6 ms·
‘I Could Solve Most of Your Problems’: Eric Schmidt’s Pentagon Offensive
- carbocation 7y ago> In an interview, Mr. Schmidt — by turns thoughtful, pedagogical and hubristic... > While that philosophy has led to social networks that spread disinformation and other unintended consequences, Mr. Schmidt said he was convinced that applying new and relatively untested technology to complex situations — including deadly ones — would make service members more efficient and bolster the United States in its competition with China. If the NYT would cast an equally cynical eye at politicians as they are doing at Eric Schmidt, it might actually be productive. To me, this article is so drenched in loathing that it's hard to read. (E.g., the second paragraph that I highlighted seems to misattribute elements of the authors' opinions to Eric Schmidt.)
- mellow2020 7y ago"seems to", "is drenched to me" -- your comment is just the usual padding without content. All you're saying is that you don't like it, but have not a single thing about it you can correct.
- verall 7y agoNo, those are some fun words, but it's not padding without content. The parent comment makes a clear point whether you agree or not: "NYT dislikes this guy so much it's distracting. I wish they did this with most politicians."
- mellow2020 7y agoThat commenter is so in love with Eric Schmidt it's distracting -- isn't making "obervations" about what one cannot observe in the first place fun?
- keiferski 7y agoI’m pretty critical of the NYT, but I don’t think this article is particularly biased. It’s a fairly in-depth look at his actions over the last few years and is mostly just descriptive.
- ForHackernews 7y agoDo you really think the NYT is uncritical of politicians? They're extremely critical of anything the GOP does, and moderately negative on the populist left. Maybe they're too cosy with corporate Democrats, but those are the same Davos set as Schmidt et al. If anything, I feel like the Silicon Valley titans have gotten a free pass from the media for too long. It's only in the past few years that issues like data privacy or monopoly power have started to get coverage in major media after decades of the EFF or Mozilla banging their lonely drums.
- crocodiletears 7y agoI'd say it's mixed. Critical coverage of tech corps like Google's market position is sparse, but when it comes, it's like watching someone trying to put up a picture frame with a sledgehammer, because it's only ever trotted out to serve as a political weapon when a publication wants to force the target of their coverage to suppress either a competing new-media outlet, or some unofficial/unendorsed' (mis)information floating around the social network. It's always framed as, "[thing] is happening, I don't like it. [Platform] is too powerful, they're too big, and they tolerate [terrorism/racism/foreign propaganda]". The article is published, gets rewritten by other journos, [platform] has its censors wipe or suppress [thing], and publication magically forgets that [platform]'s market position was ever problematic. This happens a lot, both to the right and to leftists with critiques of the established political order.
- Redoubts 7y ago> Do you really think the NYT is uncritical of politicians? NYT On Trump: On Thursday, he speculated about treatments involving the use of household disinfectants. Some experts disagree. From their own WH Correspondent: Once again, wondering how Trump would have fared had he ever run for office in NY and had to face either the NYC or Albany press corp. ... guess the NYT doesn't think highly of themselves at all. NYT On Biden: We found no pattern of sexual misconduct by Biden, beyond hugs, kisses and touching that women previously said made them uncomfortable. Later removed because "the [Biden] campaign thought that the phrasing was awkward" The NYT is flaming garbage.
- 7y ago
- ur-whale 7y ago> To me, this article is so drenched in loathing that it's hard to read Actually, it's kind of fun to see the lefties attacking one another. More please.
- pc86 7y agoLet's at least pretend to have more intelligent commentary than "get rekt lefties LOL"
- klum 7y agoI agree that the article is a little heavy on the author's opinion — the quote above neglects to put the perils of software and machine learning in any kind of relation to their positive impact, which makes it sort of pointless. Also, headlining a section "I don't care", when the (paraphrased) quote is "I don't care why people listen to me, as long as I have a positive impact", is just ridiculous.
- ForHackernews 7y agoSemi-serious question here: What are some of the "positive impacts" of big data/machine learning? We have somewhat better (but still bad) image search, and somewhat better (but still bad) machine translations. Anything else?
- klum 7y agoI'm not sure... someone else can probably give a better answer on this! Medicine, weather prediction, logistics and driving aids are a few possibilities that come to mind, but I don't know if those are actual ones. Even if there were no benefits, I think the quote in question was pointless without noting this. But what the quote actually refers to is a "worldview where advances in software and A.I. are the keys to figuring out almost any issue" — I would say it's safe to say that software has had some positive impact in the world.
- einpoklum 7y ago> If the NYT would cast an equally cynical eye at politicians as they are doing at Eric Schmidt, it might actually be productive. You forget what the NYT produces... it is Manufacturing Consent: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent
- pcdoodle 7y agoI haven't Eric since his comments on the "creepy line" and "if you have something you want to hide, maybe you shouldn't be doing it in the first place". Seems like he'd love to oil an authoritarian apparatus.
- Ackshully 7y agoYou mean, even more? Google haven't not been evil for quite some time.
- spodek 7y agoHe sounds like Robert McNamara, wonderkind of business in his time, relatively inexperienced in politics and military. Then came Vietnam. Eventually McNamara would admit > "We were wrong, terribly wrong. We owe it to future generations to explain why." You can read more in "McNamara Recalls, and Regrets, Vietnam" https://www.nytimes.com/1995/04/09/world/mcnamara-recalls-and-regrets-vietnam.html https://www.nytimes.com/1995/04/09/world/mcnamara-recalls-an.... Besides military problems, we face environmental catastrophe, which Silicon Valley's ethos that technology will solve it, when it's mostly exacerbating it, and I expect Schmidt will end up more than "wrong, terribly wrong."
- smackay 7y agoErrol Morris' documentary on McNamara, The Fog of War is well worth your time to watch. The parallels with Donald Rumsfeld's time as Secretary of Defense are remarkable - it seems Rumsfeld was making all the moves and mistakes that McNamara made. I fully expect Eric Schmidt to suffer the same fate. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Fog_of_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Fog_of_War
- yhoiseth 7y agoYou wouldn’t happen to know how to watch it outside the US? Amazon doesn’t allow that, and I can’t find it on Apple TV.
- ficklepickle 7y agoIf you don't mind a terribly distracting background and poor resolution, here is a YouTube link https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=5LsRRTvPigY https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=5LsRRTvPigY
- sjm-lbm 7y agoInterestingly, Morris also made a similar documentary on Rumsfeld: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Unknown_Known https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Unknown_Known It's (IMHO) not as good as The Fog of War, but it's still very much worth a watch.
- lowdose 7y agoFor the ones hitting a wall http://archive.is/RN8ZA http://archive.is/RN8ZA
- Eridrus 7y agoI'm not an idealist over here, but It's really weird to me that when he looks at all of the US government's tech problems, he singles out the military as the part that it is really important to improve. But I guess it doesn't satisfy his ego to try and ensure the IRS' website works properly when addresses don't work unless they're all upper case.
- Armisael16 7y agoThe DoD is also the single largest conglomeration of systems in the USG. NIH and DoE would also (presumably) be real benefits, but that’d be two different organizations to hack through.
- Eridrus 7y agoMaybe Schmidt really expects a war with China, but I find it hard to be impressed by an XX% efficiency gain in finding potential terrorists. Obviously these problems are difficult in some way, otherwise they would have been solved, but at least pick problems that are worth solving.
- Retric 7y agoThe DoD is relatively simple in comparison to the giant mess of interrelated healthcare systems the US government deals with. ASD NII then DISA has worked for years to get systems to at least talk to each other reasonably well. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assistant_Secretary_of_Defense_for_Networks_and_Information_Integration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assistant_Secretary_of_Defense... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defense_Information_Systems_Agency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defense_Information_Systems_Ag...
- jkestner 7y agoImprove, or get his cut from? Schmidt is invested in several military startups and of course Google. So he’s nothing special; no one wants to make the military more efficient. It’s just a convenient channel for transferring money to contractors while soldiers are short on body armor.
- 616c 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- naringas 7y agomaybe in a few years (or decades) there can be a book titled: "Fascism 2.0: how technology rebuilt fascism in the early 21st century"
- Gibbon1 7y agoCareful you're not allowed to talk about fascism here.
- einpoklum 7y agoI don't know if Schmidt can solve most of the Pentagon's problems, but honestly - I'd really rather those problems never be solved. Also, Schmidt could solve a lot of problems by stopping the censorship of non-mainstream content on Google Search, YouTube and possibly elsewhere. Finally, he could solve a bunch of problems by _stopping_ Google's collaboration with the US government and the NSA.
- ws66 7y agoMove fast and break things... I don’t know how well this applies to the military, I don’t think it’s a good idea!
- Barrin92 7y ago>“You absolutely suck at machine learning,” Mr. Schmidt told General Thomas, the officer recalled. “If I got under your tent for a day, I could solve most of your problems.” General Thomas said he was so offended that he wanted to throw Mr. Schmidt out of the car, but refrained. Yeah because exactly what the world needs is a bunch of Machine Learning algorithms thrown at matters of life and death and strategic decision making of the US military. Over the last ten years technology has really turned into a cult. I think Eric should go and watch Colossus: The Forbin Project if he's never seen it.
- 0xy 7y agoImagine getting mowed down by a predator drone because Mr Schmidt's artificial intelligence decided you look 74.2% like a terrorist.
- zarkov99 7y agoImagine getting mowed by a Chinese drone because our drone defenses use 90’s tech.
- Gibbon1 7y agoImagine suffering a long depression because you're leaders spent the last 40 years preparing to fight a war that is already over. Leaving you unprepared to deal with a pandemic.
- gowld 7y agoThe NSA/FISA rule is 50.1%
- remir 7y agoLet's put aside Schmidt for a moment, I think it's naive to assume other nations won't have their best talent work on ML, image recognition and AI. That being said, I am not American, so my opinion on this is irrelevant.
- obarthelemy 7y agoIt's an inflection point.