2 ms·
Banks generally don't extend HELOCs beyond a borrower's equity in the house, which is the fractional value of the house the borrower truly owns. They are basic
by loeg 7y ago
Banks generally don't extend HELOCs beyond a borrower's equity in the house, which is the fractional value of the house the borrower truly owns.
They are basically a flexible cash-out second mortgage.
> In the extreme, a home buyer borrows a million dollars to buy an expensive house, the economy tanks before the first payment, the borrower walks away, and the bank gets a house worth $400K.
You've just described ordinary mortgage risk, in no-recourse states. In recourse states, the bank can go after the borrower for the remaining balance of the loan ($600k). Generally if a bank was willing to lend $1 million to someone, they had reasonably high credit and cash flow at origination time (debt-to-income ratio, non-conventional jumbo loan). They may not get their $600k back, and in no-recourse states they will get $0 back, but that is priced in to the interest rate of the loan.
- sokoloff 7y ago> Banks generally don't extend HELOCs beyond a borrower's equity in the house, which is the fractional value of the house the borrower truly owns. For a house worth $1MM in February and a first mortgage loan balance of $700K, it sure looks like the borrower has $300K in equity in the house. If the economy, job market, and housing market evolve such that the house becomes worth $600K a year from now, how much equity does the borrower have at that point?
- loeg 7y agoWhat responsive argument or clarification are you trying to make with the rhetorical question about negative equity?
- sokoloff 7y agoThat what appears to be equity today may not be there tomorrow, which makes it sensible for banks to not lend on HELOCs up to the amount of today's (apparent) equity.
- loeg 7y agoYou're just describing the ordinary risk that comes with lending against collateral. Banks evaluate that risk and price it in all the time. What I think most likely happened is that banks plugged their (new, very high) risk level into their interest rate formulas, got very high rates (imagine 10-20%) and decided it would be worse, for publicity, revenue, or other reasons, to lend at those rates rather than halt HELOC origination entirely.
- sokoloff 7y agoIt sounds like we’re agreeing with each other.