6 ms·
I worked at a Japanese corporation for most of my career. They are not a “warm and fuzzy” bunch. But they respect apologies. If I screwed up, I quickly learne
by ChrisMarshallNY 7y ago
I worked at a Japanese corporation for most of my career.
They are not a “warm and fuzzy” bunch.
But they respect apologies. If I screwed up, I quickly learned to cop to it. The absolute worst thing I could do was cover it up.
Their attitude was not a punishing one, but we were expected to fix our mistakes, and ensure they did not happen again.
If we said we did not know something, it was assumed we would learn, or find someone who did.
Lot of “personal responsibility” stuff.
Americans, on the other hand, tend to pounce on admissions of failure or ignorance, and engage in shaming and humiliation of the person that admits an issue.
I am constantly encountering people that Absolutely. Will. Not. Admit. Ignorance. Or. Fault. Even when it’s quite clear.
It’s crazy.
- threatofrain 7y agoIt’s a standard high school debate tactic to throw someone an argument that shows poor taste to counter, but most people take the bait.
- fastball 7y agoCould you give an example?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cutemonster 7y agoMust forbid encryption to save the children from the pedo...les. But these are grown up people though, using those arguments, not high schoolers.
- andrewflnr 7y agoThis only convinces me more that high school debate has negative utility and should be abolished.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- papeda 7y ago> I am constantly encountering people that Absolutely. Will. Not. Admit. Ignorance. Or. Fault. Even when it’s quite clear. IMO this is one of the fringe benefits of a good math education. Almost everybody who does math for long enough, especially if you work in small groups with your peers, will have a moment of "oh, I see, I am totally wrong and you are totally right" and find out that being wrong does not make someone a bad person. And you will see your peers do the same. It's one underrated side effect of clear and unambiguous reasoning. Yes, many things are grey areas, but there's value in a place where you can't throw up a muddle of goalpost-shifting and rhetorical tricks to run away from your own errors.
- koonsolo 7y agoI think programming also humbles you in that sense. After thinking a few times "it must be the compilers fault", you get more humble and figure out that you're too stupid to find your own fault ;).
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoI have a rule of thumb: "If it's the tool's fault, then it's my fault." That's a big reason I don't like to use prerelease compilers and toolsets.
- Rerarom 7y agoNot really, because you find the bug soon enough and that reinforces your self-importance.
- koonsolo 7y agoWhen you write software you write bugs, because nobody is perfect. You cannot even try to deny the bugs that you wrote, because it's all in source contol. Your fix might even brake something else, every senior knows this. So I still feel the more experienced you get, the more you have to aknowledge your own shortcomings.
- thebean11 7y ago
- PragmaticPulp 7y ago> Americans, on the other hand, tend to pounce on admissions of failure or ignorance, and engage in shaming and humiliation of the person that admits an issue. It's specific to company cultures, not Americans in general. My first job out of college was at a dysfunctional company with a lot of internal competition. Making a mistake or taking responsibility for a failure was something that would be remembered for years and brought up at every opportunity. I remember my manager coaching me through covering up a simple mistake because he knew another team was eagerly waiting for me to slip up so they could attempt to take over our almost-finished project. My second job was the polar opposite. When someone made a mistake, other teams jumped in to help fix the problem and kindly educate the person about how to avoid the problem in the future. Mistakes were a learning opportunity, admitting fault was a show of leadership, and the only real way to fail was to be chronically careless or to lie. The biggest difference between the two companies was that the first company felt like a zero-sum game. We always felt like we were competing against other teams for bigger slices of the company budget, limited attention from executives, or just to keep our jobs through the next round of layoffs. It was every team for themselves, and other teams' mistakes were an opportunity to take them down a notch. Meanwhile, the better company operated like everyone was on the same team. We all succeeded or failed together. Mutual respect an taking responsibility for your actions were not only encouraged by management, it was a requirement if you wanted to work there. I've tried to model my management style after this.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoThe old saw about colleges: The infighting is so fierce, because the stakes are so small.
- pdfernhout 7y agoOr as my undergraduate advisor joked: the reason academics fight so much is that they have so little to fight about.
- Rerarom 7y agoNo, they don't! They fight for something which everybody wants and few can attain: a secure and prestigious job with little responsibility.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoMy biggest win, mentoring: a new guy put in charge of 'Engineering data' e.g. putting ad-hoc document solutions under one umbrella. He was worried, not an Engineer, thought he'd make a fool of himself. I said "Here's the trick. If you don't know something, say out loud "I don't know what that means. Can you explain it to me?" And because Engineers usually are happy to explain their shit, they'll not think badly of you but instead become helpful. Never bluff or fake it. Fast forward 2 years. Everybody now respects him. He's the most generally knowledgeable guy in the company, the CEO consults him. Moved to manage the new products. He's on the road to Director now. Still the same helpful guy with the reassuring voice and the insistence everybody in the room understand before moving on.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoLove that story. Thanks for sharing it.
- ignoramous 7y agoYou'd like this related discussion from way back when on https://42floors.com/blog/startups/i-dont-know https://42floors.com/blog/startups/i-dont-know: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7334671 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7334671
- Igelau 7y ago> Engineers usually are happy to explain their shit Ain't that the truth. Get us going and you'll have to beg us to stop.
- folkhack 7y agoThis, and I hate putting someone in a situation that they don't know up from down... Even with the "highly opinionated framework" thing you still get lots of variation on how things are built, and my products are no different. I find people are much more immediately capable if I can get a 1-2 hour "nuts-to-bolts" meeting to cover the bases. Also gets the mojo going for good questions as well.
- swayvil 7y agoI have a friend in healthcare management. They have a manual of corporate philosophy. In there they explicitly advise, "never admit fault". Which makes sense from a business, legalistic warfare perspective. $>truth after all. Maybe our corporate philosophy is leaking into our common philosophy.
- DanBC 7y ago> They have a manual of corporate philosophy. > In there they explicitly advise, "never admit fault". It's interesting to compare that advice with the advice to healthcare professionals and healthcare organisations in the UK. Telling the truth when things go wrong, even if that means admitting fault, is the law. They must do it. They have to say what went wrong, how it went wrong, what they're going to do to fix it for you, and how they're going to prevent it happening to other people in future. Here's some information from the CQC (the regulator of organisations) about Duty of Candour: https://www.cqc.org.uk/sites/default/files/Duty-of-Candour-2016-CQC-joint-branded.pdf https://www.cqc.org.uk/sites/default/files/Duty-of-Candour-2... The GMC (doctors), NMC (nurses and midwives), and HCPC (allied health professionals) have similar advice aimed at healthcare staff. This came about after the Mid Staffordshire scandal. I put together a short list last year: https://medium.com/@dan.bealecocks/advice-to-doctors-about-saying-sorry-95701cfe9ea7 https://medium.com/@dan.bealecocks/advice-to-doctors-about-s...
- swayvil 7y agoThat's an interesting contrast. Black and white even. No doubt blame tends to run in a single direction, in that business.
- matheusmoreira 7y agoDoctors are human beings. They make mistakes like every other person. The healthcare system makes them work extremely long hours, so mistakes become even more likely. Doctors aren't supposed to be mere humans, though. They're supposed to be infallible godlike beings who know everything and do everything right every single time. They have to look like they know everything otherwise they'll lose the respect of their colleagues and even their patients. Even something simple like a procedure checklist improves patient safety but people are resistant because it could be viewed as a sign of weakness. I know one professor who was openly mocked by patients in front of her staff because she brought reference books with her to the hospital. Since they usually make a lot of money, they are attractive targets for litigation. If they make a mistake, they could be personally sued for tens if not hundreds of thousands of dollars. Is it any wonder concepts like defensive medicine exist?
- WalterBright 7y ago> Americans, on the other hand, tend to pounce on admissions of failure or ignorance, and engage in shaming and humiliation of the person that admits an issue. So true. And people wonder why others don't apologize - we teach them to not apologize, because an apology is an admission of guilt and then we destroy them.
- rb808 7y ago>Americans, on the other hand, tend to pounce on admissions of failure or ignorance, and engage in shaming and humiliation of the person that admits an issue. Shoutout to all the foreigners working in the US that don't say that know everything, are quiet in meetings when everyone is yelling out stupid ideas, regularly give up their design when a competing one gets promoted loudly, then never get promoted. Eventually you'll learn never to admit failure or ignorance and eventually start demanding who made the error.
- NotSammyHagar 7y agoI have seen people do that kind of thing in the US (shame for not knowing) but it's not universal and plenty of people (including me in leadership positions) see that it's important and valuable to be able to admit I don't know, ask for help, etc.