9 ms·
I don't understand why a Mac is such a bad platform for gaming, what is the technical challenge here? Can someone enlighten me?
by baby 7y ago
I don't understand why a Mac is such a bad platform for gaming, what is the technical challenge here? Can someone enlighten me?
- wtallis 7y agoThe main reason is that Apple's pushing their own graphics API (Metal) rather than supporting the cross-platform Vulkan API. Apple also doesn't make any machines targeted for gaming use, and they haven't used NVidia graphics chips for quite a while and don't ship drivers for recent NVidia chips, so even Hackintosh users have trouble building a great Mac gaming system.
- iphone_elegance 7y agoMetal is one hurdle, Apple has a weird habit of putting many small ones up in front of you for whatever reason it gets old after awhile and the sales aren't there to justify jumping over them most mac users who want to game don't seem to have issues just buying a console either so it's not like a large group of customers isn't being reached iOS is an exception due to it's position in the market but I've been seeing less and less interest in mobile overtime too
- jsgo 7y agoSince after High Sierra (Mojave I think?), Apple eliminated the ability to use non-metal drivers on macOS wholesale. Nvidia’s drivers weren’t developed in Metal and there’s zero reason for them to do so (only way to use Nvidia is intentionally either as an addon to a Mac Pro or as an eGPU, which they don’t see a large market for it) and Apple has a long history of killing off support of something on their platforms, users be damned.
- bangonkeyboard 7y ago> only way to use Nvidia is intentionally either as an addon to a Mac Pro or as an eGPU, which they don’t see a large market for it Not quite. From Nvidia: "Apple fully control drivers for Mac OS. But if Apple allows, our engineers are ready and eager to help Apple deliver great drivers for Mac OS 10.14 (Mojave)...Unfortunately, Nvidia currently cannot release a driver unless it is approved by Apple." — https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nvidia#Apple/Nvidia_web_driver_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nvidia#Apple/Nvidia_web_driver... Apple is preventing Nvidia from releasing Mac Pro and eGPU driver support.
- jsgo 7y agoWhich means if Apple allows them to use non-metal drivers. Historically, there’s little reason to think Apple would waiver (wish they would) and the value for Nvidia to write their drivers using Metal is minimal. I’m kind of curious though: what value do their web drivers have to them now that they couldn’t just release them as OSS and allow a determined group to rewrite them as Metal.
- bangonkeyboard 7y agoNo, you've misunderstood again. Nvidia's eGPU web drivers already supported Metal in High Sierra [0]. Apple refuses to sign their drivers for Mojave and up. Without Apple's signature, GPU drivers will not run on macOS, OSS or not. [0] https://www.insanelymac.com/forum/uploads/monthly_2020_03/840568137_ScreenShot2020-03-14at3_08_33PM.png.4ea6c048cc4115cb20209c562b4167de.png https://www.insanelymac.com/forum/uploads/monthly_2020_03/84...
- jsgo 7y agoAh, that's interesting. I know there are some older Nvidia cards that do work on Mac, but most of the recent GTX/RTX/etc. ones don't. Are they similarly Metal (and just missing a signature)? Because whenever I was actually keeping up with this, the stalemate was over Nvidia not leveraging Metal.
- pcr910303 7y agoTBF, Apple’s Metal was developed before Bulkan while tackling the same problem, and for the NVidia chips, the reason on the bad relationship of NVidia/Apple is mostly on NVidia, right?
- willis936 7y agoDoes it really solve the same problem? Can I run metal API on my windows or linux machines? Also, to answer your question: no. Nvidia is in the GPU selling business. They wouldn’t mind having their high priced GPUs in high priced laptops. Apple keeps control of what hardware they sell, which dictates what software gets developed. Why would Nvidia or Apple spend resources to make software for a computer that no one is selling? It’s Apple who refuses to buy rather than Nvidia being unwilling to sell.
- olliej 7y agoCan you run direct3d on your Linux and Mac systems?
- kbumsik 7y agoThe point is that Windows has an alternative to their proprietary APIs, but mac doesn't
- jonahrd 7y agoI can run OpenGL and Vulkan on my Windows system. MacOS is the only platform that has officially deprecated OpenGL support, and there is no plan for any future Vulkan support.
- pjmlp 7y agoWindows only has support on legacy Win32 thanks to the ICD driver model. Vulkan and OpenGL aren't supported on Win32 and UWP sandboxes. Game consoles never had OpenGL support, other than a timid attempt from Sony with GL ES 1.0 using Cg as shading language.
- 7y ago
- tonygrue 7y agoAs the article alludes, lack of a build your own, flexible yet affordable desktop option seems to be a pretty deadly aspect. Pretty much Mac owners are on laptops. Even in the PC world few laptops can power VR. Those that do tend to be bulky for cooling and have nVidia GPUs; both things which MacBooks seem unwilling to have. Having a extensible desktop at 1k that supports nVidia would probably go a long way.
- sysbin 7y agoAs a gamer with a macbook pro. I just use shadow to play games over the cloud. Otherwise I would invest in a eGPU. So it's not like apple gamers are missing out if they want to game with good graphics.
- deadbunny 7y ago> Otherwise I would invest in a eGPU. So it's not like apple gamers are missing out if they want to game with good graphics. You're not going to get very far without drivers an you'll be stuck on OpenGL 4.1 and Metal. That and you'll have the problem that there are less games built for MacOS than Windows an Linux + Proton. Investing in a GPU for MacOS for gaming would be a huge waste of money IMO.
- sysbin 7y agoPeople can bootcamp if they want to run windows with a good gpu on their laptop. You're also missing the cloud gaming part.
- iphone_elegance 7y agoI'm not sold on cloud gaming yet, I gave pubg on stadia a whirl today (on my google fiber) and it was somewhat laggy and blurry compared to even my not-highend rx580 which only cost me about what a year or so of stadia would (not including the games)
- fortran77 7y ago
- numpad0 7y agoMac tends to fail meeting minimum graphics requirements. There’s no practical way around it.
- eschaton 7y agoSure there is: Design your game for the systems the majority of the users who will want to play it—after you’ve marketed it to them to them—will have. Don’t start with system requirements first and make a game targeting that because you want to show everyone how elite a hacker you are. If Sony didn’t require games achieve 60FPS at 1080p on PlayStation 4 before they’d allow them on the platform, most of the developers would be targeting PS 4 Pro because they want to show off. I expect that’s mostly the case anyway, and these developers have to be dragged by their corporate masters kicking and screaming back to baseline PS 4 support.
- f1refly 7y agoYeah well but then your game looks like garbage for most of the people who will proceed to buy some competing product that's more up to their standards. If you want to make a game and sell it only to the low end mac audience go for it, just don't expect to get your investment back. I don't expect game devs to target my 2011 thinkpad in the 2020 gaming market, that'd be ridiculous.
- pjmlp 7y agoApparently plenty of game studios seem to happy to target the lame iGPUs from Intel on PC side.
- kroltan 7y agoDanieru explained pretty well in a sibling comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23048633 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23048633
- eschaton 7y agoGame developers who insist upon working a certain way and insist that they have to target a certain kind of high baseline hardware say this. Game developers who want to reach a broad market and are willing to meet their deployment platforms halfway do not say this. They just port and ship.
- colordrops 7y agoI just upgraded to Catalina and now almost none of my steam games work. Turns out they were compiled for 32 bit support, and 32bit support was removed in Catalina, basically destroying my gaming rig.