, for example, though your comment seems to blur the two. There are folks writing stuff to interact with the broader ecosystem in Rust. That’s one of the interesting bits of networked systems! You can be heterogeneous with languages more easily when the network/api is the boundary.
- dilyevsky 7y agoDoesn’t microsoft own helm now? Nothing is stopping them rewriting it in rust since it can easily interact with kubernetes via rest api
- seneca 7y agoNo. Helm is owned by the CNCF.
- dilyevsky 7y agoCNCF doesn’t “own“ anything afaik. If you look at maintainers list most seem to still belong to deis org which is part of msft now
- seneca 7y agoCNCF hold the copyrights.
- CameronNemo 7y agoThat is absolutely not true. The contributors to helm retain full copyright. No assignment or even CLA is used (only a DCO).
- seneca 7y agoI stand corrected!
- dilyevsky 7y agoNo they don’t. Check any file header in their github repo
- pjmlp 7y agoPlenty of Kubernetes stuff is actually written in Java, .NET and other languages, not necessarily Go. Thankfully.