5 ms·
I used to write software for financial traders, so I'm more familiar with financial markets and their history than most. It's my firm conclusion that consequenc
by wpietri 7y ago
I used to write software for financial traders, so I'm more familiar with financial markets and their history than most. It's my firm conclusion that consequence-free "financial innovation" is an absolutely terrible idea.
Every major market started out with little or no regulation, and every one has ended up with quite a bit. This is true even of self-regulating entities, even of markets owned by traders. Why? Because there are tradeoffs between various market virtues. Openness to innovation is certainly one of them. But not having your money taken by scammers and criminals is another.
One of the main things that makes modern financial markets work is trust. If I buy shares of a US-regulated stock, I have some confidence that it's not an out-and-out fraud. A great example of this is WeWork. The only reason they're not public now is that going public in the US requires a fair bit of tightly regulated disclosure. When the world finally got a proper look at their numbers, the scam unwound.
That's obviously great for people who might have purchased the stock. But it's also great for every company who wants to issue stock to raise money. The more people trust that major-exchange stocks are real businesses, the more readily they'll put in their hard-won cash. That's good for everybody: investors, entrepreneurs, and the economy as a whole.
As we've seen with Bitcoin, unrestricted "financial innovation" leads to a lot of incompetence (e.g., MtGox), market manipulation, and outright fraud. So I predict that none of these "permission-less" platforms will ever amount to much until they tackle the same regulatory problems that successful markets everywhere have been forced to tackle.