2 ms·
Edited to prefix: Actually, on second thought, this doesn't really help Rachel's scenario. If the imposter knows our PSK then WPA3 does not defeat that. Huh.
by tialaramex 7y ago
Edited to prefix:
Actually, on second thought, this doesn't really help Rachel's scenario. If the imposter knows our PSK then WPA3 does not defeat that. Huh.
[Also there ought to be a way to zap that +Karma on a comment that I now realise isn't helpful ]
Original post follows:
Note that WPA3 is intended to fix this, but...
* Your corp network probably doesn't talk WPA3 yet
* Even if it does it probably also allows WPA2 back compatibility for older devices
* Lots of devices can be fooled into accepting that just because the 'foocorp' AP it usually talks to is WPA3 maybe this 'foocorp' AP is WPA2-only and that's fine
* Cheap devices (maybe not your laptop or iPhone, but perhaps a cheaper phone and definitely other devices) are too constrained to safely run the secure algorithm.
WPA3 uses a PAKE here (it calls this "Simultaneous Authentication of Equals but it's just the Dragonfly PAKE) so the advantage is that devices don't tell anybody what the PSK is. But we're probably a decade from being able to tell people (especially conservative corp sites) to turn off WPA2 altogether.
If you already use a sane 802.1x setup instead of a PSK WPA3 doesn't meaningfully improve anything and you needn't rush to update, but of course random cheap consumer WiFi gizmos that expect a PSK won't work.
- stefan_ 7y agoYou might be thinking of Wi-Fi Easy-Connect or DPP where devices enrolled through it no longer learn the PSK: http://w1.fi/cgit/hostap/plain/wpa_supplicant/README-DPP http://w1.fi/cgit/hostap/plain/wpa_supplicant/README-DPP