3 ms·
No, this is exactly why Universities exist. As idea machines that occasionally turn out something that changes the world. As well as educating our (elite) child
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
No, this is exactly why Universities exist. As idea machines that occasionally turn out something that changes the world. As well as educating our (elite) children.
- seemslegit 7y agoAnd that's great, but nowhere does it say that this something should end up as the property of a corporation who will then charge the public for its use.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoCan't enslave professors, so its part of the deal. Been happening about 1000 years. And I'm not sure I care to make Universities into profit centers (any more than they are).
- seemslegit 7y agoNeither is what being proposed nor is a reasonable reading of the above, if Google hires out an entire group and its associated work then the university and federal research funding agencies should maintain equity in its results, many universities have programs for exactly this kind of thing. Also afaik John Martinis maintained a paid and tenured position at UCSB during his work at Google.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoNot sure how that's different at all. Hiring out === freedom of the individual. Not going to support any rule to keep University employees from going to work wherever they please. Its the idea that the University would 'own' part of a commercial enterprise that's chilling. Means even more commercialization of Universities than at present.
- auntienomen 7y agoIt's not unusual for universities to own part of a commercial enterprise. Stanford owned a chunk of Google, IIRC. More commonly they derive revenue from licensing intellectual property.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoUm hm. And its not unusual for Universities to have become commercial juggernauts run by for-profit administrators with 7-figure salaries, at the expense of faculty and students.
- seemslegit 7y agoAnd yet the private sector is not impeded by "freedom of the individual" when it comes to protecting investments with NDAs, non-competes all the way to Levandowski-style criminal prosecution. Obviously noone should be forced to stay where they don't want to be or prevented to work where they want but in this case it's about what they take and bring with them beyond their innate skills.
- aikinai 7y agoOn top of what others have said (this is how it's intended to work), if the university saw fit to fund the research up to commercialization, or at least a patent, they would be the ones taking the profit.
- seemslegit 7y agoYou can say that about YC or any other incubator and yet they seem keen on maintaining their equity.
- paulcole 7y agoYes! The thrill of funding something and then paying a corporation who took little risk when the product is finally ready.
- seemslegit 7y agoIt's not even partially ready, but that's not the point - it was more credibly possible when it was acquired by Google then it was when it was initially funded by the public.