4 ms·
“The only stupid question is the one you don’t ask.” -On the wall of a classroom in my past -can’t remember where.
by ChrisMarshallNY 7y ago
“The only stupid question is the one you don’t ask.”
-On the wall of a classroom in my past -can’t remember where.
- cl0rkster 7y ago"Even a fool is wise who knows when to keep his mouth shut" -Proverbs "I know it's a much better decision to shut yo' mouth When you don't know what you talkin' 'bout Than to validate what everybody already thinks of you" -Hip hop
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoI don't really care what my classmates think of me. I'm not there to make them happy. I'm there to learn. If I don't understand a subject "to the bone," I am quite tenacious about finding out what makes it tick; even if that means bothering a content expert teacher with questions about fundamentals. The results speak for themselves. I also don't shame or humiliate others; even if they seem to be "intellectually lazy," or willfully ignorant. I get absolutely no benefit from that attitude. None whatsoever. In fact, learning to shame and humiliate others makes me a pretty shoddy team member. No one wants to work with someone that will jump on their weak points and won't help them to fulfill their potential.
- rumanator 7y ago> I don't really care what my classmates think of me. I'm not there tomake them happy. That remark shows a complete lack of understanding of your situation, your best interests, and social awareness. In the very least, your role is to ensure your peers don't become a roadblock on your path to progress. The least you should aim for is to leverage your classmates as facilitators by helping you lower the difficulty curve. By completely disregarding your classmates you are effectively doing the stupidest thing you could do, other than antagonizing both the student body and teachers: make your life harder just because you are totally oblivious to the importance of living in society
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoI have no idea why you made that post.
- cl0rkster 7y agoI should have added context. I just believe there ARE SUCH THINGS as intelligent questions that show a desire to learn.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jerf 7y agoI have some regrets in my college experience, but this is definitely not one of them. Ask questions. It's like a cheat code; you're getting twice the education that someone who doesn't ask questions is, because you walk away with a comprehensive, integrated understanding of a topic but they walk away with one shot full of random holes. Plus, if you're wondering it, so is half the class. There was only a couple of occasions where it turned out I was on a very idiosyncratic path and decided to just let it go. Most of the time the class is nodding along at the question.
- watwut 7y agoI swear to god, there were stupid questions during lectures. And "senpai notice me, praise me for asking this question despite the answer being obvious/irrelevant" questions. And the "I was not listening can you repeat it" questions.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoMe lern gud. One reason is that I am not afraid to ask questions about why something is. I need to learn my subject "to the bone." At the start of class, I'd always be asking questions that would have facepalms and guffaws around the room. By the end of class, I'm helping everyone to figure the material out. The best teachers I ever had were trained teachers; not subject matter experts. The absolute worst teachers I ever had were subject experts. They would routinely skip important fundamentals, and shame you for not knowing them. I guess that they assumed we would be able to figure it out on our own; which isn't a bad idea. Except when they don't give us the time or access to resources required to learn.
- zogulus 7y agoYeah, the worst lecturer I ever had was a maths genius. I remember on one occasion someone asked a question and the best he could do was "but that's trivial".
- loeg 7y agoI had a multivariable calc prof who used one of those overhead projectors and would spit on the projection as he lectured. He was also pretty hostile to the students.
- watwut 7y agoI dont have that experience. People who asked simple questions or "senpai notice me" were not the ones helping everyone out by the end of class. Mostly, first group were people who did not paid attention or were not used to think for themselves. Plenty of times it takes like 15 seconds to find the answer if you think about it. People who don't bother to think rarely start to be able to figure out on more difficult concepts by the end of the class. The dichotomy between people who ask simple questions and the ones who don't care is false one. There is massive group of people who think for themselves at least a bit when they come across issue. "Senpai notice me" people tended to be orthogonal to quality of knowledge or willingness/ability to explain. Full disclosure, I asked these questions when the "participation" was necessary to get points. It is a bit stupid when you know answer, but still needs that participation point ... None of that has anything to do with quality of lecturer.
- wenc 7y agoEh. Stupid questions of various varieties do exist (and it is not unkind to recognize that). They mostly arise from: * mental laziness (didn't want to spend a few seconds thinking and just wanted to be handed the answer -- very commonly disguised as curiosity) * bad faith (trolling, attempts at eliciting humor, "not really a question but a comment", agenda pushing) It's very tiring to respond to stupid questions of this ilk -- it shifts the burden from the questioner to the respondent. It's not neutral, and having an environment of "no question is stupid" is draining -- psychologically, empathy is a finite resource like it or not. That's why there are so many guides on how to ask questions. (asking questions that elicit useful answers is actually a life skill!) That said, I think the spirit of "no-stupid questions" is really about being open to (1) really out-of-left-field questions that challenge our thinking; (2) sincere questions that arise from curiosity; (3) clarification so that one doesn't persist in the wrong direction. I think this framing should be encouraged and environments/cultures should be cultivated to enable this. But in my opinion "no stupid questions" as a catch-all is not practically tenable. The costs seem too one-sided.