2 ms·
> What makes you say that? The article says so, at least implicitly, in passages like this one: What we are doing with rights management information i
by pdonis 7y ago
> What makes you say that?
The article says so, at least implicitly, in passages like this one:
What we are doing with rights management information
is simulating Colour in a computer-sciencey way. But
lawyers will seize on the possibility of doing this
kind of simulation and say, "See! You admit it! You
can recognize the Colour of bits after all!" and then
conclude from there that all the other rules they want
to make (such as "Red Troubleshooters may not walk
down Orange hallways") are meaningful in the computer
science realm.
My view of the typical legal attitude towards DRM schemes and the like is similar.
> I would expect that the law (or the judge enforcing it) cares more about the reasons people use the software and what they get out of it in the end than about the specific bit strings.
The law is also supposed to care about the people who created the bits in the first place--after all, the purpose of copyright law is to encourage creation of works. But the law as it is actually practiced does not do this at all; the parties it most consistently favors are, as I said, large corporations whose business model does not include fair compensation to the original creators.
I agree that, viewed as an actual legal strategy within the context of our current legal system, OFFSystem is daft. No court is going to agree with the legal interpretation that the creators of OFFSystem claim to be using. But I view that aspect as simply an illustration of the fact that you can't fight legal mumbo jumbo with more legal mumbo jumbo. The proper response to draconian legal doctrines with regard to DRM is to remind the legal system what it is actually supposed to be doing, and to refuse to accept the arguments that DRM proponents offer in the framework of copyright law, which basically amount to saying that they have exactly the same rights as the actual creators of the content, even though their business model treats those creators as expendable cogs in a machine. That's what I mean when I say the law needs to change: it needs to stop taking the claims made by large corporations promoting DRM and the like as presumptively valid, simply because they have maneuvered themselves into a position where they can show a piece of paper saying they "own" the copyrighted content.