5 ms·
How popular is OpenShift? Seems cool but have never heard of anyone actually using it.
by verdverm 7y ago
How popular is OpenShift? Seems cool but have never heard of anyone actually using it.
- aquaticsunset 7y agoI'm a huge fan, and it seems to be finding commercial success[1]. What it does well for me is preserve kubernetes concepts, but expose them in a way that's easier to manage from an admin standpoint. I learned kube through OpenShift - and was able to ramp up quickly enough to manage our internal application as an engineer. [1] https://www.openshift.com/learn/success-stories/ https://www.openshift.com/learn/success-stories/
- cagenut 7y agoits just kubernetes for redhat shops, so it will be roughly as popular as redhat enterprise and ibm services contracts. which is to say, probably billions in revenue, and yet no one on HN will touch it.
- ofrzeta 7y agoI would always consider it as an option because it is 100% open source and has all the primitives that are needed for the prevalent use case that is CI/CD. For instance built-in Jenkins, Imagestreams, Build Configs...
- blinkingled 7y agoI had to deal with it past 2 years - it is extremely bloated, not very well thought out and anything that needs decently performing storage is screwed over by GlusterFS and now I guess Ceph. All in all you really want to carefully analyze which apps you want to put on it and how much benefit you are really getting out of it - because it isn't free in any sense of the word - licensing, maintenance, operations - you are adding a crap ton of complexity and giving developers more ways to shoot themselves in the foot. [Wow, looks like we have OpenShift fans here. Still, I prefer leaving the f out of OpenShift like everyone who has actually worked on it trying to get complex apps running smoothly :)]
- pestaa 7y agoI want to get into OpenShift/OKD, but the distributed storage systems are quite frightening. There are plenty nightmare stories related to GlusterFS performance. However, strange as it sounds, I'm looking to deploy a cluster on a single node, primarily for the Kubernetes API & ecosystem (so many tooling options). What is your opinion on running K8s this way, and having only local RAID storage?
- blinkingled 7y agoI have tried running OKD/OpenShift locally - even using the latest retake on it - Code Ready Containers. It is way too resource intensive for a single VM. That is before you start the prometheus/monitoring/alerting stuff or metrics server - at that point your single VM is good as dead. You can just learn plain old K8S - get an Ubuntu VM and snap install microk8s. Add another vm as a node and it works well for most part and sans storage stuff (you can do NFS though) you can learn almost everything. After that catching up to OpenShift specifics is not that big of a deal - it's not all that different.
- oso2k 7y agoAs mentioned, CodeReady Containers (CRC) is the easy button for a single node setup [0]. But it is heavy for a single node. Alternatives for labs and demos are learn.openshift.com [1] and the All-in-One VM blog [2]. Storage isn't too important in a single node setup unless you're looking for Metrics, Logging, and Monitoring to be turned on. You could use NFS if you have to. Just don't do that in Production, IMO. [0] https://developers.redhat.com/blog/2019/09/05/red-hat-openshift-4-on-your-laptop-introducing-red-hat-codeready-containers/ https://developers.redhat.com/blog/2019/09/05/red-hat-opensh... [1] https://learn.openshift.com/ https://learn.openshift.com/ [2] https://www.openshift.com/blog/revamped-openshift-all-in-one-aio-for-labs-and-fun https://www.openshift.com/blog/revamped-openshift-all-in-one...
- bennofs 7y agoThis sounds like you want https://k3s.io https://k3s.io, a kubernetes distribution specially made for single node and probably much simpler.
- oso2k 7y agoDisclaimer: I work for Red Hat Consulting where my day job is 100% OpenShift. You're probably using applications and systems which are hosted on OpenShift [0][1]. Second article says we have over 1100 customers which seems low, to me at least. We have OpenShift in a lot of places and you don't realize it (which is how we intend it). A subset of our customers can be found here [2]. I've personally worked on some really interesting systems and projects, successfully faced off against Black Friday, and reached some really interesting scales. But at the end of the day, OpenShift is a Kubernetes distribution [3] with an opinionated install story, an opinionated AppDev story, and the ability to be deployed on-prem, in the public & private clouds, and on VMs or baremetal. The try it on your laptop method can be found here, branded CodeReady Containers [4]. If you want to just play with an already running system, try learn.openshift.com [5]. [0] https://www.zdnet.com/article/ibm-paid-34b-for-this-where-red-hat-is-taking-openshift/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/ibm-paid-34b-for-this-where-re... [1] https://technology.informa.com/617145/red-hats-container-software-strategy-paying-off-for-now https://technology.informa.com/617145/red-hats-container-sof... [2] https://www.openshift.com/learn/success-stories/ https://www.openshift.com/learn/success-stories/ [3] https://github.com/openshift/okd https://github.com/openshift/okd [4] https://developers.redhat.com/blog/2019/09/05/red-hat-openshift-4-on-your-laptop-introducing-red-hat-codeready-containers/ https://developers.redhat.com/blog/2019/09/05/red-hat-opensh... [5] https://learn.openshift.com/ https://learn.openshift.com/
- jasonv 7y agoI work for a financial institution using openshift in cloud. Learning it now.
- decisionSniper 7y agoWe tackle sepsis with OpenShift across our 180ish hospitals. https://youtu.be/ZWMhZ83AHvY https://youtu.be/ZWMhZ83AHvY
- jonfw 7y agoI work almost exclusively with openshift- it's very popular for enterprise stuff. We've got a lot of clients in banking and insurance and those sorts of industries- where you need your technology to scale but you're not really a technology company.
- gladskdks 7y agoWe use it at my place if work, for some things. To be honest it's hit and miss whether our clients do - I'd say about 40% do. I was pretty surprised to see our latest client uses it. I won't name any names but they're a HUGE teleco in Europe and operate in many countries. Looks like it's growing in popularity.