8 ms·
I don’t buy the idea that dealerships benefit communities. If they simply charged sales tax based on the address of the purchaser, it would be more equitable.
by hedora 7y ago
I don’t buy the idea that dealerships benefit communities. If they simply charged sales tax based on the address of the purchaser, it would be more equitable.
The current law creates local dealership monopolies, and the dealerships provide terrible service, and rip everyone off as a result. If you don’t like it, you have to drive dozens of miles to go to a competitor (and car purchases invariably involve multiple trips).
Cities want the sales tax revenue, so they give the dealerships huge tax breaks to attract them.
The whole system should be scrapped.
- reaperducer 7y agoI don’t buy the idea that dealerships benefit communities. It's a method of spreading the wealth. The model increases the number of people employed and businesses involved, both directly and indirectly, exponentially.
- gruez 7y agoYou're not wrong, but there are far better ways to redistribute wealth than mandating the use of rent-seeking middlemen. Why not levy a tax directly and cut out the middle man?
- renewiltord 7y agoBecause the step past that of using the tax to redistribute is politically infeasible. It's like "Why not get rid of tipping and just give waiters a tax benefit?". Well, turns out we can't do the second piece so that's why we don't do the first piece.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoIf the purpose of dealership laws is redistribution then to get dealership laws you need enough public support for it to pass a law, in which case it might as well be the good law instead of the garbage one. Moreover, this is exactly the sort of thing where the bad is the enemy of the good. If redistribution is good and cronyism is bad then allowing the cronyist redistribution law to pass not only placates the people who want redistribution (and so they fight less for the better one), it also inflames the good should-be-allies anti-cronyists and requires you to waste political capital on infighting. Bad compromises are bad. Good law > nothing > bad law.
- renewiltord 7y agoUsually when you do things like this, you package it in a defensible way. So maybe you decide you want some redistribution, but that's politically infeasible. Instead you package it as something else. Another example is most big infrastructure projects in California. You'll notice that most don't finish in time. The real reason is to ensure that there is sustainable construction work going on. They're capable of finishing fast but no one wants that. They just want a large number of people employed. The Trojan Horse is "we're building infrastructure" because otherwise you have to fight the anti-redistribution anti-subsidy people. That's because when a concession is made to people they rarely will fight to make it perfect in the name of perfect is the enemy of good enough. Anti-cronyists don't expend political effort because they don't have upper-level political support. It's not a thing anyone needs to worry about. Only people who want to get something concrete and people in danger of losing something concrete expend political effort.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Usually when you do things like this, you package it in a defensible way. So maybe you decide you want some redistribution, but that's politically infeasible. Instead you package it as something else. So do the same thing with the good solution. Make it a UBI but call it a negative income tax and tell everybody you're giving them a huge tax cut (which for the majority of people you actually are). > Another example is most big infrastructure projects in California. You'll notice that most don't finish in time. The real reason is to ensure that there is sustainable construction work going on. They're capable of finishing fast but no one wants that. They just want a large number of people employed. The Trojan Horse is "we're building infrastructure" because otherwise you have to fight the anti-redistribution anti-subsidy people. But that's the same thing. Instead of purposely delaying the construction, just finish it on time and then go back and say "look how inexpensive we can build things now, let's build all the things" and get a hundred more construction projects. Blowing the budgets every time is how you get them all canceled by giving very inconvenient real evidence to the people who want to cut them out next time. > Anti-cronyists don't expend political effort. It's not a thing anyone needs to worry about. Only people who want to get something concrete and people in danger of losing something concrete expend political effort. All the cronyists and taxpayers are also anti-cronyists for everything but their own projects because everything else is competing for resources with them. A state can't pass a budget with a 500,000,000% deficit and expect anybody to buy the bonds, so every piece of garbage in the budget is crowding out the garbage that somebody else wants. The easier you make it to make the case against your thing, the more likely they are to get their garbage to replace yours.
- WillPostForFood 7y agoIt is inherently unequal though. Not every community gets a dealership, especially poor neighborhoods. But they do have car purchases. If sales were online, and sales tax distributed by purchaser addresses, the tax revenue would be much more broadly spread out.
- smileysteve 7y agoYou're discovering the regressiveness of the sales tax. Instead of a sales tax, let that person spend that money on other products and services. And to raise revenue, use a progressive tax such as income.
- _jal 7y agoEntertainingly, dealership owners are notoriously Republican-leaning. Perhaps they just need a bit of help staying true to their free-market ideals some times.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI was not aware Republicans had free market ideals. Based on their actions at least.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoIt depends whether you're talking about the politicians or the constituents. There are plenty of Republican voters with free-market ideals, because who else are they going to vote for? Bernie Sanders? But the politics is systemic corruption. To get elected, both parties have to raise money from somebody, and not a lot of those "donors" are buying politicians because they want fairness and free market competition.
- landryraccoon 7y agoIs this the same logic that leads to making it illegal to step out of your car to pump gas, because the attendant at the gas station needs a job?
- dhosek 7y agoIn Illinois and California, at least, the sales tax rate for cars is based on the purchaser's residence. I think though, that the bulk of the tax revenue goes to the location of the dealer (but I could be wrong). Purchasing out of state is generally discouraged by having the purchaser pay at least the difference in tax rates if the purchase was less than a specific time since the arrival of the car in state.
- pfranz 7y agoThis article implies it's based on the dealer location in California https://www.caranddriver.com/research/a31548432/california-car-sales-tax-calculator/ https://www.caranddriver.com/research/a31548432/california-c... I seem to remember tax based on the purchase location when I bought a car a few years ago in California.
- dhosek 7y agoIt might have changed, but I remember ads from dealers on just the LA side of the LA-San Bernardino county line advertising that sales tax was based on the purchaser's address. That was still the case in 2014 according to the L.A. Times [1]: >There’s no advantage, in terms of sales tax, on where you go to buy a car. An Orange County resident who buys a car in Santa Monica will stay pay the Orange County sales tax rate. The sales tax rate is charged based on where the car will be registered. I suspect that the Car and Driver article was poorly researched and factually incorrect. [1] https://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-aa2-snapshot-sales-tax-20141128-story.html https://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-aa2-snapshot-...
- closeparen 7y agoIt's a hell of a stretch to call a built environment with a car dealership in it a "community." These things are blighted dead space, and they belong out of the way.