3 ms·
Amen to this part: "Yes but what PROBLEM are we trying to SOLVE?" Every time a blockchain-based solution comes up, I try asking that question. There's only occ
by wpietri 7y ago
Amen to this part: "Yes but what PROBLEM are we trying to SOLVE?"
Every time a blockchain-based solution comes up, I try asking that question. There's only occasionally a real answer. Then my next question is, "How EXACTLY does this solve the problem BETTER?" The answers there are almost always tautological, some version of, "because blockchain!"
(For what it's worth, I give the original bitcoin paper [1] full marks on these points. It has a clear thesis: distributed e-cash will solve particular problems for particular people. It turns out it was wrong on every count, but at least the idea was clear.)
A while back a friend asked me to meet with a first-time entrepreneur pal. The entrepreneur had a business plan that was, like so many others, "existing business, but blockchain". After some explanation of how it would work, I asked, "Ok, how does this help your users?" The answer was, "It's more secure, because blockchain!" I said that wasn't sure it really was more secure. But either way, how could customers know it was better? Because the customer experience for the blockchain version and the non-blockchain version were the same. Either way, it came down to a company saying, "Trust us!" Would the new company's customers see a claim of blockchain usage as better? And better enough to compensate for the product limitations imposed?
They didn't really have an answer for that. And, unsurprisingly, I never heard back again. Nobody likes it when you tell them their baby is perhaps not the most beautiful child ever. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
[1] https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf
- seibelj 7y agoBlockchain is good for permission-less financial innovation including raising funds. It doesn't matter if the SEC considers a digital asset a security if everything is offshore and the purchasers are offshore or anonymous. It is a financial network without regulation. Regulation can pierce areas of the network that interface with physical entities, just as regulators can regulate pieces of the internet they can control but lack capabilities around the darknet. This is what blockchain is - purely digital and open financial networks.
- mochapot 7y agoThere is a group of people who assert that laws will not apply to them because technology obscures their identity. Those people are wrong. Blockchain is an append-only database. It does not create sovereign citizens.
- seibelj 7y agoThe laws of sellers of digital assets based in Caribbean islands, and purchasers in locations such as Eastern Europe and Russia, do not necessarily agree with the laws of western nation like the USA. This has nothing to do with sovereign citizens.
- kyboren 7y ago> Blockchain is an append-only database. It does not create sovereign citizens. Telecommunications push bits over a wire or the ether. They do not create "cyber spaces". My point is: There are some interesting applications of these funny distributed systems that do lots of work to maintain an increasingly-consistent cryptographically-secured append-only shared state. Your statement is a bit too reductionist. Frankly I'm surprised to read this kind of thing on Hacker News. I suppose the days of zeal for revolutionary self-sovereignty are truly over: > Governments of the Industrial World, you weary giants of flesh and steel, I come from Cyberspace, the new home of Mind. On behalf of the future, I ask you of the past to leave us alone. You are not welcome among us. You have no sovereignty where we gather. > This is our world now... the world of the electron and the switch, the beauty of the baud.
- wpietri 7y agoWhen I first read that, I too was inspired by it. But I don't think it aged well. Cyberspace ultimately isn't a space, any more than there was a "telephone-space" or a "telegraph-space" before that. Blind techno-utopianism is an understandable but erroneous reaction that keeps happening, and it generally ends up being ridiculous: https://www.amazon.com/Victorian-Internet-Remarkable-Nineteenth-line-ebook-dp-B07JW5WQSR/dp/B07JW5WQSR/ref=mt_kindle https://www.amazon.com/Victorian-Internet-Remarkable-Ninetee...
- khuey 7y agoIf everything is offshore it's not subject to the SEC's jurisdiction in the first place. "Permission-less financial innovation" generally means "breaking federal securities law" because nearly all of these scheme ultimately choose to involve US persons at some point.
- wpietri 7y agoExactly. And there's a clear effect here akin to adverse selection. Financial innovators on the up and up will just use the existing platforms. People who are up to no good and are hoping not to get arrested will have a strong incentive to use new platforms. That moves right on to the slippery slope: the new platforms get reputations for being the financial equivalent of bad neighborhoods, which means even less legitimate financial innovation. Eventually, nobody in their right mind will use the new platform, so it's down to criminals and fools.
- wpietri 7y agoI used to write software for financial traders, so I'm more familiar with financial markets and their history than most. It's my firm conclusion that consequence-free "financial innovation" is an absolutely terrible idea. Every major market started out with little or no regulation, and every one has ended up with quite a bit. This is true even of self-regulating entities, even of markets owned by traders. Why? Because there are tradeoffs between various market virtues. Openness to innovation is certainly one of them. But not having your money taken by scammers and criminals is another. One of the main things that makes modern financial markets work is trust. If I buy shares of a US-regulated stock, I have some confidence that it's not an out-and-out fraud. A great example of this is WeWork. The only reason they're not public now is that going public in the US requires a fair bit of tightly regulated disclosure. When the world finally got a proper look at their numbers, the scam unwound. That's obviously great for people who might have purchased the stock. But it's also great for every company who wants to issue stock to raise money. The more people trust that major-exchange stocks are real businesses, the more readily they'll put in their hard-won cash. That's good for everybody: investors, entrepreneurs, and the economy as a whole. As we've seen with Bitcoin, unrestricted "financial innovation" leads to a lot of incompetence (e.g., MtGox), market manipulation, and outright fraud. So I predict that none of these "permission-less" platforms will ever amount to much until they tackle the same regulatory problems that successful markets everywhere have been forced to tackle.
- tmpz22 7y agoOne interesting application is virtual economies with very low levels of trust and high degrees of fraud. Lets say I'm selling virtual gold items in an MMORPG like WoW or Runescape, if I sell my gold to somebody through Paypal the buyer can quite easily revert the charge or use a stolen credit card found online, the cash will eventually be removed from my financial account or my financial account will be locked or even terminated as a result - while the buyer gets to keep their virtual gold. It's no surprise that Bitcoin becomes a preferred payment method here because once it's sent it's sent and not going back. Bitcoin provides an opportunity to remove consumer protections when that effect may be desired, weird as it sounds it is very effective in a trusted seller : untrusted buyer relationship. This process lubricates trade between some international exchanges with countries with higher amounts of fraud or fewer legal protections.
- wpietri 7y agoInteresting! But isn't this a "there's no honor among thieves" issue? My understanding is that this sort of trading is not permitted by the platforms. Are there markets with this kind of trust asymmetry that aren't up to something totally dodgy?
- tmpz22 7y agoCan't say for sure, there are probably more instances in third world countries were corruption or monopoly creates market inefficiencies that bitcoin can blast through - though I think it boils back to "bitcoin will save us from predatory transaction fees" which I think has been invalidated at this point. Notably the same virtual grey market forums I mentioned for WoW and Runescape have been using high reputation middle men (who charge a 10% fee) to broker the transaction for over a decade. Bitcoin is just more efficient then those middlemen transactions because people are willing to trust entities in exchange for the convenience of a near-instant transaction.
- Spooky23 7y agoI agree with you — if blockchain were around in the 90s, it would be ideal for many scenarios where disconnected clients were common. Now though... pervasive wireless is available for most circumstances and is cheaper than the complexity of a distributed blockchain.