4 ms·
Peter Norvig explained why he came to Python from Lisp in an HN posting a decade ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1803815 https://news.ycombinator.com
by DonHopkins 7y ago
Peter Norvig explained why he came to Python from Lisp in an HN posting a decade ago:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1803815 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1803815
>norvig on Oct 18, 2010 | parent | favorite | on: Ask PG: Lisp vs Python (2010)
>Peter Norvig here. I came to Python not because I thought it was a better/acceptable/pragmatic Lisp, but because it was better pseudocode. Several students claimed that they had a hard time mapping from the pseudocode in my AI textbook to the Lisp code that Russell and I had online. So I looked for the language that was most like our pseudocode, and found that Python was the best match. Then I had to teach myself enough Python to implement the examples from the textbook. I found that Python was very nice for certain types of small problems, and had the libraries I needed to integrate with lots of other stuff, at Google and elsewhere on the net.
>I think Lisp still has an edge for larger projects and for applications where the speed of the compiled code is important. But Python has the edge (with a large number of students) when the main goal is communication, not programming per se.
>In terms of programming-in-the-large, at Google and elsewhere, I think that language choice is not as important as all the other choices: if you have the right overall architecture, the right team of programmers, the right development process that allows for rapid development with continuous improvement, then many languages will work for you; if you don't have those things you're in trouble regardless of your language choice.
Kenny Tilton (smuglispweeny) tells this story, that ced posted a link to in the same discussion:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1803627 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1803627
>ced on Oct 18, 2010 | parent | favorite | on: Ask PG: Lisp vs Python (2010)
>That reminds me of a cool story, in Norvig's talk about Python...
>When he finished Peter [Norvig] took questions and to my surprise called first on the rumpled old guy who had wandered in just before the talk began and eased himself into a chair just across the aisle from me and a few rows up.
>This guy had wild white hair and a scraggly white beard and looked hopelessly lost as if he had gotten separated from the tour group and wandered in mostly to rest his feet and just a little to see what we were all up to. My first thought was that he would be terribly disappointed by our bizarre topic and my second thought was that he would be about the right age, Stanford is just down the road, I think he is still at Stanford -- could it be?
>"Yes, John?" Peter said.
>I won't pretend to remember Lisp inventor John McCarthy's exact words which is odd because there were only about ten but he simply asked if Python could gracefully manipulate Python code as data.
>"No, John, it can't," said Peter and nothing more, graciously assenting to the professor's critique, and McCarthy said no more though Peter waited a moment to see if he would and in the silence a thousand words were said.
http://smuglispweeny.blogspot.com/2008/02/ooh-ooh-my-turn-why-lisp.html http://smuglispweeny.blogspot.com/2008/02/ooh-ooh-my-turn-wh...
- TurboHaskal 7y agoSo basically a race to the bottom in order to communicate with the ALGOL intolerant fanatics.
- dang 7y agoAw, come on. It's a truly beautiful story.
- randomsearch 7y agoWonderful. What a lovely unspoken communication, particularly from Peter.