4 ms·
Most of those regulations are written in the blood of patients. In addition, I suspect that you have never debugged a delicate physics experiment. A single ex
by bsder 7y ago
Most of those regulations are written in the blood of patients.
In addition, I suspect that you have never debugged a delicate physics experiment.
A single experiment could fill a dozen notebooks with records of what I tried and used. There were records of serial numbers, calibration sequences, colors of wires, etc. I could go on and on.
Why?
Because when something didn't work, I needed to have "ground truth" as to what was working so I could focus on the (hopefully contained) surface of uncertainty. And this was for a physics experiment where the outcome is KNOWN.
If you don't actually know the outcome, everything gets worse as you don't have a definite signal between "Hypothesis is wrong" vs "Experimental setup is broken". Now, multiply this by thousands of steps for a drug. Brrrrrrrrrr.
To top it off, the physical world isn't like software, you often can't go backwards. In the physical world, if you didn't record everything on the forward pass, you may have to go back to start. :(
- BurningFrog 7y agoThe tough part of these regulations is that patient blood is spilled on both sides of the tradeoff. A: If you allow a drug that ends up causing more harm than benefit B: If you ban a drug that would have caused more benefit than harm. So making these regulations is about finding the balance between A and B. The problem is that a type A error causes a huge scandal. Those who took the drug and died are known by name and there is terrible publicity. But a type B error only causes people who would have died before to still die. Nothing new has happened, and there is no outcry. So the pressure on FDA to err on the side of never having any type A deaths, while allowing possibly millions of type B deaths is enormous.
- tptacek 7y agoI'm noticing that you didn't really address the meat of the parent comment, about the requisite complexity in documenting even a straightforward physics experiment.
- BurningFrog 7y agoYeah, I didn't see how that, and especially my personal experience of it, had any relevance to the issue of government drug regulation. So I tried to move on to the substance. It's of course true that science can be very hard. I'm... not really connecting the dots?
- bsder 7y ago> I'm... not really connecting the dots? No, you're not. And that's why you're missing the point that the details ARE the substance. The voluminous FDA regulations surrounding drug approval are about tracing EVERYTHING about that drug so that when (not if) something goes wrong, you can figure out what went wrong. Theoretical Example: 5 people just went blind from eyedrops of a drug that has never exhibited that problem before. Should the drug be pulled from shelves? If we work backward through the pipeline records and find that the 5 people all share the same batch of eyedrops, yes. If they don't share the same batch, no, but then we probably need to call the CDC as we have a new disease. But, what's a batch in common? There is the crate that got delivered to the pharmacy--did the drug get too hot and melt some of the conatiner into it? There is the batch that got delivered to the distributor--did a rat or something urinate on the box? There is the batch that got delivered to the sterilizing company (probably gamma radiation for eyedrops)--did they not give it enough dose or did they have a metal obstruction from multiple loads in the facility. I can keep going further and further back. Was the water in the process supposed to be deionized or sterilized in some way? Did somebody mix up two similar compounds on the line? Did you clean your reactor with the wrong compound? Some drugs are made by cells and your reactor can "drift" over time and you may have to purge it and start over when the drift gets too far. The regulations demand that you record all of that up front before you can even BEGIN the process of getting a drug approved for use. (The cleaning the reactor one is not theoretical: https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2007/07/09/now_with_ethyl_mesylate https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2007/07/09/no... ) In addition, I would like to add that the FDA are actually really helpful once you demonstrate that you are not a clown. However, they get a LOT of clowns on a daily basis and basically have to assume that you are too until you demonstrate otherwise.