3 ms·
> I feel being patronized by a large SW vendor who forces me to automatically run his software on my system after each login. I know this isn’t really related,
by dangus 7y ago
> I feel being patronized by a large SW vendor who forces me to automatically run his software on my system after each login.
I know this isn’t really related, but we should really get rid of the nasty habit of genderizing people and companies.
In this sentence it would be more appropriate to use “their software,” not “his software.”
A large software vendor most certainly isn’t a “he.”
Edit: every time I point this out on a threads I get downvoted. That’s fine, I don’t really care about that. But it disappoints me to see that because it reflects how so many people are that much against a really simple way to be inclusive. So, I want to emphasize that this is just a polite suggestion, not an inquisition.
- chrisseaton 7y agoI feel like the author probably isn't a native English writer, so maybe give them a break.
- dangus 7y agoIt’s not an inquisition, just something to be aware of. I’m downvoted every time I point out this very simple thing we can do to be more inclusive. I don’t see any indication that the author isn’t a native English speaker and I wouldn’t want to make any assumptions in that regard either.
- chrisseaton 7y agoI don't think anyone's disagreeing with the idea of being inclusive. But if the author very clearly isn't used to writing in English in the first place (you cannot possibly have missed that) then you can start gently with the fact that we don't use genders for all nouns, as they may not even be aware of that, before you go in with the big guns of calling people's efforts at writing in a foreign language 'nasty'. If I asked you to write a blog post in Sumerian and you made a faux pas and I jumped all over it you'd be a bit put out wouldn't you?
- dangus 7y agoI thought the piece was written well enough that I couldn’t tell they were not a native speaker. I checked the about me page and the author said nothing about location. That’s about as far as I got.
- syntheticcorp 7y agoWhen I see a genderised statement like this I always wonder if I had missed something earlier in the writing and the author was referring to a specific male person rather than a company. I also find it equally jarring when authors unexpectedly use “her” for a gender neutral object like a company in some misguided attempt to write with inclusivity.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoYes but pedants are jarred by 'their' and 'them' which are technically plural. I know, in speech we abuse them freely, but in writing it can be jarring to some.
- aspenmayer 7y agoYour info is out of date. Singular “they” is now standards compliant. ‘The singular “they” is a generic third-person singular pronoun in English. Use of the singular “they” is endorsed as part of APA Style because it is inclusive of all people and helps writers avoid making assumptions about gender. Although usage of the singular “they” was once discouraged in academic writing, many advocacy groups and publishers have accepted and endorsed it, including Merriam-Webster’s Dictionary. ‘Singular “they” is covered in Section 4.18 of the APA Publication Manual, Seventh Edition’ https://apastyle.apa.org/style-grammar-guidelines/grammar/singular-they https://apastyle.apa.org/style-grammar-guidelines/grammar/si...
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoYeah, I'm out-of-date because I'm older than that 'decision'. Which is why its jarring, and will remain so despite appeal to authority.
- cyphar 7y agoUnless you're more than 700 years old, you're not older than common usage of singular "they" (which entered common usage in the 14th century). It's honestly not that new of a concept. I'm honestly always a little surprised when this topic comes up with the number of people who find this grammatically jarring. To be fair, I am fairly young, but I do remember learning about singular "they" while I was in primary school in the early 2000s. Is the issue that this isn't taught in US schools, hence all the confusion?
- oarsinsync 7y agoHere's another hint for you https://blog.bembel.net/2019/07/ebbelwoi-statement/ https://blog.bembel.net/2019/07/ebbelwoi-statement/
- wolco 7y agoGood point and one I overlooked until you pointed that out. Let's leave genders at the door. A bad vendor is a monster without a gender.
- einpoklum 7y agoFair enough, but FYI: In some languages, _all_ nouns are genderized and there isn't a gender-neutral form. e.g. in Arabic, "table" is grammatically female, while in Hebrew, it's grammatically male.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- papermachete 7y agoIf you keep getting downvoted, why don't you get a clue?
- Chris2048 7y agoYou say it's just a polite suggestion, but you describe alternatives to your suggestion as a "nasty" habit - is it really polite? It's a slippery slope to eir/em/..etc and other "new" pronouns; The latest thinking is you have to ask someone what their pronouns are, and they can insist on pretty much any fad pronoun they want, or else you'll be accused of anything between "being rude" to "hate-crime" (lot of motte-bailey around this). It's probably no wonder people want to keep things simple and stick to convention. In other words, this simple way might get a lot more traction, if it wasn't a gateway / stepping-stone to a worse way.
- doublesCs 7y agoI don't disagree with being inclusive, I disagree with the idea that grammatical details of how we speak have anything to do with inclusiveness. It's like if I start complaining that you use "their" to refer to a software vendor because that implies there's more than one person involved and so you're not being inclusive of solo founders. Or that "their" antromorphizes a vendor and therefore isn't inclusive of sea cucumbers. In reality, this has zero consequence to anyone, other than guys who enjoy feeling offended on behalf of others. EDIT: I'm finding a lot of pearls in your comment history. Like this one where you complain of people telling you what to do https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23006925 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23006925 Now you know how we feel, I guess.
- aspenmayer 7y agoAs I mentioned in another comment, singular “they” is now standards compliant. ‘The singular “they” is a generic third-person singular pronoun in English. Use of the singular “they” is endorsed as part of APA Style because it is inclusive of all people and helps writers avoid making assumptions about gender. Although usage of the singular “they” was once discouraged in academic writing, many advocacy groups and publishers have accepted and endorsed it, including Merriam-Webster’s Dictionary. ‘Singular “they” is covered in Section 4.18 of the APA Publication Manual, Seventh Edition’ https://apastyle.apa.org/style-grammar-guidelines/grammar/si.. https://apastyle.apa.org/style-grammar-guidelines/grammar/si....
- cyphar 7y agoI do think this topic is something it doesn't hurt to be mindful of. However, it's pretty clear to me that the author's first language is not English. One of my mother tongues has gendered pronouns, and I find one of the simplest tells that a speaker's native tongue isn't English is the inappropriate usage of gendered pronouns. In fact I don't recall a single time I've heard a native English speaker use gendered pronouns in this manner (not to mention a company is a collection of people -- so there isn't even a singular "they" discussion to be had here). So my main issue with this discussion topic is not that we shouldn't use more inclusive pronouns generally, it's these discussions seem to always ignore that folks whose mother tongue has gendered pronouns automatically think about objects differently when talking about them. For instance, a table being masculine (at least in my mother tongue) is not a conscious judgement of tables on the speaker's part -- it's a kind of classification that your brain does on autopilot. It should just be seen as the garden variety grammatical slip-up that it is, and treat it as such (ignore it and move on).