4 ms·
> Why should Google be required to host data for an enemy state? For the same reason the telephone company isn’t allowed to arbitrarily cancel your phone servi
by sneak 7y ago
> Why should Google be required to host data for an enemy state?
For the same reason the telephone company isn’t allowed to arbitrarily cancel your phone service based on who you choose to call with it.
> YouTube's policies reflect mainstream social mores.
This is precisely the problem. Before, the bar to be silenced was the law; now the bar to be silenced is arbitrary application of “mainstream social mores”. Surely you see the problem there? Have you never derived benefit from media
or creative works that fall outside of “mainstream social mores”?
Even if you haven’t, YouTube’s been deleting videos of war crimes in Syria, making it harder for investigators to track them down and document them. How’s that for “mainstream
social mores”?
- runawaybottle 7y agoAre they deleting them due to graphic explicitness?
- sneak 7y agoDoes it matter? Wouldn’t you want evidence of war crimes to be both graphic and explicit, therefore making it better documentation of a crime and more likely to assist in the prosecution of the criminal(s)?
- NotSammyHagar 7y agoIt does matter why they ban things. They make mistakes too, sometimes put things back. It always matters.
- sneak 7y agoI disagree. The danger is not YouTube or YouTube's policies, whatever they may be at any point in time. The danger is centralized models that permit invisible, sometimes-on, sometimes-off, point-and-click censorship. Those models fail when the military puts a machine gun in a sysadmin's face in wartime, regardless of how good or decent their censorship policies were in peacetime. It's the model that's bad, not YouTube's current policies.
- catalogia 7y agoIf you ban graphic depictions of war, you should ban all depictions of war. Otherwise you are whitewashing war and will warp the general perception of war, quite possibly making war more likely to occur as a result.
- cfmcdonald 7y ago> For the same reason the telephone company isn’t allowed to arbitrarily cancel your phone service based on who you choose to call with it. That's not an analogous case. YouTube is more like a broadcast medium like TV or radio, and those have never been treated as common carriers. A sexy phone call between two people doesn't affect AT&T's reputation, but pornography hosted on YouTube would affect theirs. > This is precisely the problem. Before, the bar to be silenced was the law; now the bar to be silenced is arbitrary application of “mainstream social mores”. Surely you see the problem there? Have you never derived benefit from media or creative works that fall outside of “mainstream social mores”? Being taken down from YouTube does not equate to being silenced. There are many other ways you can express your ideas and opinions, especially if you are willing to do so in non-video form. And the bar to expression on someone else's publishing platform has never only been legal. Every medium has had gatekeepers, generally far more stringent than YouTube's. > Even if you haven’t, YouTube’s been deleting videos of war crimes in Syria, making it harder for investigators to track them down and document them. How’s that for “mainstream social mores”? I don't see why it should be the responsibility of a for-profit entertainment company to provide hosting for war crimes investigators, any more than I would expect Hulu or Netflix to do the same. It would make far more sense to me for journalists or NGOs or governments to provide a place for people to upload their video evidence. There is no need for them to host it publicly, which is the expensive part of YouTube.
- nicbou 7y ago> Being taken down from YouTube does not equate to being silenced. It does not equate to having your free speech violated, but it does equate to being almost silenced. It's akin to a candidate being excluded from the main political debate. If it's not on the main platforms, it's not on people's feeds. It's not shown by recommendation engines. It's not in Google results. You won't hear about it unless you look for it. We can all agree to censor child pornography, but I feel like we're inching closer and closer to censoring merely controversial opinions. My point is that a small group of American companies get an immense amount of influence over mainstream culture, since they control most of the internet traffic. It's legal, but that doesn't make it a good thing.
- NotSammyHagar 7y agoIt's not universal but the people who complain about not liking "social mores" tend to be on the racist, nazi, hate speech spectrum. I'm okay with twitter not giving a platform to people that want to kill people of my religious or sexual persuasion. The behaviors of big companies aren't perfect and they have a lot of conflicts. In the case of this article, the things in the piece in the atlantic he mentions seem both terrible and destructive and also over-reactions by the authors (all the lying facebook posts about covid-19 is no big deal, it's a democratic conspiracy to take our guns, it's going to be solved by applying some drug that is untested for it) do cause damage.
- nicbou 7y agoPart of my point is that "mainstream social mores" aren't and shouldn't be dictated by a group of companies mainly located within a single American state. There are some things that are normal in parts of the world, but unacceptable in America, and vice-versa. There are also some facts different countries disagree with. Should the mainstream internet adopt the American position by default? Should America's terrorists and freedom fighters be Google and Microsoft's too? A large company that recommends content for a billion users holds significant influence, and that power should not be taken lightly.