3 ms·
May I introduce you to the video games industry? While there are good paying jobs out there, I'd risk saying the vast majority of people working in games are hu
by gambiting 7y ago
May I introduce you to the video games industry? While there are good paying jobs out there, I'd risk saying the vast majority of people working in games are hugely underpaid. At my first job I was literally told "yeah the pay is crap, but you get to work on big titles so it's fine". And it's not just demand and supply - we're having a very hard time recruiting for senior positions as there just aren't any candidates around, but the pay is still very poor compared to other industries.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 7y agoIf you are not able to recruit then that pretty much proves you are underpaying, right? If you pay market price for devs you would not have trouble recruiting, well, devs.
- gambiting 7y agoYes, seems obvious, right. But every time I tell HR that we have to pay more or we won't find candidates it's always the same - "that's the standard industry pay, there's nothing wrong with it, we've done our research and programmers in comparable positions are paid this much or less"
- deathgrips 7y agoSounds like your company is dying if people who don't understand labor market economics are overruling managers on hiring decisions.
- jlokier 7y agoBoth statements are true at the same time. So my answer to HR's answer is: If we offer industry standard pay for games companies, we get industry standard hiring crisis and candidate quality, as seen at other games companies. Have you researched hiring success at other companies and not just salaries? Experience suggests the answer to that from HR would be cultural inertia though, so it's not really them you'd need to persuade. It's a strategic decision for the company leaders, whether they think it's worth spending more to attract hires of the type who get better offers elsewhere.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 7y agoRight, HRs exist to do the bidding of the execs, not be independent critical thinkers. They couldn't personally care less how much people are paid, they only need to be seen as doing broadly what the execs have approved.
- jlokier 7y agoI think it's not quite that simple. Individual HR people may not all be critical thinkers, but HR people do salary research and keep up with trends in hiring. They have their own professional communities where they discuss this stuff. Even if they aren't all individually doing it, some within the HR communities look at such things and talk about it with others. They use this to advise each other and their execs if nothing else. HR industry groups could, as a body, look into whether "the industry standard" is getting hiring results as well as employee churn, satisfaction, and company-reported satisfaction with their hiring outcomes and make that information available to HR people and then to whomever needs to take it into account in strategic decisions.
- Raed667 7y agoI got approached by a big AAA game studio. The offer was (much) lower than my at-the-time salary. With a straight face they responded to my objection that i would get access to all their PC game catalog and a limited-discount for consoles. I still laugh when i remember that conversation.
- jlokier 7y ago> there just aren't any [senior] candidates around I think that statement is almost certainly false. Offer better pay, conditions and interesting work that has career prospects for the people when they leave, and make it known you are doing this, and I think you will have plenty of interested, good candidates. (Unless you make crappy games infested with 15s gameplay alternating with 30s brain-polluting ads, and that's for the people who paid for the "ad-free" feature. I jest not - I just turned down a recruiter for a games company looking for someone in a senior role, after I researched the company and the first few reviews I looked at showed the games fit the above description. I copied the reviews over to the recruiter and said this this is why I could not imagine myself working there in a salaried role.)
- gambiting 7y agoI work for one of the largest developers in the world - the career prospects and attractiveness of work are both not an issue. I'm surrounded by people who have worked here 15, 20, even 25 years, we pretty much never let people go unless they want to leave and try something else, and generally the company tries to bend over to accomodate any wishes towards your dream career path(I personally know several people who changed their speciality within company just because they wanted to, and the company did everything it could to accomodate such changes) - you can also move to any of our 40+ studios across the world if you so desire(there is a process, but no one is going to stop you from transferring if you want to do it). Pretty much everyone here has worked on at least one title that sold 10+ million copies - it's a pretty good place to work all things considered. No, the main and only problem is pay, and it all stems from the fact that there are hundreds of applicants willing to apply for junior positions, some of which I am certain would literally chop their own leg off for the opportunity to work in video games - if it was legal they would literally agree to work for free. So they all start on some extremely low salary(especially considering that actually, our standard for hiring programmers seems extremely high and I have no doubts that those people could find much better paid jobs elsewhere), but obviously that leads to problems further down the line. But, just because we have thousands of applicants for junior positions, that doesn't mean we have as many for say Senior roles - those see barely anyone applying, and yes, I'm 100% convinced it's purely because of pay. And the pay is what it is, because HR considers it unacceptable to pay new hires more than what we pay people who have advanced through the ranks naturally(which obviously cannot be a lot, seeing as your starting salary as a junior was so low, even if you somehow through some miracle managed 10% increase every year that's still not a lot by the time you get promoted to senior).