6 ms·
> Americans, on the other hand, tend to pounce on admissions of failure or ignorance, and engage in shaming and humiliation of the person that admits an issue.
by PragmaticPulp 7y ago
> Americans, on the other hand, tend to pounce on admissions of failure or ignorance, and engage in shaming and humiliation of the person that admits an issue.
It's specific to company cultures, not Americans in general.
My first job out of college was at a dysfunctional company with a lot of internal competition. Making a mistake or taking responsibility for a failure was something that would be remembered for years and brought up at every opportunity. I remember my manager coaching me through covering up a simple mistake because he knew another team was eagerly waiting for me to slip up so they could attempt to take over our almost-finished project.
My second job was the polar opposite. When someone made a mistake, other teams jumped in to help fix the problem and kindly educate the person about how to avoid the problem in the future. Mistakes were a learning opportunity, admitting fault was a show of leadership, and the only real way to fail was to be chronically careless or to lie.
The biggest difference between the two companies was that the first company felt like a zero-sum game. We always felt like we were competing against other teams for bigger slices of the company budget, limited attention from executives, or just to keep our jobs through the next round of layoffs. It was every team for themselves, and other teams' mistakes were an opportunity to take them down a notch.
Meanwhile, the better company operated like everyone was on the same team. We all succeeded or failed together. Mutual respect an taking responsibility for your actions were not only encouraged by management, it was a requirement if you wanted to work there. I've tried to model my management style after this.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoThe old saw about colleges: The infighting is so fierce, because the stakes are so small.
- pdfernhout 7y agoOr as my undergraduate advisor joked: the reason academics fight so much is that they have so little to fight about.
- Rerarom 7y agoNo, they don't! They fight for something which everybody wants and few can attain: a secure and prestigious job with little responsibility.
- catalogia 7y agoDo they stop fighting after getting tenure? I'm far from an expert in the matter, but that doesn't really fit my experience.
- Rerarom 7y agoThey don't stop because they are so used to fighting that they forget what they were fighting for.
- cambalache 7y agoIf you think this is the only reason academics feud about, reality will set you straight.
- Rerarom 7y agoIt's not, but it's enough to counter the point that they fight about nothing.
- mlader 7y agoOne of my colleagues used to love referencing Sayre's Law when we found ourselves bikeshedding https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sayre%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sayre%27s_law.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoThat makes a kind of sense. The smaller the difference between two viewpoints, the harder it is to distinguish the difference. Its possible to argue forever and never see which is better/right.
- naveen99 7y agoIt’s a balance between competition between each other and solidarity against the outside world.
- folkhack 7y ago> It's specific to company cultures, not Americans in general. I mean as someone who's worked in a corp that has one foot in the US and one foot in Japan, I see where OP is coming from. Japan's business culture is no-frills "get it done" which rewards performance + optimization all the way down to the factory worker/janitors. In the US we have a culture of middle-management bloat where performance is usually transitive up the chain in some weird hierarchy; ie: my accomplishments are actually my manager's. This is all done with the "teamwork" mechanic - I didn't accomplish something... the team did. What this leaves is a whole buncha people who know their failures will blow back on them 10X vs. any successes, giving the company an excuse to withhold incentives (raises, bonuses, etc). You're incentivized to cover stuff up because you know it's going to come up in your reviews, and with your accomplishments being diluted into the "team" it ends up being a major point of contention. This is all anecdata but... I really understand/see where OP is coming from with his comparison as someone with a similar situation!!
- dnautics 7y agoHaving one foot in Japanese culture and the other in American, I think there's a lot of saving face in Japan too (as with Asian and Western cultures in general), just it doesn't take the form of cover-ups in the business world as much. It's not foreign in American culture, either. My understanding is in the us Navy for junior officers and enlisteds anyways covering up is the worst thing you can do; you can cause catastrophic accidents that if they don't kill anyone will result in no punishment besides a "what did we learn here?" lecture. Not as true in the upper, more political ranks so I understand.
- rekabis 7y ago> Navy “Were you told to not do that? Yes.” “Did it work? Also, yes.” “Now clean up this goddamn mess.”
- gfxgirl 7y ago> Japan's business culture is no-frills "get it done" which rewards performance + optimization Uhhhhh what? Japanese IT companies run decades old practices, are hugely inefficient and if anyone suggests they change its the famous "the nail that sticks up gets hammered down" Also they are not known for rewarding performance what-so-ever, they're known for rewarding seniority and butt-in-seat time. They're famous for both of those.
- dkarl 7y ago> It's specific to company cultures, not Americans in general. I think some cultures have an ingrained mistrust of the idea that some people are so far above others. Perhaps that attitude forces a false humility onto geniuses, but it works as a cultural inoculation against blowhards and pretend superheros. In the U.S., I think we have a complicated melange of different influences ranging from the New England protestant stereotype who would never tolerate such people to the South which I think cultivates an unfortunate craving for Great Man saviors (which can manifest on the small scale, like one engineer gathering a cabal of awed worshipers in an engineering organization, or on the national scale with politicians.) These are broad stereotypes, and I think cultural and geographic mixing in the U.S. makes accurate generalization impossible, but different people have different gut reactions to people who make implicit or explicit claims to greatness, and I think these gut reactions are culturally ingrained in childhood. Companies can cultivate a culture, but I don't think that will override whether a person responds to grandiose self-presentation with aversion or craving.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoI’m in a really strange place. The last couple of years, I’ve been “refactoring” myself, to pivot from being a manager (I ran a C++ image processing shop for a long time), to being an engineer (specializing in native Apple device programming in Swift). For years, I never needed to self-promote. The people that mattered knew all about me; warts and all. It wasn’t important for anyone else to be impressed. I am now working towards hanging a shingle as a contract engineer, and I need to let folks know why they should pay me for my work and experience. It’s really difficult to talk about myself and what I can do, without it sounding like boasting; yet that’s what I’m expected to do. I am really, really honest, which is, apparently, absolutely worthless in today’s business environment. The Japanese really liked it, but no one else seems to find it at all appealing. I’m not one of those “brutally honest” people that ends up making a pariah of themselves, but I have a very stringent code of personal ethics that I follow. All that is to say that I’m not good at the “humblebrag.” If I’m good at something, I simply say that I’m good at it. I don’t claim expertise at anything I don’t know, and I don’t make promises I don’t plan to keep. You don’t last long at a Japanese company, if you are full of hot air. I’m way past the Dunning-Kruger Peak, and the Jon Snow Trough. If I say I can do something, I mean it. I won’t say I can do something that I can’t do. It’s that simple.
- the_duke 7y agoOut of curiosity, what size were the two companies, respectively?