5 ms·
Wait... ...again?!?! After his SEC agreement expressly requires him to have his tweets vetted first, and he didn't? What is the man thinking. He's not an idio
by crazygringo 7y ago
Wait... ...again?!?!
After his SEC agreement expressly requires him to have his tweets vetted first, and he didn't?
What is the man thinking. He's not an idiot. Is he self-destructing? Does he have the impulse control of a 5-year-old?
He's going to lose his position on the board, for real.
And he deserves to at this point.
When you run a publicly traded corporation, there are rigorous rules about what you can and cannot say, and when, to ensure a fair playing field for investors. The same way there are rigorous rules against insider trading.
If he wants to act irresponsibly, then he should have kept Tesla a private company.
Seriously. The guy is simply not exhibiting the mental self-control to run a publicly traded corporation. It's becoming clear he simply can't do the job as is required, no matter how smart he may otherwise be.
- jlengrand 7y agoWhat is the man thinking. He's not an idiot. Is he self-destructing? Does he have the impulse control of a 5-year-old? He's going to lose his position on the board, for real. -> You mean, like the man that runs the country he lives in ? :)
- osrec 7y agoHad you mentioned the man that "runs" your country by name, I assure you, you would have been downvoted. Almost as if bots are monitoring this forum, and downvoting anything negative about their overlord. I dare you to try!
- jshevek 7y ago>Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ljw1001 7y agoIf it were boring, you wouldn't feel obligated to respond.
- jshevek 7y agoThere is so much wrong in one short post. I didn't claim that I find comments on voting boring, I cited the guidelines. I didn't feel obligated to respond, I felt it was useful and helpful to the community to respond. Your argument is a non sequitur. If I did find a pattern of behavior boring, I might comment on it to discourage it to improve the overall quality of my experience of the site.
- osrec 7y agoFair enough - it's just an interesting, yet somewhat scary trend me and my friends have noticed.
- jlengrand 7y agoDidn't even mention the name, and I assure you I've been downvoted, and not just a little :). Make it what you want
- afiori 7y agoPersonally I am no bot (an neither someone living in that country), but I am honestly tired of how methodically wrong the criticism are toward that person. It is as if a chuck of the world (as in this case, just like I am doing now, this particular country politics is often in international news) decided that only ever building strawmen was enough. it is just so tiring to see your own tribe, my tribe, have standard so low in term of what constitute a valid criticism.
- osrec 7y agoWhat makes you feel he is not deserving of criticism? I am not from the US either, but the guy has made a mockery of himself. And it's not just media distorting the facts - a lot of the times, he makes himself look a fool in videos, where he is simply talking without interruption.
- jshevek 7y ago[The parent comment does not suggest the premise of this question:] > What makes you feel he is not deserving of criticism? The focus on that comment was the nature and quality of the criticism, not the simple fact of some criticism occurring. For those of us who feel very strongly that there is some very important criticism we should be focused on, it can be frustrating and disheartening to see a media establishment, and millions of uncritical viewers, making the worst types of criticism (criticism based on lies and false reasoning). The most important (and valid) criticisms get lost in the noise. Further, moderately critical thinkers can become desensitized due to the low quality criticism. When they hear that he has done some new terrible thing, some of them start to tune it out as 'most likely another lie'. (Appending paragraphs with edits) One part of the problem is click-bait journalism. Hyperbolic claims get more eyeballs, more clicks. Incidentally, I agree with the second half of your statement.
- osrec 7y ago> but I am honestly tired of how methodically wrong the criticism are toward that person The criticisms are described as "methodically wrong", but I disagree. In fact, while the US P frequently dabbles in ad-hominem, most criticisms of him seem valid and well presented. I don't feel he is being unfairly targeted by falsehoods, since much of the critique is a direct result of what comes out of his mouth, rather than hearsay. I do agree with you on click-bait journalism. I think the current US P has given the media an unbelievable boost, and they must be (secretly!) hoping he stays in office forever. I mean, they have probably never had such a sensational political soap-opera to report on! Yet only part of the sensationalism can be blamed on the media - much of the story is sensational in its own right, thanks to the person involved!
- aaomidi 7y agoLol if only SEC actually had any way of having strong enforcement. I love how white collar crimes which involve stealing money get punished by.....requiring them to pay money. Someone can probably minmax the right amount to steal to make sure they make a profit at the end of it all.
- Gibbon1 7y agoI love how people that commit white collar crimes pay fines using stockholders money. Which seems like embezzlement to me.
- geoelectric 7y agoAt this point, I'm fairly sure he either has a cyclic mental illness causing him to be reckless in waves; is incredibly sleep-deprived to the point of executive function broadly going sideways; or has a serious problem with tweeting (and apparently earnings calls) while on stuff. It's possibly all three. Whatever the case, it resembles a lot what my ADHD did when it was completely unmanaged and at peak. But I didn't have a few billion dollars to make people have to put up with me. It definitely smells like impulse control/executive function in some way or the other.
- s5300 7y agoIt's his life. Why do you want it to be controlled to your ideals?
- geoelectric 7y agoIf he's shooting for self-destruction and eventual reclusiveness, he's doing a great job. Seems unlikely that's his intent, though, and that's pretty much what's happening.
- Gibbon1 7y agoMaybe Musk and John McAfee can can retire to a Caribbean Island together.
- jahlove 7y agoIf I was a Tesla investor my answer would be because that's what he signed up for when he took Tesla public.
- yellow_postit 7y agoWhat about the investors that want an unfiltered Elon and believe that’s part of the package deal?
- khazhoux 7y agoAll philosophical arguments are moot in his TSLA tweet. He broke the law. The question posed here is: Why?
- KorematsuFred 7y ago> He's going to lose his position on the board, for real. I bet he won't. > there are rigorous rules about what you can and cannot say, and when, to ensure a fair playing field for investors. Many of such rules when applied would have put half the wall street in jail after 2008. Instead they got bailouts. Many things that Trump has done would have got presidents impeached 50 years ago.
- jdxcode 7y agonobody cared when the zoom ceo said the same thing https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-04-18/zoom-video-soars-to-16-billion-valuation-in-u-s-trading-debut https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-04-18/zoom-vide...
- loceng 7y agoThe "imo" he added at the end clarifies it's his personal opinion. The market deserves this for being so irrational; the people who sold probably all made profit because they bought it far lower, and then it'll bounce back up - where the long-gamers will repurchase it at a discount taking a risk/gamble that they'd expect irrational dump of stock for the opportunity to buy when it's low. Stock market games aren't as obvious as people make them out to be - and they wouldn't be happening if Elon wasn't convinced by someone to not take Tesla private like he wanted to.
- ljw1001 7y agoCEOs of publicly traded companies aren't allowed to express "personal" opinions in public. If they do, they're not personal; they're guidance.
- DarthGhandi 7y agoAre you sure about that? Care to point to the legislation?
- athriren 7y agoNot to be too glib, but 15 U.S.C. § 78a, which created the SEC and invested in it broad power to regulate financial markets.
- jshevek 7y agoMy understanding is that this legislation does not universally prohibit a CEO from stating an opinion about the value of their company's stock.
- loceng 7y agoThey won't be able to elaborate - and if such a law did somehow pass, it's against a person's First Amendment rights.
- loceng 7y ago
- medion 7y agoSerious question, but why doesn't the same apply for Trump? Why is he allowed to tweet any old crazy thing but Elon isn't?
- krapp 7y agoIt absolutely should apply for Trump. But Trump already had a public history of crazy tweets (global warming is a Chinese hoax) and statements (grab them by the pussy) and he got elected anyway, so I guess the bar for sanity and impulse control is higher for a CEO in the eyes of the American public than for a President. Or maybe not, since it doesn't seem like either has actually suffered any material, significant consequences for their actions.
- afiori 7y agoFor the same reasons elected officials are not bound to electoral promises. There are procedures to remove people from offices and rules to limit their power, but elected officials should be able to act in their best judgment in those bounds, as in no "court" should be able to force a politician to pass/vote for a law.
- s5300 7y agoLooks like somebody beat me to the point... But - a US citizen loses their freedom of speech when they run a publicly traded corp? What do you have to say about the president then...
- TickleMeTrumpmo 7y agoNot how it works. Nice try, though. Musk is a giant baby and always has been. It boggles my mind that people idolize him. Most people aren't great critical thinkers, though.
- afiori 7y agoThe concept of publicly traded companies is multifaceted. In this case the relevant part would be that when you accept the role of a CEO (which I believe Musk is) you take on various levels of liability on part of the investors. Specifically if a CEO decides to just destroy a company then investor can personally sue him or her. Overall from what I see the concept of free speech is being misused so much it becomes quite difficult to understand which variant people are referring to.
- jonny_eh 7y agoYou lose your freedom of speech when you willingly sign it away in exchange for power and responsibility.
- Exmoor 7y agoIt is my belief that Elon has Narcissistic Personality Disorder. ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narcissistic_personality_disorder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narcissistic_personality_disor... ) I was involved with an organization where the leader had NPD. Their actions made little sense until I did a little reading on NPD and then it all made sense. The most disconcerting thing about NPD, IMO, is that many folks who have it tend to end up with little (or large) groups of people who latch on to them defend them even when there's no logical reason to do so.
- threatofrain 7y agoMental health professionals already have a culture of not engaging in speculative diagnosis from afar, ought we not exercise even further restraint before engaging in clinical terminology? And are you even claiming personal access to Elon Musk?
- rootusrootus 7y ago> Mental health professionals That's the operative bit. Lay people on HN speculate all the time about pretty much everything that graces the front page.
- osrec 7y agoIt seems to be all the rage at the moment...
- friendlybus 7y agoWhat about that diagnosis makes sense for Elon? I am curious. It would be difficult to separate the diagnosis criteria from what is reasonable for Elon to do when running a money burning company. His marketing efforts to build a dedicated fanbase seems prudent for Tesla and spaceX. Differentiating excess grandiosity and claims of high status from his business life is difficult. His life is grand and he does have a high status, npd or not.
- dang 7y agoInternet Psychiatric Diagnosis (IPD) is to be avoided on HN. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=%22internet%20psychiatric%20diagnosis%22&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
- ljw1001 7y agoHe's corporate America's Donald Trump.