4 ms·
Yeah I wonder about the real estate situation. There is a retail development near me that sat largely empty for years. They kept it up and clean, but word was
by duxup 7y ago
Yeah I wonder about the real estate situation.
There is a retail development near me that sat largely empty for years. They kept it up and clean, but word was the prices were sky high. It still has a huge number of vacancies ... we're talking 5+ years after it was built.
Meanwhile other retail places had shops closing, word was the rent kept climbing.
I almost want to suggest that the local city come up with a concept that somehow would encourage actual occupancy. Granted that could be complex but it seems a real waste to have these spaces empty / taking up space with high rents where maybe some business could try to run if rents were lower...
It is a weird dynamic. It's like every spot is just waiting for a Chipotle or Noodles & Company or some small fitness fad / chain and if not that ... nothing.
- ip26 7y agoMaybe they haven't got it exactly right, but this shoe seems to fit rather well: https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/11/27/the-paradox-of-persistent-vacancies-and-high-prices https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/11/27/the-paradox-o... In summary, lowering rents to market price lowers the value of the building and makes the project insolvent.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoYou can't "make something insolvent". A project is either solvent or it isn't. You can make a mistake about estimating solvency, but that's the fault of your poor estimation skills and your inability to read the situation accurately, not the situation itself. If a project isn't objectively solvent and banks are still lending on it, then the problem is higher up the food chain - a lending "market" based on moral hazard which encourages poor decisions that blow up later. This is one of those situations where the people on the ground - shopkeepers, small restaurant entrepreneurs, and their customers - are being punished for policy errors in the financial and real estate industries.
- ip26 7y agoA project is either solvent or it isn't If you read the link, the point is the project is able to pretend it is still solvent when it isn't anymore.
- karmelapple 7y agoHarvard Square in Cambridge, MA, has trended towards being one of these places in recent years. Restaurant or other long-standing business can no longer afford the rent, and it’s either replaced by nothing or a bank. It says the lifeblood out of the area. From what I understand, the owners of the buildings are holding out for the high cost renters... like a bank. A city government could provide incentives to ensure these places don’t sit vacant, and that formerly thriving areas stay interesting and have shopping for most people, not just those with massive wallets or looking for a bank.
- galago 7y agoHarvard Square isn't a good example because Harvard owns so much of the property. That's why Davis/Porter/Central all have liquor/wine stores but Harvard doesn't. Businesses exist because Harvard allows it--not a free market within that limited zone.
- wendyshu 7y agoIsn't the lack of rent already an incentive to not let places sit vacant?
- lmm 7y ago> I almost want to suggest that the local city come up with a concept that somehow would encourage actual occupancy. Granted that could be complex but it seems a real waste to have these spaces empty / taking up space with high rents where maybe some business could try to run if rents were lower... Land value tax. Shift away from taxing the value of buildings and towards taxing the value of the land they're built on; that way you encourage appropriate and efficient development / land use.