4 ms·
I agree it's a good analogy, but I think you can also use it to illustrate my point. In your example, the goal of the judge is not to convict whoever is seen o
by xg15 7y ago
I agree it's a good analogy, but I think you can also use it to illustrate my point.
In your example, the goal of the judge is not to convict whoever is seen on the video. Their goal is to convict whoever commited the crime - and the camera footage may or may not be essential in reconstructing that information.
The fact that A has an identical twin makes the video into less conclusive evidence, but this just means other pieces of evidence are required - it does not change anything about the original crime.
In fact, if A was bragging on Twitter how he is about to commit the crime and no one will be able to prove it was him, the tweets themselves would probably become evidence.
In the same way, I believe (IANAL) two files being byte-for-byte identical is usually strong evidence that one file is a copy of the other in the copyright sense. However, it's neither a necessary criterion, nor strictly speaking even a sufficient one (e.g. in the 4'33 case).
- jatone 7y agobut the proof that the byte-for-byte duplicate exists isn't available. yes you maybe know that A,B,C can be combined to create the byte-for-byte duplicate but they can also be combined to create a completely different file. so just monitoring the network proves nothing. you have to get access to the end result on the users device. the point is copyright is now much harder to prove.