4 ms·
Oil income is supporting many horrible regimes. I have some hope a prolonged oil glut might make some of them fall. A world where Russia or Iran or Venezuela
by BurningFrog 7y ago
Oil income is supporting many horrible regimes.
I have some hope a prolonged oil glut might make some of them fall.
A world where Russia or Iran or Venezuela was run by decent government would be a great improvement!
I wish the same for Saudi, but I think that regime is safe.
- lobotryas 7y agoI like your sentiment, but it conveniently forgets the significant amount of bloodshed and instability that usually occurs when one such regime collapses. Just look at Libya. The West got rid of Gadaffi and the country went from stability under a dictator to fractured chaos where tourism industry is dead and slave markets have opened.
- bobthepanda 7y agoThis is the problem with pie in the sky US neoconservatism or neoliberalism. Not every has a secular civil society ready to jump in and create lasting national institutions. Then they get all hot and bothered when what replaces a dictatorship is either control by a party they don't like, mass corruption, total anarchy, or some combination of the three. See: Iraq, Afghanistan, Egypt, Syria, Libya, South Sudan The particularly dumb thing about Libya is that the US administration at the time was quite keen on emphasizing that they did not want to get involved initially, since the US was tired of war and the US has no major presence there. Britain and France, who loved waxing on about Iraq being an immoral war, were the primary supporters of intervention.
- BurningFrog 7y agoI'm absolutely not advocating US invasions. These petrostate governments get their power from controlling the oil wealth. If that becomes worthless, they have no power basis and serve no purpose anymore. Sure, what comes after, nobody knows. But in general, I think non-oil economies, that have to thrive of regular people working, produce much healthier governance.
- Synaesthesia 7y agoI think a big reason why Saudi Arabia and US are keeping oil prices low is because it’s a useful attack on Russia, Iran and Venezuela. I don’t see why Venezuela say is worse than Colombia which is a far worse human rights offender.
- WillPostForFood 7y agoThat's funny, because other conspiracists think Russia and Saudi Arabia are keeping prices low to attack the US. Everyone has an incentive to be the primary player and drive others out of business, so "A & B are conspiring to hurt C" is always going to make some sense. If I were to reality check though, this isn't the time the US would be choosing to take another hit on its own economy to disrupt Iran or Venezuela.
- Synaesthesia 7y agoAfter reading this piece it seems I do indeed have in backwards! https://www.counterpunch.org/2020/05/01/so-were-all-in-this-together-really-what-about-big-oil/ https://www.counterpunch.org/2020/05/01/so-were-all-in-this-...
- capableweb 7y agoOne could say "A world where US was run by decent government would be a great improvement" as well, but the collapse that you now seem to be in front of, does not give me any joy, even though I enjoy the thought of a future US that doesn't wage wars.
- exolymph 7y ago> A world where Russia or Iran or Venezuela was run by decent government would be a great improvement! There is no guarantee that whoever comes out on top after civil war is better than the previous big dog.
- PeterisP 7y agoThere's a structural difference in the needs that a government needs to satisfy in order to stay in power depending on these economic factors. If your economy runs on extraction and export of a few raw commodities, then any government that can keep that concentrated industry running will be successful, and it does not need a strong citizenship, quite the opposite, it needs a weak citizenship so that it's easier to control that concentrated source of wealth - that's part of the "resource curse" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_curse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_curse) that facilitates dictatorships in such areas. A similar country without oil or comparable resources, on the other hand, simply has to rely on decentralized citizenship producing wealth through their labor and skill, and its leadership needs to facilitate a strong population even if it wanted to be an extractive dictatorship, because otherwise there's nothing to extract. In the long run, these circumstances push towards a society structure that's more reasonable and beneficial for the population masses than the resource-rich countries.
- BurningFrog 7y agoTrue. But when are there ever guarantees? There is also no guarantee civil wars will happen.