5 ms·
What I find weird is that a technology advances because public money are funding much of the research and innovation. And there comes a private company and get
by DeathArrow 7y ago
What I find weird is that a technology advances because public money are funding much of the research and innovation.
And there comes a private company and gets whole teams and even patents and projects.
Wouldn't it be fair that tax payers also get something in return of their funding?
- gcb0 7y agoThat's a very reasonable and old idea, comrade.
- testaccount22 7y agowe get the technology
- seamyb88 7y agoWhich would be completely impossible to obtain without giving the profits to the rich. It wasn't science or engineering that built the modern world, it was privatisation. (end of sarcasm)We won't get the technology we want, we will get the technology Google wants us to have. We will get decades of fighting Google over their abuse of the technology. We will get an Edward Snowden releasing files to show how Google allowed Governments to spy on their own people, with the technology. Or just live in your bubble, whatever.
- emsy 7y agoOh yeah behind patents and embedded in corporate secrecy that is almost guaranteed to be irrecoverable once the people that created the technology leave or die. I don’t think cooperations are bad and they should be reimbursed for their expenses, but our current way of handling these things leaves a lot of room for improvement if our goal is to advance the cooperative future of humanity (which it should be).
- 627467 7y agoThe point of patents is to incentivize disclosure of knowledge in exchange for limited protection. I personally think that public institutions funding research that leads to patents should share benefits of said patents. I believe most operators of those public funds (ie. Universities) actually benefit from this most of the time. At least in major public European universities
- atq2119 7y agoUnfortunately, patents don't really do that in practice. For example, it is typical for engineers to be advised not to read any patents at all. Plus, most patents are written in a style that's pretty much opposite to how you'd write if the goal was dissemination of knowledge.
- rapsey 7y agoAnd the jobs and all that comes with a growing economy.
- Majromax 7y ago> Wouldn't it be fair that tax payers also get something in return of their funding? What's the purpose of scientific funding: to progress science or to make money? If the goal is altruistic progression of science, then undoubtedly that's best accomplished through free, nearly-unrestricted publication. That includes both work on nonpatentable fields (fundamental science, or advances too remote from commercialization for a patent timeframe to be viable) and not aggressively pursuing the full suite of IP protections for work that may be patentable. If the goal is to make money, why should there be public funding in the first place? We don't ordinarily expect the government to run business ventures, and treating science funding like a Bell Labs writ large would be just such a business venture. On the balance, the situation described in this article appears to be close to an optimal outcome: foundational science happened at a university, but a corporation came in with deep pockets and significantly more funding to work on the commercialization process.
- aguyfromnb 7y ago>What's the purpose of scientific funding: to progress science or to make money? What's the purpose of scientific progress if the people can't share in the benefits? >but a corporation came in with deep pockets Deep pockets partially because they domicile in tax-havens, and re-contribute the bare-minimum back to the source of the foundational science, forcing that foundational science funding onto the backs of the people, via trillions in student loans. How is this "optimal"? Do you think we wouldn't be able to search the web without Google?
- slowmovintarget 7y agoTaxpayer funded research belongs to the taxpayers.
- 627467 7y agoIf we think of public funding as early stage (extremely risky) investment, then it's more like the lottery that angel investors and vcs play: most investments result in little to no public good but some will make up for bad investments. I definitely think we should push for fairer and more transparent public investment in science, but saying that all downstream benefits from publicly funded efforts cannot be privatized just seems to tilt incentives in the wrong direction.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- currymj 7y agothey probably do, often the university negotiates royalties or equity for spinoffs of research done using university resources.
- MiroF 7y agoThat’s still private money, no? Well, I guess in this case it was a public uni. It in many cases it is not.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]