3 ms·
Having designed and run clinical trials and combo manufacturing (drug + device) in my past I can testify that this is right on. There's a huge effort (pushed b
by gumby 7y ago
Having designed and run clinical trials and combo manufacturing (drug + device) in my past I can testify that this is right on. There's a huge effort (pushed by the FDA back on the manufacturer) to isolate variables and to ensure that whatever you want to say about your product you have actually verified to their satisfaction. As a person who also takes medication I'm glad about it.
I also don't think people should harsh on the FDA because of their strictness. There's a lot of gaming attempted in dealing with them which makes them harder to work with, but in my experience they've been pretty decent to deal with. Of course we had a policy of no attempting to game the system.
- doctoring 7y agoOn gaming: it's very interesting that, even within all of the byzantine rules and regulations and guidances how much gray area and leeway there can be. From a drug/device company perspective, which people in the FDA assigned as reviewers / contact points for you and how well you are able to articulate & convince them of your goals can play a huge role in whether you have to do X type of trial or adhere to Y rules. This is especially true at the boundaries (new types of testing, devices, technologies) that don't quite exactly fit the more well-trod paths. Not saying this in a judgmental way -- it's just the nature of dealing with extremely complex problems while also making sure people aren't harmed unnecessarily and that at the end when you say drug/device/tech A improves condition B we actually are sure it is true. And then there's the more malicious "gaming", fraud! Clinical research is obviously heavily incentivized toward positive trial outcomes, but for each site the act of just enrolling patients is incentivized, so you need to be damn sure the patient data (and the patients themselves!) in your study are real. And being sure is not easy or cheap. For fun, here's the FDA's list of people who have been blacklisted from performing clinical research: https://www.fda.gov/inspections-compliance-enforcement-and-criminal-investigations/compliance-actions-and-activities/fda-debarment-list-drug-product-applications https://www.fda.gov/inspections-compliance-enforcement-and-c... Their associated "Volume Page" lists (in excruciating bureaucratese) their "crimes", which may be unrelated illegal narcotics peddling (oops) or falsifying patient data.
- gumby 7y agoThe gaming has really made it harder to work with the Agency because you can't just call up or stop by and ask a question any more -- your interactions are more structured and formal. I agree that the shift to biomarker endpoints has made the process a bit more aggressive (in probably a good way) but has also lead to all sorts of opportunities for gaming you way to pointless success...but then you have something in the market with something you can talk about!
- refurb 7y agoI wouldn't really consider "articulate & convince them of your goals" as really gaming. There are areas that are new for everyone, and you are correct, if you don't come up with your approach, the FDA will come up with one for you. What I've appreciated about the FDA is their scientific focus. The FDA might say "You need to do X", but if you can come back and convince them with a scientific argument that you don't have to, they will listen to you!
- refurb 7y agoI've worked on the drug side of the business and I agree with your assessment. I've found the FDA to be quite reasonable, and also very science driven. Most of the regulations are there because without them, problems have arisen in the past. And as a consumer I'm very happy that if I get prescribed a drug it's been thoroughly evaluated for safety and efficacy.
- roenxi 7y agoThere is an issue with the framing there. From something like the dawn of written recording through to 1950, a very large number of advances were very dangerous for the people involved. Entire cities have been built and powered major advances in the state of the art despite being built in a fashion that would be illegal under a modern building code. Medical science is riddled with people doing crazy things to themselves and others. Biology has some shockers in the closet. Grand infrastructure building projects have always had a body count. I would very much struggle to pick on a point in time up to now where a society picking 'do things safely' has developed a real advantage over a society that went with 'learn quickly'. The learn quickly people make truly horrific mistakes, but then have an opportunity to learn from them and settle into much more sophisticated equilibrium where they achieve better future results in perpetuity. Government regulation makes things safer by banning unsafe practices. We don't see the damage this does because stuff that doesn't happen never gets seen. However, it is worth holding on to the idea that it just isn't the government's job to keep someone safe when the person involved doesn't care. People should be allowed to buy and treat themselves with potentially unsafe or ineffective drugs if they understand the risks and have read up on cases like, eg, Thalidomide. There will be benefits from learning from the mistakes and since it isn't possible to live a risk-free life the government shouldn't be trying to enforce it. A strategy of education and information is great. A strategy of prohibition and red tape is actually big-picture risky in itself with a a counterfactual point of view where things are experimented with widely.
- Spooky23 7y agoWhat you are describing is beyond unethical. How do you educate and provide information about the drug without an understanding whether it works or is safe? Thalidomide didn’t have a sticker that said “will cause birth defects in your unborn child”. Medical science has produced untold numbers of what would be classified as miracles 70 years ago. I can name a half dozen people I’m personally acquainted with who live today because of effective, safe treatments. As the disgusting affair around COVID has demonstrated, hucksters and idiots will happily push unsafe, ineffective treatments for a variety of self-serving reasons. Or if that’s too controversial, how many needlessly suffered from application of junk cures like bleeding or mercury?